Forés @ UVPress






         Universitat de València PRESS -UVPress- weblog for research uses

March 18, 2012

05 Busting Mr. Daisey

Filed under: economía,future,módulo básico,politics & literature — fores @ 11:30 am
Opinion

Jack Shafer

Follow Jack Shafer

Busting Mr. Daisey

By Jack Shafer
March 16, 2012

This week, the highly regarded public radio show This American Life learned a lesson that many journalists, including me, have learned the hard way: It’s almost impossible for an editor to fact-check a contributor who lies.

The show, hosted by Ira Glass, just retracted its Jan. 6, 2012, episode, “Mr. Daisey Goes to the Apple Factory,” adapted from Mike Daisey’s popular one-man show, The Agony and the Ecstasy of Steve Jobs, which is about working conditions in a Chinese factory that makes Apple products.

Daisey’s deceptions were uncovered by Rob Schmitz, a China-based reporter for Marketplace. This American Life will air an hourlong explanation and re-examination this weekend, featuring both Glass and Daisey, about the circumstances behind the retraction. Glass and the show are to be commended for their quick response, and everybody who cares about real journalism owes a debt of gratitude to Schmitz.

We don’t yet know all the lies Daisey told Glass and the listeners of This American Life, but here’s a taste. In the Jan. 6 segment, Daisey said:

The problem is that n-hexane is a potent neurotoxin, and all these people have been exposed. Their hands shake uncontrollably. Most of them can’t even pick up a glass.

I talk to people whose joints in their hands have disintegrated from working on the line, doing the same motion hundreds and hundreds of thousands of times. It’s like carpal tunnel on a scale we can scarcely imagine. And you need to know that this is eminently avoidable. If these people were rotated monthly on their jobs, this would not happen.

When a doubting Schmitz contacted Daisey’s translator, he learned that the artist hadn’t talked to workers poisoned with hexane. We have now learned that he met people who knew people who had been poisoned. So why did he lie? Because, Daisey said, “I wanted to tell a story that captured the totality of my trip.”

On his own website, Daisey offers this larger rationalization, which deserves complete quotation.

I stand by my work. My show is a theatrical piece whose goal is to create a human connection between our gorgeous devices and the brutal circumstances from which they emerge. It uses a combination of fact, memoir, and dramatic license to tell its story, and I believe it does so with integrity. Certainly, the comprehensive investigations undertaken by the New York Times and a number of labor rights groups to document conditions in electronics manufacturing would seem to bear this out.

What I do is not journalism. The tools of the theater are not the same as the tools of journalism. For this reason, I regret that I allowed This American Life to air an excerpt from my monologue. This American Life is essentially a journalistic — not a theatrical — enterprise, and as such it operates under a different set of rules and expectations. But this is my only regret. I am proud that my work seems to have sparked a growing storm of attention and concern over the often appalling conditions under which many of the high-tech products we love so much are assembled in China.

This grander explanation, which invokes the liberties one can take with the truth working inside the theater, skirts the question of why he lied to Glass, who obviously trusted him to tell the truth. Daisey’s only stated “regret” here is that he allowed the program to air part of his monologue. Meanwhile, the New York Times has excised a paragraph from an Oct. 6, 2011, op-ed he wrote, because “Questions have been raised about the truth of a paragraph in the original version of this article that purported to talk about conditions at Apple’s factory in China.” As I write, surely others are scouring his book, 21 Dog Years: Doing Time @ Amazon.com (2002) for fabrications.

Perhaps Daisey will offer more complete contrition on This American Life‘s hair-shirt edition this weekend, but I doubt it. Liars come up with all sorts of justifications when caught. In Daisey’s case, he claims “dramatic license” gives him the right to lie to Glass. Other apprehended fibbers working in the journalistic arena have blamed booze, drugs, madness, overwork, bad fact-checking, notes got lost, wrong version got sent to the editor, or family problems.

I’m still waiting for somebody who got caught lying while practicing journalism to say why he did it. I have my theory: 1) They lie because they don’t have the time or talent to tell the truth, 2) they lie because they think they can get away with it, and 3) they lie because they have no respect for the audience they claim to want to enlighten. That would be an ideal subject for a one-man theatrical performance.

(Afterthought, March 17: If this piece interested you, allow me to direct you to my piece from earlier in the week about the fabulisms in Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood.)

******

Send scripts to Shafer.Reuters@gmail.com. My Twitter feed tells the truth. Sign up for email notifications of new Shafer columns (and other occasional announcements). Subscribe to this RSS feed for new Shafer columns and subscribe to this hand-built RSS feed for corrections to my column.

PHOTO: Mike Daisey appearing on MSNBC’s The Ed Show.

Mar 16, 2012
6:28 pm EDT

Mr. Shafer, please also bust NYT for their Apple Foxconn story.

Did you guys miss the NPR retraction of Mike Daisey Apple Foxconn story? It’s full of fabrication.

NYT never disclosed the fact their primary source, China Labor Watch, is a US government funded dissident group that is financially beholden to US foreign policy interest.

China Labor Watch’s financial connection with US Congress is open information. National Endowment for Democracy grant publication clearly states the grants given to CLW.

Posted by ChasL | Report as abusive
Mar 16, 2012
10:25 pm EDT

So what are the facts about the working conditions at Foxconn? Can Mr. Shafer contribute to the discussion?

Posted by Aretherefacts | Report as abusive
Mar 16, 2012
10:50 pm EDT

Daisey’s monologue may be “theatre” but he gave interviews where he wasn’t peforming, and he misled people in those interviews.

Posted by KenG_CA | Report as abusive
Mar 16, 2012
11:55 pm EDT

It is not the responsibility of the playwright to be factually accurate. To hold Mr. Daisey to the standards of someone like Stephen Glass at The New Republic is ludicrous. Journalistic standards do not and should not apply to theater. Almost no play would be left standing.

Many audience members and journalists have claimed that they were falsely led to perceive Mr. Daisey’s accounts as fact. Are plays now to be fact-checked and playwrights treated as journalists? Shall we exhume Shakespeare’s corpse, reanimate him and demand to know why he presented Richard III as hunchback when it wasn’t factually accurate?

This debacle has made it very clear that a great many people have utterly no idea what purpose the theater serves and what it is that we actually do. No wonder that funding for the arts in the United States is so appalling and the majority of our national theatrical output is swill.

Mr. Daisey has rightly pointed out that he is attempting to communicate the essential truth of the situation, which he has done in all of his work with great success. Any appearance/writing by a playwright in Op-Ed, television, radio, et al. should be viewed primarily as publicity for their play, not as journalism. Organizations like The New York Times and This American Life should note that if they want to fact-check a play, they should not cite the proverbial horse’s mouth as a source.

Complain all you like, but there’s blood on our hands. For example, I just typed this on my iMac.

Posted by SethDuerr | Report as abusive
Mar 17, 2012
12:24 am EDT

More hard evidence of America’s deteriorated democracy & and American media’s credibility.

Posted by GMavros | Report as abusive
Mar 17, 2012
5:01 am EDT

Limbaugh, Brietbart, Beck, Daisey? Oh heck, they’re just “entertainers”… nobody takes them seriously.

And I would laugh at what they, except for the blatant attempt to defraud people. And, mostly out of hatred.

Posted by nieldevi | Report as abusive
Mar 17, 2012
6:42 am EDT

We can’t wait to hear the Apple fanboys claim vindication…

We’ve been waiting for that other plump Mike, the Moore guy, whom we’re now going to start calling “Smart Mike” to distinguish him from this guy, to get on the Apple story like he did the Nike story. Because as much as he’s a self-promoter, he gets it right. And it’s a story that doesn’t need a break in momentum.

Watching Daisy stammer in the first part of his CNBC interview would have made any good detective a bit worried about his veracity. Live and learn. He’ll no doubt write a book about it next.

Posted by WeWereWallSt | Report as abusive
Mar 17, 2012
11:10 am EDT

Jack, your theory needs a fourth leg, though it doesn’t apply in the case of Daisey, since his story was pre-packaged. But more and more in these “narrative nonfiction” days, editors want a moral along with the pitch. It’s not enough to say, “I know there’s something there–let me figure it out.” Editors want conclusions before they’ll take a pitch, and the temptation for journalists is to offer those, then mash all unwieldy material into that frame. The urge to oversimplify and find a sermonizing arc is ultimately everyone’s fault, since readers and listeners reward these stories the most. And as we’ve seen from this piece and the Kony nightmare, those tendencies are worsened x10 when the story happens abroad.

Posted by Esmerelds | Report as abusive
Mar 17, 2012
1:11 pm EDT

@SethDuerr (and those making similar arguments): It’s true that a playwright is not obligated to be factually accurate when writing a play, but in this case Daisey wasn’t writing a play. He was adapting his play for This American Life, on which he was fully aware that it would be presented as the truth. Reading Daisey’s “apology” makes it sound like he just realized that This American Life was a journalism program and that its viewers understand everything on the show to be true (as in factually correct, not “true” as Daisey is accustomed to interpret the word).

But this isn’t the case, because Daisey lied to Ira Glass and the staff of TAL and actively sought to cover up the parts of his show that were fabrications. There is no excuse for this. I guess he sees this act as another part of his selfless, noble quest to right the wrongs in this world, but I can’t help but see it as the act of a immoral man who is more concerned with his own publicity than his own integrity or the reputation of Glass and TAL.

Daisey could have either told Glass that parts of his story weren’t entirely true, so TAL could have aired a disclaimer, or they could have modified his story to take out the untrue parts. Instead, he chose to lie. And now he’s only made it worse with his self-righteous, weaselly non-apology.

Posted by TheDollarGame | Report as abusive


No Comments »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

WPMU Theme pack by WPMU-DEV.