Forés @ UVPress






         Universitat de València PRESS -UVPress- weblog for research uses

June 22, 2009

00 At Meetings, It’s Mind Your BlackBerry or Mind Your Manners

Filed under: módulo básico — fores @ 10:57 am

At Meetings, It’s Mind Your BlackBerry or Mind Your Manners

Jessica Ebelhar/The New York Times

Nadia Ries Shen, left, using an iPhone at DMD, a marketing company in New York, while Amanda Huber works nearby.

Published: June 21, 2009

For the first half-hour of the meeting, it was hardly surprising to see a potential client fiddling with his iPhone, said Rowland Hobbs, the chief executive of a marketing firm in Manhattan.

At an hour, it seemed a bit much. And after an hour and a half, Mr. Hobbs and his colleagues wondered what the man could possibly be doing with his phone for the length of a summer blockbuster.

Someone peeked over his shoulder. “He was playing a racing game,” Mr. Hobbs said. “He did ask questions, though, peering occasionally over his iPhone.”

But, Mr. Hobbs added, “we didn’t say anything. We still wanted the business.”

As Web-enabled smartphones have become standard on the belts and in the totes of executives, people in meetings are increasingly caving in to temptation to check e-mail, Facebook, Twitter, even (shhh!) ESPN.com.

But a spirited debate about etiquette has broken out. Traditionalists say the use of BlackBerrys and iPhones in meetings is as gauche as ordering out for pizza. Techno-evangelists insist that to ignore real-time text messages in a need-it-yesterday world is to invite peril.

In Hollywood, both the Creative Artists Agency and United Talent Agency ban BlackBerry use at meetings. Tom Golisano, a billionaire and power broker in New York State politics, said last week that he pushed to remove Malcolm A. Smith as the State Senate majority leader after the senator met with him on budget matters in April and spent the time reading e-mail on his BlackBerry.

The phone use has become routine in the corporate and political worlds — and grating to many. A third of more than 5,300 workers polled in May by Yahoo HotJobs, a career research and job listings Web site, said they frequently checked e-mail in meetings. Nearly 20 percent said they had been castigated for poor manners regarding wireless devices.

Despite resistance, the etiquette debate seems to be tilting in the favor of smartphone use, many executives said. Managing directors do it. Summer associates do it. It spans gender and generation, private and public sectors.

A few years ago, only “the investment banker types” would use BlackBerrys in meetings, said Frank Kneller, the chief executive of a company in Elk Grove Village, Ill., that makes water-treatment systems. “Now it’s everybody.” He said that if he spotted 6 of 10 colleagues tapping away, he knew he had to speed up his presentation.

It is routine for Washington officials to bow heads silently around a conference table — not praying — while others are speaking, said Philippe Reines, a senior adviser to Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton. Although BlackBerrys are banned in certain areas of the State Department headquarters for security reasons, their use is epidemic where they are allowed.

“You’ll have half the participants BlackBerrying each other as a submeeting, with a running commentary on the primary meeting,” Mr. Reines said. “BlackBerrys have become like cartoon thought bubbles.”

Some professionals admitted that they occasionally sent mocking commentary about the proceedings, but most insisted that they used smartphones for legitimate reasons: responding to deadline requests, plumbing the Web for data to illuminate an issue under discussion or simply taking notes.

Still, the practice retains the potential to annoy. Joel I. Klein, the New York City schools chancellor, has gained such a reputation for checking his BlackBerry during public meetings that some parents joke that they might as well send him an e-mail message. Few companies have formal policies about smartphone use in meetings, according to Nancy Flynn, the executive director of the ePolicy Institute, a consulting group in Columbus, Ohio. Ms. Flynn tells clients to encourage employees to turn off all devices.

“People mistakenly think that tapping is not as distracting as talking,” she said. “In fact, it can be every bit as much if not more distracting. And it’s pretty insulting to the speaker.”

Still, business can be won or lost, executives say, depending on how responsive you are to an e-mail message. “Clients assume they can get you anytime, anywhere,” said David Brotherton, a media consultant in Seattle. “Consultants who aren’t readily available 24/7 tend to languish.”

Playful electronic bantering can stimulate creativity in meetings, in the view of Josh Rabinowitz, the director of music at Grey Group in New York, an advertising agency. In pitch meetings, Mr. Rabinowitz said, he often traded messages on his Palm Treo — jokes, ideas, questions — with colleagues, “things that you might not say out loud.”

The chatter tends to loosen the proceedings. “It just seems to add to the productive energy,” he said.

But business relationships can be jeopardized. Lori Levine, the founder of Flying Television, a talent-booking agency in Manhattan, said that in an effort to be environmentally sensitive she instructed employees to take notes on BlackBerrys instead of paper during client meetings.

“Then I got a call from a client screaming that our vice president spent an hour on his BlackBerry during a huge meeting,” Ms. Levine recalled. To soothe the client, Ms. Levine read aloud the notes the vice president had taken.

In Dallas, a college student sunk his chance to have an internship at a hedge fund last summer when he pulled out a BlackBerry to look up a fact to help him make a point during his interview, then lingered — momentarily, but perceptibly — to check a text message a friend had sent, said Trevor Hanger, the head of equity trading at the hedge fund, who was helping conduct the interview.

Very few companies have policies on smartphone use in meetings, which leaves it up to employees to feel their way across uncertain terrain.

To Jason Chan, a digital-strategy consultant in Manhattan, different rules apply for in-house meetings (where checking BlackBerrys seems an expression of informal collegiality) and those with clients, where the habit is likely to offend. There is safety in numbers, he added in an e-mail message: “The acceptability of checking devices is proportional to the number of people attending the meeting. The more people there are, the less noticeable your typing will be.”

Beyond practical considerations, there is also the issue of image. In many professional circles, where connections are power, making a show of reaching out to those connections even as co-workers are presenting a spreadsheet presentation seems to have become a kind of workplace boast.

Mr. Brotherton, the consultant, wrote in an e-mail message that it was customary now for professionals to lay BlackBerrys or iPhones on a conference table before a meeting — like gunfighters placing their Colt revolvers on the card tables in a saloon. “It’s a not-so-subtle way of signaling ‘I’m connected. I’m busy. I’m important. And if this meeting doesn’t hold my interest, I’ve got 10 other things I can do instead.’ ”

June 18, 2009

00 Civil-disobedience database: http://BeyondTalk.net

Filed under: módulo básico — fores @ 2:17 pm

June 18, 2009
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

TOP HEADLINE: WORLD LEADERS SIGN PACT TO AVERT CLIMATE DISASTER
Newspaper Ignites Hope, Announces “Civil Disobedience Database”

In a front-page ad in today’s International Herald Tribune, the leaders of the European Union thank the European public for having engaged in months of civil disobedience leading up to the Copenhagen climate conference that will be held this December. “It was only thanks to your massive pressure over the past six months that we could so dramatically shift our climate-change policies…. To those who were arrested, we thank you.” There was only one catch: the paper was fake. Looking exactly like the real thing, but dated December 19th, 2009, a million copies of the fake paper were distributed worldwide by thousands of volunteers in order to show what could be achieved at the Copenhagen climate conference that is scheduled for Dec. 7-18, 2009. (At the moment, the conference is aiming for much more modest cuts, dismissed by leading climate scientists as too little, too late to stave off runaway processes that will lead to millions or even billions of casualties.) The paper describes in detail a powerful (and entirely possible) new treaty to bring carbon levels down below 350 parts per million – the level climate scientists say we need to achieve to avoid climate catastrophe. One article describes how a website, http://BeyondTalk.net, mobilized thousands of people to put their bodies on the line to confront climate change policies – ever since way back in June, 2009. Although the newspaper is a fake (its production and launch were coordinated by Greenpeace), the website is real. Beyondtalk.net is part of a growing network of websites calling for direct action on climate change, building on statements made in recent months by noted political figures. (For example, in September Nobel laureate Al Gore asserted that “we have reached the stage where it is time for civil disobedience to prevent the construction of new coal plants.”) Leading American environmentalist Bill McKibben was enthusiastic about the newspaper’s message and the methods BeyondTalk.net calls for. “We need a political solution grounded in reality – grounded in physics and chemistry. That will only come if we can muster a wide variety of political tactics, including civil disobedience.” “Non-violent civil disobedience has been at the forefront of almost every successful campaign for change,” said Andy Bichlbaum of The Yes Men, who helped write and edit the newspaper and are furnishing the technology for BeyondTalk.net. “Especially in America, and especially today, we need to push our leaders hard to stand up to industry lobbyists and make the sorts of changes we need.” “Roosevelt would never have been able to push through the New Deal if people hadn’t taken to the streets, occupied factories, and demanded it,” noted newspaper writer/editor and University of California professor Lawrence Bogad. Segregation, British rule in India, and apartheid wouldn’t have ended without a lot of people being creatively uncooperative – even if that meant getting arrested. Nonviolent civil disobedience is the bread and butter of progress.” The fake newspaper also has an ad for “Action Offsets,” whereby those who aren’t willing to risk arrest can help those who are. A HOPEFUL NEWS PANDEMIC? Today’s fake International Herald Tribune is part of a rash of recent publications which mimic prominent newspapers. Last November, a fake edition of the New York Times announced that the Iraq War was over. A few days earlier, a hoax USA Today featured the US presidential election result: “Capitalism Wins at the Polls: Anarchy Brewing in the Streets.” And this April 1st, a spoof edition of Germany’s Zeit newspaper triumphantly announced the end of “casino capitalism” and the abolition of poor-country debt. The rash of fakes is likely to continue. “People are going to keep finding ways to get the word out about common-sense solutions those in power say are impossible,” said Kelli Anderson, one of the designers of the fake International Herald Tribune and co-designer (with Daniel Dunnam) of BeyondTalk.net. “We already know what we need to do about climate change,” said Agnes de Rooij of Greenpeace International. “It’s a no-brainer. Reduce carbon emissions, or put the survival of billions of people at risk. If the political will isn’t there now, it’s our duty to inspire it.”

* Civil-disobedience database: http://BeyondTalk.net * PDF of printed newspaper: http://iht.greenpeace.org/todays-paper/ – Online version: http://www.iht-se.com/ * Video: http://iht.greenpeace.org/video/ (coming soon)
* CONTACT:
– The Yes Men, mailto:press@theyesmen.org – Mark Breddy (Greenpeace), mailto:mark.breddy@greenpeace.org, (+32) (0)2 2741 903, (+32) (0)496 15 62 29 (mob.) – Lawrence Bogad, mailto:l.m.bogad@gmail.com, +1-212 300 7943

June 17, 2009

00 Mata una mosca en directo

Filed under: módulo básico — fores @ 5:51 pm

Mata una mosca en directo

¿Quién dijo que Obama no era capaz de matar una mosca?

El presidente de EE.UU. ha dejado claro que no se deja molestar por estos insectos y mucho menos en plena entrevista.

http://www.rtve.es/mediateca/videos/20090617/mata-una-mosca-directo/
526737.shtml?s1=noticias&s2=&s3=

00 INDAGANDO TV –

Filed under: módulo básico — fores @ 9:19 am
Presentación de INDAGANDO TV

Publicado 13/06/2009 19 Comentarios

Invitacion2

INDAGANDO TV se presenta en sociedad de la mano de:
–Vladimir de Semir. Director del Observatorio de la Comunicación Científica de la Universidad Pompeu Fabra.
–Cecilia Cabello. Jefa de Gestión de la Información Científica de la Fundación Española para la Ciencia y la Tecnología (FECYT).

La fecha: Martes, 16 de junio. 11:00 horas.
El lugar: Teatro Alcázar. Alcalá, 20, 1º planta. Madrid.
View Larger Map

19 Respuestas a “Presentación de INDAGANDO TV”


  1. 1 Jose Samar 14/06/2009 a las 14:52

    Mi mas sincera enhorabuena por este proyecto, que ya era hora de una tv española dedicada a la ciencia e inovacion. un saludo y suerte!.

  2. 2 Vazquez 16/06/2009 a las 6:39

    Esta es una notica increible, estamos todos de enhorabuena

  3. 3 Icaro 16/06/2009 a las 7:58

    Os llevo esperando desde que oí de vosotros, contad conmigo como usuario diario. Incluso si no puedo veros os tendré de fondo siempre en el ordenador!

    ¡Enhorabuena por el proyecto!

  4. 4 Javier 16/06/2009 a las 8:41

    Por fin!

    La TV debe tener un fin educativo y de mejora de las personas además del entretenimiento.Estamos saturados de tele basura y tele politica.

    Buena idea,
    gracias

  5. 5 Garcia S. 16/06/2009 a las 9:49

    Hola:
    Muy buena idea de vuestra TV cientifica. Servirá para que podamos aprender muchas cosas que con mucha frecuencia ignoramos.
    En mi caso personal este tipo de TV si que me gusta.
    Enhorabuena, os deseo de verdad todo el exito del mundo.
    Saludos cordiales.

  6. 6 6cR 16/06/2009 a las 10:34

    Felicidades por estrenaros y ánimo, ya era hora de un canal dedicado a la ciencia, aquí tenéis otro teleespectador.

  7. 7 Javier Muñoz 16/06/2009 a las 11:40

    El proyecto tiene una pinta excelente, me ha gustado mucho la presentación de hoy, mucho ánimo y suerte!

  8. 8 Francisco Bas 16/06/2009 a las 11:59

    En epoca de crisis es una gran noticia iniciativas emprendedoras de valor añadido como esta.

    Os deseo lo mejor como emprendedores digitales, sois un equipo multidisciplinar y os avala el Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación a través de la Fecyt en donde trabaja gente muy seria y cualificada.

    Animo y Mucha suerte,

    Un saludo,

    Paco Bas
    (basmaestrefrancisco@gmail.com)

  9. 9 marcelino1944 16/06/2009 a las 13:04

    Me parece fenomenal.Menos mal que la televisión se pone de manera clara a favor de la ciencia. Somos muchos los que deseábamos ver en un canal un seguimiento de todos los avances de la ciencia, de los temas de mantenimiento del medio ambiente y de el tratamiento informativo asimilado a la ciencia…Os deseamos una trayectoria exitosa y larga. Salu2.

  10. 10 Diego Fernández 16/06/2009 a las 15:01

    Os deseo mucho éxito.
    Saludos,

    Diego

  11. 11 Uranus 16/06/2009 a las 16:59

    Les deseo muchos éxitos, por fin un canal dedicado a todos los curiosos como nosotros. Ahora no tenemos excusa para no aprender.

  12. 12 Horacio Salazar 16/06/2009 a las 17:06

    Muchas felicidades. Iniciativas así necesitamos por montones, para disipar las sombras y alegrar el intelecto.

  13. 13 ahskar 16/06/2009 a las 18:47

    Es un proyecto verdaderamente prometedor. Mis mejores deseos.

    Ánimo y adelante.

  14. 14 Rosa 16/06/2009 a las 19:48

    Enhorabuena , que tengais mucha suerte y exito. La mirare frecuentemente.

  15. 15 lopersonalespolitico 16/06/2009 a las 20:11

    ha sido una pena no poder asistir a la presentación. Espero que tengais mucho éxito.

  16. 16 ALFREDO 16/06/2009 a las 20:33

    Sobre todo me apetece y me gusta que haya cosas en ingles.

    Enhorabuena.

  17. 17 Carlos ERnesto Cornejo Flores 16/06/2009 a las 20:59

    Hola Amigos:
    Les evío un cordial saludo desde Lima-Perú.
    La verdad que tener un canal de internet de información exclusivamente científica es verdaderamente importante. Me apunto desde ya en ser un “internetvidente”.
    Una pregunta: Tendrán programas como REDES de TVE, que entra a temas científicos y filosóficos, de una manera muy amena y clara.
    Bueno slo me queda desearles todos los éxitos, que en realidad doy po descintado que lo tendrán. Me encargaré de difundir su dirección de su WEb.
    Saludos!

    Carlos E. Cornejo Flores

  18. 18 Oscar 17/06/2009 a las 1:37

    Mis mas sinceras felicitaciones. Los que somos adictos a la información en ciencias estabamos esperando algi así. Muchisima merde y fortuna.

  19. 19 indagandotv 17/06/2009 a las 7:11

    Gracias a todo el mundo. Los comentarios son un inyección de optimismo para todo el equipo de INDAGANDO TV.




Daoíz, 12, 2º izda. 28004 Madrid (Spain) ********* +34 91 521 96 87 ********* ********* info@indagando.tv *********

June 14, 2009

00 Why I went on “The O’Reilly Factor”

Filed under: módulo básico — fores @ 12:13 pm

Joan Walsh

Friday June 12, 2009 19:13 EDT

Why I went on “The O’Reilly Factor”

(UPDATED after The O’Reilly Factor aired)

I was surprised when so many people I respect told me not to appear on “The O’Reilly Factor.” I’d attacked Bill O’Reilly for his jihad against Dr. George Tiller, and he asked me on to discuss my “accusations.” I thought that was fair. I could explain my point of view to his face; to say no felt like being a punk. But smart and supportive friends, family, co-workers, Twitterers and media stars all over the country reached out and suggested I skip it.

I thought about it, but not for long. I like doing TV. I’m not terrible at it. I criticized him, I should have the guts to repeat it to his face. I also need to say that when I announced I’d said yes, every one of the doubters, and more, sent me great advice and good wishes. (Thanks to Media Matters who, unbidden, just had staff start sending me clips to watch, about O’Reilly’s lies. And if you’re not on Twitter, well, Twitter rocked for me.) My daughter coached me; so did my litigator ex-husband, so did my friend and Salon co-conspirator Kerry Lauerman. It takes a village to debate Bill O’Reilly!

His producers also helped by doing that thing they do: “Hey, Bill really respects you for coming on the show! He wants to have a conversation! It’ll be fine!” (And they promoted my appearance on the show by identifying me on the Web site as “Joan Walsh of Slate.com.”)

Well, it was so not fine. I think the high or low point was when he shrieked at me, “You have blood on your hands!” At one point he also either told me to “Shut up” or “Be quiet,” I can’t remember. (If I’m wrong about that, when I see the clip, I’ll correct it. UPDATE: Actually, he shouted “Stop talking!”) He called me “vile.” I think I said he was vile, too. There were a couple of “I know you are but what am I?” moments that I’m not totally proud of. It was a kaleidoscopic nightmare, a TV acid trip, and I don’t do acid. It almost seems like O’Reilly does, but I don’t think so. The man is driven by demons. God bless him and save him.

Now all I can really do is wait for the edited, taped version to air at 5 p.m. PT/8 p.m. ET. And as one media friend, urging me not to do it (while sending me great newsy tidbits of O’Reillyisms that I used), explained, I’m not likely to feel good about it: “This is not about debate nor offering an alternate point of view. This is the Harlem Globetrotters, and if you’re too good to be the Washington Generals, he will make you into them by editing and lying.” I grew up loving the Harlem Globetrotters, so man, that really hurt.

But actually I can do one more thing besides wait: I can lay out what I remember saying (I should have taped it) so we can compare the final, edited show. Which may differ significantly, or it may not.

(UPDATE: I’m going to give “The O’Reilly Factor” credit here: The show was pretty much how it went. Exactly how it went, as I can recall. I will post it later)

First of all, he wasn’t Genial Bill O’Reilly, grateful to have a left-wing critic to spar with. From his opening words he was curt. He instructed me to answer his very simple questions directly. (I got a Guantánamo kind of vibe; do I have to?) And basically, like at Guantánamo, he just asked the same loaded question over and over seeking the same answer: Do I think there should be any protections for late-term fetuses?

I started calm. I acknowledged that late-term abortion is the most angst-producing of all reproductive rights issues, but it only accounts for 1 percent of the abortion in the U.S. — and most of the women who do it have heartbreaking reasons. I tried to make the point, repeatedly, that it’s sad that there are two versions of reality on this: the O’Reilly version, where Tiller is a killer, and worse, a profiteer, and the feminist version, where Tiller is a hero, because he performed this legal but rare procedure in dire circumstances for women who were diagnosed late in pregnancy with aggressive breast cancer; for a 9-year-old girl, raped by her stepfather, who didn’t know she was pregnant; for women who found late in their pregnancies that their babies had brain and heart deformities that would kill them early in their lives, but not without a lot of surgery and suffering.

If I’m sorry I did the show — and I’m not yet sure I am — it’s only because of one thing: He used me to try Dr. Tiller again, postmortem. He brought out uncorroborated stories he claimed he’d never shown before: a 13-year-old girl (I couldn’t see her or verify her story) who claimed Tiller killed her baby and had her deliver it in a toilet. He featured psychiatrists who from a distance challenged Tiller’s findings that women were in danger if they delivered late-term babies. He continued his “profiteering” charges, claiming that Tiller charged $6,000 per abortion; I said, “Bill, you’ve always said it was $5,000, so that’s interesting! And I know he did some for less and pro-bono.” I think that’s when he cut me off and denied that, but I’m not sure. But, jeez, it did get worse. He also accused me of calling him “a vile accomplice” to Scott Roeder, and I jumped in, “I called you vile, but I never called you an accomplice.” On both these recent shootings I’ve made clear the responsible parties are the shooters, I told him. Woo-hoo! We’ll see if it airs.

What else do I remember? It’s getting lost in a haze of post-adrenaline marveling at the surreality of the whole thing! I told him that he was within his rights to think late-term abortion should be illegal, and that he should work to make it so. But right now it’s legal. I compared his position to that of gun opponents. We can legally, under various circumstances, own guns. But some gun opponents would like most guns, especially handguns, to be illegal. What if those folks started a crusade against gun dealers, maybe picking out one in particular, saying he had “blood on his hands,” “he should be stopped,” all the O’Reilly Tiller quotes?

Sadly, Bill cut me off and derided that comparison as stupid, and went back to asking me his one apparent question: if late-term fetuses deserved any protection. I hemmed and hawed — I hate that I did that, but as I said, though I’m ardently pro-choice, I’m Irish Catholic, and I was raised to think abortion was wrong — but in the end, I support the law as it is. My overriding principle is that I believe this very tough choice can only belong to women. It might have been then he said, “You have blood on your hands!” Not sure; we’ll watch the video.

Shortly after that he started badgering me about whether I’d call Dr. Tiller a hero, and I strangely bobbed and weaved until reality beckoned, and I said, “Yes, he’s a hero!” Well, it was over then. He had what he wanted. His audience could see what I was (you fill in the blanks there). I believe he repeated that I have blood on my hands, but I’m not sure. I might have said he has blood on his hands. It wasn’t pretty.

At the end, I threw several things at him I expect will be cut, but I’d be thrilled to be wrong. (UPDATE: I was wrong.) They are all factually correct. I mentioned O’Reilly’s attacks on liberals like Rosie O Donnell, Janeane Garofalo and Michael Moore for whipping up possible violence against the right. I also talked about O’Reilly’s tragic previous connection to the slaughter of liberals, almost a year ago, by wingnut Jim David Adkisson. It’s chilling. Just like Scott Roeder, unbelievably — is there really a God? I believe there is but sometimes there’s precious little proof — Adkisson shot his prey in a church. He’d railed against “liberals,” repeatedly — and police found the collected works of Bill O’Reilly, Sean Hannity and Michael Savage in his house.

O’Reilly shut up as I made those last two sets of points, and so if I had to bet what would be cut, it would be that. Oh well, I tried.

Watch O’Reilly yourselves tonight, and weigh in here. Maybe he’ll run the uncut version! If he does, I’ll apologize. In the meantime, I’ll leave you with the probably really pathetic uncut version of the “Talking Points” I had prepared for O’Reilly, almost none of which got used. I’m a little embarrassed because they make me look like a liberal Pollyanna, a lamb ready to lie down with the lion — to be eaten! Live and learn.

Thanks for having me Bill, maybe this is the first step in what I talked about on my blog: Dialing down the extreme rhetoric and hate. If we can sit here and talk calmly, maybe we’ll set a good example for others.

My basic issue is that we are a nation of laws, and abortion is legal. Late-term abortion is legal. It’s heart-wrenching, and it gets a lot of attention, but we should note that only 1 percent of all abortions in the U.S. are after 21 weeks.

What bothers me, Bill, is that you started a crusade against a doctor who was doing his legal job. You have an enormous audience, the top show in cable, and I think you have a responsibility to think about the impact of your words. And on the issue of abortion, there’s a terrible history of violence in this country. At least four doctors have been killed, multiple clinics have been bombed. Dr. Tiller himself had been shot twice in 1993, Bill. His clinic had been bombed and repeatedly vandalized. He was in clear danger, and yet you attacked him, 42 times over four years, and at least 24 times you called him a “baby killer.” (That’s from the nonpartisan fact-checker Politifact.) You accused him of “murder,” “you said he had blood on his hands,” you said he “had to be stopped,” and the people of Kansas were a “disgrace” for not stopping him — even though he was acquitted by the courts multiple times of various legal charges against him.

I know you have decried vigilante justice, and I believe you mean that, but we saw vigilante justice in this case. Every time I’ve written about it, Bill, I’ve been sure to say you did not cause it. The only person responsible at this point is Scott Roeder, unless we find he had formal accomplices, no word of that so far. I’m just saying that in the wake of Dr. Tiller’s tragic murder in a church, no less, you might have expressed some remorse. Instead, you turned your show into a pity party, and made yourself the victim, and honestly, Bill, I don’t often agree with you, but I thought you were better than that. I was disappointed. That’s what I said.

If you really wanted to be fair and balanced, you could have said in every segment, “Some call him Tiller the baby killer, others call him Dr. Tiller, the hero, because he has performed this legal but rare procedure for women in dire circumstances: Women who were diagnosed with breast cancer; for a 9-year-old girl raped by her stepfather, who didn’t know she was pregnant, for women who found late in their pregnancies that their babies had brain and heart deformities that would kill them early in their lives, but not without a lot of surgery and suffering. The two sides probably can’t meet, Bill, but there is another side. And again, only 1 percent of abortions are late-term abortions, taking place after 21 weeks. One percent, Bill.

I am a pro-choice Irish Catholic. I have agonized for years, but I am pro-choice. I have one Catholic aunt who works at Planned Parenthood, escorting women past clinic protesters. I have another Catholic aunt who loved Obama’s economic policies but couldn’t vote for him because of abortion. I love them both, and they love me. After prayer and soul searching I came to believe the only answer is that this is the woman’s choice. We live in a pluralistic country, Bill, people disagree. People don’t agree on when life begins. They’re not sure the right course here. So abortion stays legal. People stay uncomfortable with it, for sure. It’s true. But it is legal, and if you don’t think it should be legal, work within our great democracy to change the laws.

Finally, Bill, you yourself have demonized folks on the left for saying things that you believe could lead to violence: You’ve railed against Hollywood, you’ve railed against Rosie O Donnell and Janeane Garofalo and Michael Moore for saying things you believed were irresponsible and could foment violence. Just last month, you criticized Google Maps for making it easy to find the homes of people who gave money to Prop. 8, because they might get hurt. Antiabortion crazies regularly published the address of Dr. Tiller’s home, church and clinic. So I think you’re inconsistent on these issues, you call out the left if you think their speech could endanger conservatives, or just Americans, but I’m a pariah for raising the same questions about your Tiller speech? I don’t understand it, but I hope we’ve improved the terms of the debate tonight.

Epic fail! What was I thinking? I’ll be back after I watch the final clip with a reaction.

Oh, and while you’re waiting: Media Matters has clips of O’Reilly calling Dr. Tiller a “baby killer,” without any attribution, which he denies doing

Update: Watch the segment here.

— Joan Walsh
« Previous Page — Next Page »

WPMU Theme pack by WPMU-DEV.