Forés @ UVPress






         Universitat de València PRESS -UVPress- weblog for research uses

February 8, 2013

07 Drones, US Propaganda and Imperial Hubris

Filed under: archivo personal,Holístico,módulo básico,política — fores @ 6:38 am

Middle East Research and Information Project

Drones, US Propaganda and Imperial Hubris

by Sarah Waheed | published January 25, 2013 – 10:38am

Pakistanis should be more supportive of having their national sovereignty violated by Americans, according to US-based political scientists who favor drone strikes in Pakistan. I am trying hard not make this sound like an Onion article, even though it does.

In a January 23 article for The Atlantic, professors Christine Fair, Karl Kaltenthaler and William J. Miller argue that Pakistani opposition to drone strikes is not as widespread as previously claimed, and that the US government should take steps to convert Pakistanis to the official US view on drone strikes:

[The US] must draw to its side the large swath of the population that doesn’t even know about the program. This may mean using radio, non-cable TV (including local Pakistani networks) or even hyper-local media such as SMS — and it means doing so in Urdu and perhaps other vernacular languages.

This is some of the most propagandistic writing in support of President Barack Obama’s targeted kill lists to date. It takes a serious level of arrogance to suggest inserting a US policy stance into the output of another country’s media. It apparently also requires misrepresenting data related to the numbers of Pakistanis who support drone strikes and using faulty methodology.

The truth is that the majority of Pakistanis do not support having the sovereignty of Pakistan violated. Even the Pakistani government objects. Maybe that is because, to borrow Obama’s words, “There’s no country on earth that would tolerate missiles raining down on its citizens from outside its borders.” Without even once trying to explain why the use of drones in Pakistan is necessary, the Atlantic article basically claims that Pakistanis want drone attacks, but that not enough Pakistanis want them badly enough.

According to Fair et al, this is because not enough Pakistanis know that having their children, their houses and their funeral processions blown up by US drone strikes is actually a good thing for them. The reason they don’t know is because they don’t know English:

In a developing country like Pakistan, the greater the level of education, the more likely they would be able to read English and have the wealth and knowledge to access the Internet and other sources of electronic media…. The average Pakistani…only has access to Urdu-language media…. There is a pervasive anti-drone discourse in Pakistan’s boisterous Urdu-language media, which tends to be more jingoistic. More educated Pakistanis have access to more nuanced reporting about the drones and the terrorism issue in Pakistan. While the reporting on drones may still be relatively negative, there is some positive commentary in the English-language press in Pakistan. The more educated are also more likely to read stories in sources that address the terrorism problem arising from the tribal areas. Drones in those sources are presented not just as a reason many Pakistanis are killed, but also as one possible tool to fight a very serious security threat.

Note the slippage between “more educated,” “English-language press,” “access to the Internet” and “more nuanced reporting.” This passage implies that Pakistanis who rely on the Urdu-language press are dumb and getting dumber, but that people who read English are inherently more critical thinkers. Why? Because the English media in Pakistan at times includes positive commentary about drone strikes! Congratulations: You just won the critical thinker award in Pakistan, for being uncritical of US drone strike policy.

Now, if only more Pakistanis could think like this. Maybe more of them will think this way, if Pakistanis get daily text messages to their phone, informing them that terrorism is a problem in their country. Oh, but make sure to do it in Urdu. Apparently, they didn’t get the memo. With a strange combination of naivete and hubris, Fair et al propose that the US must try to win the hearts and minds of Pakistanis. It is hard to see how this is possible, as Pakistan has been exempted from the new drone manual that sets the rules governing targeted killings. In any case, winning hearts and minds, for Fair et al, does not mean stop killing Pakistanis. It means convincing the Pakistanis to get on board with the killing, by getting the Urdu (and other regional) language media to propagate the official US view on drone strikes.

As it happens, having an English-language imperial power wanting to screw around with one’s language and (political) education is not really a new thing for South Asians. Fair et al are not all that creative in that way.

Just for fun, let’s go back 180 years to see what an influential Englishman had to say:

All parties seem to be agreed on one point, that the dialects commonly spoken among the natives of this part of India contain neither literary nor scientific information, and are moreover, so poor and rude that, until they are enriched from some other quarter, it will not be easy to translate any valuable work into them. It seems to be admitted on all sides, that the intellectual improvement of those classes of the people who have the means of pursuing higher studies can at present be effected only by means of some language not vernacular amongst them. We have to educate a people who cannot at present be educated by means of their mother tongue. We must teach them some foreign language. The claims of our own language, it is hardly necessary to recapitulate. It stands preeminent even among the languages of the West.

That was T. B. Macaulay — who knew no “Oriental” languages to speak of — addressing British officials in a Minute on Indian Education (1833) about how Indians ought to be educated under their rule. In 1837, Persian was replaced by English as the language of governance in India. To secure a high-paying job, Indians had to know English. And to study English, an Indian had to be from those “classes of the people who have the means of pursuing higher studies.” In the nineteenth century, Indians began to debate among themselves whether they wanted such an education for themselves or for their children, but that is another story.

Being the “culturally sensitive” rulers that they were, the British decided that they should be able speak to their Indian subordinates in their own language. So they came up with grammar books and dictionaries to teach themselves how to say “Get me my shoes” and “Hurry up!” to their Indian servants. These books made it possible for the British to standardize and index terminology for official use. Persian was also replaced at the lower levels of judicial and revenue administration, but here, it was replaced by Indian vernacular languages like Urdu.

Back then, Urdu was also called “Hindustani” (and a bunch of other things), but there, too, the British brought their own assumptions to bear on vernacular education policies for Indians. The Indians just did not know what was good for them, the British kept insisting.

Since the British saw Indians as groups of “Hindus” and “Muslims,” they also began to describe religion as a marker of linguistic difference, which is part of the reason why a shared north Indian language ended up getting divided into Hindi (for Hindus) and Urdu (for Muslims). Sometimes, when the British were in a bit of a Victorian mood, they tried to get Urdu poets to stop composing “obscene” poems about wine and women and write about sledding at Christmas instead. But I digress.

A class divide quickly emerged between vernacular-educated Indians and the English-speaking elites. An English-speaking Indian elite was desirable for officials like Macaulay, who needed “a class of persons Indian in blood and color, but English in taste and manners” as a buffer between themselves and the masses. A hundred years or so later, this stratagem backfired when new generations of this class of Indians began clamoring for their rights, and talking back to the English, in English. South Asians eventually won their independence from British rule — but only after paying a hefty price in the partition of India along religious lines for the first time in history, a division that cost millions of lives and would scar the region forever. Pakistan inherited the messy frontiers of the old imperial order.

What Fair et al are proposing is to educate Pakistanis about what the US thinks is good for them. For these political scientists, the right kind of Pakistani possesses the right kind of knowledge: Drone strikes are for his or her own good. It is with US intervention, through drones and propaganda, that Pakistanis can be saved from their backwardness, their tribalism, their Islamism, their nationalism — in short, themselves. But this kind of imperial experiment has been tried out before in South Asia. How about trying something new for a change?

  • Tweet this Share on Facebook Print this Email this

Latest Issue

Winter 2012
Copyright © Middle East Research and Information Project.  All Rights reserved.

Middle East Research and Information Project
1344 T St. NW #1
Washington, DC 20009

February 5, 2013

07 Alberto García-Alix: “La fotografía alimenta mi deseo de vivir”

ENTREVISTA CON UN ICONO DE LA FOTOGRAFÍA

Alberto García-Alix: “La fotografía alimenta mi deseo de vivir”

El fotógrafo expone en La Virreina una selección de sus mejores autorretratos

Martes, 5 de febrero del 2013 – 11:08h.

El fotógrafo Alberto García-Alix presenta la exposición ‘Autorretrato’ en La Virreina, Centre de la imatge. Podrá verse hasta el 5 de mayo. MÒNICA TUDELA Foto: J. CORTADELLAS

MÒNICA TUDELA / BarcelonaNo le gusta demasiado mostrarse en público, ni las entrevistas ni que le hagan fotos. Pero el fotógrafo Alberto García-Alix (León, 1956) tiene que dejar de lado estos días su timidez porque anda presentando en Barcelona la exposición ‘Autorretrato’, una selección de fotografías en las que puede leerse su vida en imágenes. La muestra puede verse en La Virreina, Centre de la imatge, desde este miércoles y hasta el 5 de mayo. “Me da un poco de vergüenza esta exposición de autorretratos. Me da mucho pudor”, confesa Alix. “Hay veces que me miro y no me reconozco. Me pregunto: ¿este soy yo?”, añade.

García-Alix, Premio Nacional de Fotografía en 1999 y Premio Photoespaña 2012, lleva más de 35 años con la cámara a cuestas. Toda una carrera fotográfica que a veces ha sido calificada de tormentosa pero que, en cualquier caso, ha configurado una mirada única del artista y su época. “La fotografía la empleo como un alimento personal. La palabra alimento no es solamente de comida. Alimenta mi deseo de vivir, de mirar”, cuenta el artista.

Como paso previo a la exposición, Alberto García-Alix ofrece esta tarde una conferencia en el Institut d’Estudis Fotogràfics de Catalunya (19.00 horas) ante estudiantes y amantes de la imagen. “Doy pocos cursos o encuentros con público. Cuando los doy, lo único que puedo hacer es procurar es transmitir la pasión de amar la fotografía”, dice.

Noticias relacionadas

http://www.elperiodico.com/es/noticias/ocio-y-cultura/entrevista-fotografo-alberto-garcia-alix-2310961?utm_source=rss-noticias&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=portada

García-Alix, desnudo en cuerpo y alma

La Virreina de Barcelona expone 76 imágenes protagonizadas por el fotógrafo y su mundo

Barcelona 5 FEB 2013 – 14:03 CET
‘Autorretrato en Budapest’ (2000). / Alberto García-Alix

“No me gusta fotografiarme, me da pudor”. Pese a eso, son pocas las imágenes realizadas por el fotógrafo Alberto García-Alix (León, 1956) en las que él no sea el protagonista. Él o su mundo. Su cuerpo, su rostro, su sombra, su habitación, sus amantes, sus animales, como la gata Nicotina, o los lugares en los que ha estado, se convierten en objetivo de la nada inocente cámara de este autor autodidacta. “Hay algo masoquista y cruel en mi insistencia en verme, pues me ha convertido en un rabioso exhibicionista de mi tiempo y mi angustia”, reconoce el propio fotógrafo. Se podría decir que toda su obra, en conjunto, es un gran autorretrato. Autorretrato Alberto García-Alix es el nombre de la exposición que inaugura este miércoles La Virreina Centre de la Imagen de Barcelona con 76 imágenes, algunas de ellas inéditas, en las que García-Alix aparece a lo largo de tres décadas en cuerpo y en alma, en persona o representado por sus objetos.

Sin ser un recorrido cronológico vemos a García-Alix desde su juventud hasta la madurez, comprobando su evolución física y la de su mirada como fotógrafo. Desde los primeros autorretratos de los años 70, más ingenuos, sus amigos y sus aficiones. “No hay una mirada inocente y espontánea, siempre hay malicia e intencionalidad en la mirada”, explicó el fotógrafo que se niega a comentar las imágenes por pudor, y no porque muestren su cuerpo desnudo, entero o por fragmentos, de forma desinhibida, en muchas de ellas. “No es lo mismo hacerlas que explicarlas”, se justifica. “Retraté mis posesiones y mis vicios y las esquinas de las calles por las que me moví porque quería elevarlas a la altura de una épica”, asegura el autor que reconoce que no hay nostalgia del pasado.

Comisariada por Nicolás Combarro, la exposición no es una antológica, pero si la muestra más completa sobre el autor que se ha podido ver Barcelona en los últimos años. “Todo lo que dice de mi Wikipedia es mentira, yo no fui el fotógrafo de la movida, yo estaba allí y fotografié mi entorno y a mis amigos”. La idea de la exposición empezó a fraguarse hace un año, durante la celebración de Arco. “Hubo la posibilidad de hacer algo conjunto con el pintor Miquel Barceló sobre retratos, pero eso está parado”, explica García-Alix que asegura que el proyecto no ha quedado descartado del todo.

La exposición coincide con la edición de un libro que ha editado La Fábrica con 150 imágenes (entre ellas las de la exposición) y que incluye un texto del fotógrafo sobre el miedo. “Nacemos con miedo, vivimos y morimos con miedo. Yo me tengo miedo”, dice.

Para el fotógrafo el título de sus fotografías es importante. Por eso le cuestan tanto, pero acaban convirtiendo a las imágenes en pequeños microrrelatos. Es el caso de Última noche en Madrid, Cartas de Montse o Mi tálamo nupcial. La exposición, abierta hasta el 5 de mayo, también incluye la proyección de dos vídeos del artista Tres vídeos tristes y De donde no se vuelve, donde construye a partir de imágenes y su propia voz una serie de relatos en primera persona. Son otra clase de autorretratos en movimiento.

http://ccaa.elpais.com/ccaa/2013/02/05/catalunya/1360069221_166005.html

 

García-Alix: “Comencé a hacer autorretratos como un juego”

La Virreina ofrece la más amplia exposición organizada en Barcelona sobre la obra del fotógrafo español

Cultura | 05/02/2013 – 13:34h

García-Alix:

‘Mi lado femenino’, 2002 García-Alix/La Virreina

Barcelona (EFE/Jose Oliva).- “Comencé a hacer autorretratos como un juego”, ha dicho hoy Alberto García-Alix en la presentación de Autorretrato, la más amplia exposición organizada en Barcelona sobre la obra del fotógrafo español actual más internacional.

La exposición, que se exhibirá del 7 de febrero al 5 de mayo en el Palau de la Virreina, ofrece al público el García-Alix más íntimo a través de 76 obras del artista.

El comisario de la muestra, Nicolás Combarro, ha subrayado que no se trata de una retrospectiva ni una colección de autorretratos, sino que es “una radiografía de sí mismo”.

Como se hiciera en la exposición que organizó el Museo de Arte Reina Sofía, en Autorretrato “aunque hay un orden cronológico, es su propio testimonio el que va conduciendo la narración”.

A través de interiores de habitaciones, objetos de los más variopintos, su figura enmascarada o fragmentos de su cuerpo, García-Alix establece, en palabras del comisario, “un monólogo con su propia imagen”.

Además de las fotografías, en la exposición se proyectan dos de sus vídeos: la trilogía Tres vídeos tristes (2003) y De donde no se vuelve (2008), realizados por García-Alix a partir de su obra fotográfica.

Según Combarro, “los vídeos son un ejercicio de generosidad de Alberto, porque sirven para que el espectador se meta literalmente en su obra”.

El artista no ha ocultado cierto “miedo” a esta muestra de la Virreina pues lo deja en una situación de excesiva sobreexposición.

“Soy tímido”, confiesa ante las risas incrédulas del auditorio, y añade que no hace fotografía para vencer esa timidez. “Hacer fotografía no me da ningún pudor. Tener la cámara en la mano tiene un sentido depredador, con intencionalidad, y por eso siempre rechazamos a alguien que quiere hacernos una foto, porque desconocemos su intención”.

Sin embargo, García-Alix sólo hace retratos a aquellos con los que establece una relación de confianza y no le interesa la foto robada en la calle.

En la presentación la palabra miedo surge constantemente: “El miedo -dice- es lo más íntimo, lo más humano y lo que todos tenemos desde que nacemos. Yo tengo miedo al exterior, pero también me tengo miedo a mí mismo”.

García-Alix relativiza asimismo el canon de belleza, un eterno debate en el mundo del arte: “hasta en lo que aparentemente no es bello hay belleza”, apunta, para añadir que “la belleza en la fotografía está además modulada por la composición y la luz”.

Como fotógrafo se confiesa “un ser malicioso” y explica que “incluso en lo más escabroso, lo más duro, se puede encontrar alguna idea estética”, y pone como ejemplo que hace un tiempo visitó una morgue y allí vio a una mujer asesinada con 17 puñaladas, algo que “no es bello, es trágico”, pero en el retrato que hizo de aquella mujer se puede encontrar belleza a través de la composición o de la iluminación.

Desde los primeros negativos del artista de finales de los años 70 se pueden ver fotografías en las que aparece autorretratado en actitud desafiante, como si la cámara fuera un elemento al que tuviera que seducir, o posando en escenografías de su vida en las que siente la necesidad de ocupar el espacio que fotografía.

También son frecuentes las acciones que él mismo ejecuta ante la cámara para generar una ficción paralela a su realidad.

Con el tiempo, sus autorretratos han ido evolucionando desde planos más generales hasta primeros planos o incluso aproximaciones extremas, casi macroscópicas, en las que su rostro está recortado por el encuadre.

A esta última tendencia pertenecen las fragmentaciones fotográficas de su propio cuerpo, o cuando él mismo sostiene algún objeto o elemento que le es propio.

La moto es uno de esos objetos recurrentes en su obra, que, para García-Alix, es sinónimo de “alegría de vivir”.

Se atreve el fotógrafo a teorizar sobre esa evolución en sus cuarenta años de trayectoria: “Comencé sin casi referentes fotográficos y he evolucionado en paralelo a la evolución de mi vida. He evolucionado aprendiendo a escuchar mi voz interior y los años me han hecho más preciso, conciso”.

Rechaza categóricamente que se le califique como ‘el fotógrafo de la Movida madrileña’: “Yo no fotografié la movida, la viví como actor pleno y fotografié mi entorno más propio, pero ya me hubiera gustado tener conciencia de fotógrafo”, comenta y reconoce que otros fotógrafos retrataron más aquel movimiento como Miguel Trillo o Pablo Pérez Mínguez.

 

February 3, 2013

07 What is a Medium? Terror and Magic

Filed under: economía,future,Holístico,tecnología — fores @ 11:17 am

What is a Medium? Terror and Magic

Posted on December 13, 2011 | Comments Off

The premise of Inventing the Medium  is that computation has created a new medium of representation.  How do we know when we have discovered a new medium? One answer might be that we know it by the combination of terror and delight that we experience as pioneering practitioners explore the new affordances for human expression.

For cinema there is mythic moment associated with the birth of film, the Lumière Brothers 1895 showing of a film about the everyday occurance of the arrival of a train.

According to the legend, the audience for this film went screaming from the Paris screening room in terror, believing that a real train was bearing down upon them (an episode that Martin Scorsese adopted for his 2011 film  Hugo). Although film scholars are skeptical of this event, the iconic story captures the feeling that accompanies a new medium: the frightening sense of being unable to tell the difference between something that is represented and something that is really there.

Some early film artists explicitly played with the delusional quality of film, most notably George Méliès who simulated magic tricks in playful and imaginative staged scenarios like this one:

The Lumière films were documentaries, exploiting the camera’s affordance of portability  – its ability to capture outdoor events  and spectacles too large to be captured on stage or too far away to be seen in person.  Méliès exploited the new representational affordances of the physical film, such as the ability to splice together different shots leaving out intervening events or to capture multiple images in a single frame through  multiple exposures. But both the realist and the fantasist approach are driven by the same  fascination with the power of a new medium to represent the world.

We can see the same cultural patterns in the response to other media, from spoken language to computation…but that is  matter for other posts.

What is a Medium? Terror and Magic

February 2, 2013

07 Top ten brains of the digital

Filed under: archivo personal,future,Holístico — fores @ 8:51 pm

Prospect Magazine

Top ten brains of the digital

 

by Tom Chatfield

/ December 15, 2010 / 5 Comments

Who are the world’s leading thinkers on technology? Prospect has convened an expert panel to select the top ten minds whose ideas are helping to shape our future

Above: digital consumers are living for the first time in a culture where being part of a globally interconnected group is normal


When we refer to something digital—a film, a book, a song—we simply mean that it exists as a string of ones and zeroes within a machine. As ever more of our cultural and intellectual life migrates towards digital media, however, the staggering implications are becoming clear: that to live in a digital age is to live in an era of instantaneous and infinite reproduction, communication and creation.

Change has rarely been at once so rapid and so universal; and many ideas that will shape the 21st century are emerging from the digital realm. In the past 12 months, the total number of global internet users has swept past the 2bn mark. Thanks to the explosive growth of mobile phones, we live for the first time in a culture where being part of a globally interconnected group is normal for most of the world’s adults. The last major medium not to have gone digital—books—has begun to make the transition in earnest. Apple’s iPad has sold over 1m units a month since its launch in April, and helped define a new kind of computing device, the tablet. The population of the world’s largest virtual social network, Facebook, has passed the half billion mark—while human-machine interactions took another leap forward with the launch in November of Microsoft’s Kinect: an affordable device that allows users to interact with a games console through movement alone.

But if 2010 was important, 2011 promises still more. The US Supreme Court is currently hearing the first appeal involving interactive media, about whether selling violent videogames to minors should be criminalised. More controversies will arise as the growing power of interactive media provokes debate over not only violence, but also addiction and the “shallowing” of information-saturated minds.

Beyond this, 2011 is set to see a greater intensity of both debate and legislation around personal information, virtual identities and digital public spaces—those increasingly valuable and exploitable aspects of most lives that now exist online. From privacy to data ownership, and from intellectual property to the ethics of conduct and commerce, the intersection between technology and society poses some of the most vital questions that our intellectual culture must address if we wish to describe—let alone decide—what 21st-century living means.

Digital society’s top three: Tim Berners-Lee, Susan Crawford and Henry Jenkins are helping to shape the future of our wired century

1. TIM BERNERS-LEE

In March 1989, the British engineer and computer scientist Tim Berners-Lee published a research paper outlining his concept for “a universal linked information system” that would “allow a place to be found for any information or reference which one felt was important.” It’s an event that numbers among the most significant in recent history, for Berners-Lee’s proposal introduced what would come to be known as the world wide web: the greatest communications project in history, and an open system that today contains over a trillion unique locations and that is used by almost a third of humanity.

Born in London in 1955, Berners-Lee studied physics at Oxford before working in telecoms, software engineering and technical design. In 1984 he became a fellow at Cern in Switzerland, where in 1989 he first conceived of the system that would change the world. Berners-Lee was knighted in 2004 for his achievements and is revered today as “the father of the web.” Perhaps still more remarkable than his ingenuity, however—and the reason that he heads our list of the world’s most important digital thinkers—is his continuing, impassioned advocacy of the freedom and universality embodied in his creation.

Once the web had begun to demonstrate its potential, rather than profit from restricting its use, Berners-Lee dedicated himself to ensuring its permanent availability to all. In 1994, he founded the World Wide Web Consortium, an international organisation resolved “to lead the Web to its full potential” by maintaining openness and open, universal digital standards. A proud, restless parent, Berners-Lee is an advocate of what might prove the web’s next great evolution, a “semantic” network able to connect different sites by interpreting the meaning of the information within them. Most recently he and professor Nigel Shadbolt helped lead the “open data” movement in Britain, persuading the government to release vast amounts of public information online—as well as co-ordinating efforts across the rest of the world to bring ever more knowledge into the hands of citizens, complete with the tools to use it.

2. SUSAN CRAWFORD

Barack Obama’s special assistant for science, technology and innovation policy until December 2009, Susan Crawford is a legal scholar, renowned blogger and thinker once described by Wired magazine as “the most powerful geek close to the president.” Currently a professor at Cardozo School of Law in New York City, Crawford has written extensively about issues including online identity, freedom and net neutrality—the principle that all internet users paying for a service should be entitled to an identical level of access, unrestricted by either governments or internet service providers. Crawford herself is an outspoken critic of allowing companies “private control over communications” online.

Born in Santa Monica, California, in 1963, Crawford studied at Yale and was a partner at a firm in Washington before becoming a professor at Cardozo for the first time in 2002. Having overseen the expenditure of Obama’s stimulus package on broadband internet and sat on the board of ICANN, the corporation responsible for managing all internet address allocations, hers is one of the most influential perspectives around on the future of online culture.

3. HENRY JENKINS

How are digital media affecting what constitutes “culture”—and what should it mean to educate the citizens of a digital world? Henry Jenkins, professor of communication, journalism and cinematic arts at the University of Southern California, is perhaps the world’s most influential and radical scholar addressing these questions.

Born in Atlanta, Georgia, in 1958, his early career explored how the relationship between readers and texts was transformed by new media and fan culture. Through books like 2006’s Convergence Culture: Where Old and New Media Collide, he has since become one of the definitive chroniclers of online culture in all its frantic complexity. Jenkins is also the principal investigator for Project New Media Literacies, a group developing new educational methods for teaching engagement with contemporary media; while his work with the Convergence Culture Consortium is devoted to building links between academic researchers and the media industry in order to help the rethinking of consumer relations.

4. JIMMY WALES

In 2001, American entrepreneur Jimmy Wales founded what would become the world’s most influential single information portal, Wikipedia: a free online encyclopaedia that could be both accessed and edited by anybody. Debates over accuracy and range continue but, today, the site boasts almost 3.5m articles in English and over 22m pages in total, written in 275 languages and used by over 380m people monthly. Through his campaigning, Wales has maintained the site as a free service without using advertising—making it a byword for the power of online collaboration.

5. STEVEN JOHNSON

American author Steven Johnson is one of the world’s bestselling and most prescient explainers of technology. His 1997 debut, Interface Culture, was one of the first studies of how interacting with machines changed the nature of thinking, while 2005’s Everything Bad Is Good for You offered an influential defence of popular culture. His 2010 book, Where Good Ideas Come From, explored the ways in which old and new world-changing innovations emerge. As well as writing books, in 2006 he founded the online service outside.in—a “geographic web” of local information.

6. IQBAL QUADIR

Born in Bangladesh in 1958, Iqbal Quadir worked in banking in the US before founding Bangladesh’s first GSM mobile phone provider in 1997—a company that today is its leading telecommunications service provider. The principle of empowering citizens in poorer countries through mobile phone access, which Quadir pioneered, has been one of the most radically effective technological innovations of recent decades. Quadir has also set up a foundation to promote innovations in Bangladesh, as well as a new company developing power generation capabilities for rural farmers and villagers.

7. JANET MURRAY

One of the world’s most influential interactive designers, Janet Murray is a professor at the Georgia Institute of Technology and specialises in connecting research work on artificial intelligence with cultural forms such as games, film, literature and television. With a PhD in English from Harvard, Murray’s work looks ahead to the newly expanded possibilities of expression created by interactive media, and is hugely influential on the cutting edge of game design, interactive television and filmmaking.

8. JIANG ZEMIN

As the internet grows steadily in importance, so too do issues of censorship and cyber-warfare. And few individuals have had more influence in this field than former Chinese premier Jiang Zemin, who as China’s president between 1993 and 2003 oversaw the launch of its “great firewall” and what has become the world’s most sophisticated system of online snooping, regulation, infiltration and cyber-warfare. Understanding the nature of the modern web also means understanding these forces—how and why they began, and are wielded.

9. JOI ITO

Born in Japan in 1966, Joi Ito has founded companies including PSINet Japan, Digital Garage and Infoseek Japan. He teaches and speaks widely, and is chair and chief executive of Creative Commons—a non-profit organisation devoted to expanding the range of creative works available online for others to build upon and share legally. Ito took over the role in 2008 from founding CEO Lawrence Lessig, and has championed Creative Commons as the world’s leading model for the free, regulated distribution and re-use of creative work online.

10. JILL TARTER

As director of the US Search for Extra-Terrestrial Intelligence (Seti) programme, astronomer Jill Tarter was the model for Jodie Foster’s character in the film of Carl Sagan’s novel Contact, and is the world’s most prominent figure in the search for extraterrestrial civilisations. Tarter has led Seti in making unprecedented use of mass online collaboration in analysing its vast stores of astronomical data, as well as helping to develop and co-ordinate the future of the US astronomical programme.

THE RUNNERS-UP

Speculative fiction author Neal Stephenson was praised, as was Christopher “mOOt” Poole, the elusive founder of 4chan, the world’s most influential imageboard website. The WikiLeaks founder, Julian Assange, is hard to ignore; while writers Charles Leadbeater, Jonathan Zittrain and Clay Shirky are numbered among the most influential public voices exploring the internet’s impact and future. Ted Nelson was hailed for inventing the precursor to the world wide web; Premal Shah for his microfinance site kiva.org; and Sugata Mitra for his inspirational work on digital learning.


The Prospect panel

Aleks Krotoski is a fellow at the Oxford Internet Institute, doctor of social psychology, writer and broadcaster; most recently, she presented The Virtual Revolution (BBC)

Ren Reynolds is a philosopher, writer, strategist, founder of virtualpolicy.net, former head of digital strategy at Cable & Wireless, and consultant to several government departments

Justine Roberts is a writer, journalist, and co-founder and chief executive of the website Mumsnet, one of Britain’s most successful community websites

Bronwen Maddox is the editor of Prospect and former chief foreign commentator of The Times

Tom Chatfield is Prospect’s former arts and books editor and the author of Fun Inc. (Virgin)

January 31, 2013

07 The NRA Myth of Arming the Good Guys

Filed under: archivo personal,future,George Lakoff,política — fores @ 9:17 am

Mother Jones

The NRA Myth of Arming the Good Guys

Mass shootings in the US are on the rise—and ordinary citizens with guns don’t stop them.

By | Fri Dec. 28, 2012 1:11 PM PST


The gut-wrenching shock of the attack at Sandy Hook Elementary School on December 14 wasn’t just due to the 20 unthinkably young victims. It was also due to the realization that this specific, painfully familiar nightmare was unfolding yet again.

As the scope of the massacre in Newtown became clear, some news accounts [1] suggested that mass shootings in the United States have not increased, based on a broad definition of them. But in fact 2012 has been unprecedented for a particular kind of horror that’s been on the rise in recent years, from Virginia Tech to Tucson to Aurora to Oak Creek to Newtown. There have been at least 62 such mass shootings in the last three decades, attacks in which the killer took the lives of four or more people (the FBI’s baseline for mass murder) in a public place—a school, a workplace, a mall, a religious building. Seven of them occurred in 2012 alone [2].

Along with three other similar though less lethal rampages—at a Portland shopping mall, a Milwaukee spa, and a Cleveland high school—2012 has been the worst year for these events in modern US history, with 151 victims injured and killed [3]. More than a quarter of them were young children and teenagers.

The National Rifle Association and its allies would have us believe that the solution to this epidemic, itself but a sliver of America’s overall gun violence, is to put firearms in the hands of as many citizens as possible. “The only thing that stops a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun,” declared the NRA’s Wayne LaPierre in a press conference a week after Newtown, the same day bells tolled at the National Cathedral and the devastated town mourned its 28 dead. (That day a gunman in Pennsylvania also murdered three people and wounded a state trooper shortly before LaPierre gave his remarks.) LaPierre explained that it was a travesty for a school principal to face evil unarmed, and he called for gun-wielding security officers to be deployed in every school in America.

As many commentators noted, it was particularly callous of the NRA to double down on its long-standing proposal to fight gun violence with more guns while parents in Newtown were burying their first graders. But more importantly, the NRA’s argument is bereft of supporting evidence. A closer look reveals that their case for arming Americans against mass shooters is nothing more than a cynical ideological talking point—one dressed up in appeals to heroism and the defense of constitutional freedom, and wholly reliant on misdirection and half truths. If only Sandy Hook’s principal had been packing heat, the argument goes, she could’ve stopped the mass killer. There’s just one little problem with this: Not a single one of the 62 mass shootings we studied in our investigation has been stopped this way—even as the nation has been flooded with millions of additional firearms [5] and a barrage of recent laws has made it easier than ever for ordinary citizens to carry them in public places [11], including bars, parks, and schools.

Gun rights die-hards claim the Portland mall shooter saw an armed good guy—who ran for cover instead of firing—and promptly shot himself dead. Obviously.

Attempts by armed citizens to stop shooters are rare. At least two such attempts in recent years ended badly, with the would-be good guys gravely wounded or killed [5]. Meanwhile, the five cases most commonly cited as instances of regular folks stopping massacres fall apart under scrutiny [6]: Either they didn’t involve ordinary citizens taking action—those who intervened were actually cops, trained security officers, or military personnel—or the citizens took action after the shooting rampages appeared to have already ended. (Or in some cases, both.)

But those facts don’t matter to the gun rights die-hards, who never seem to run out of intellectually dishonest ammo. Most recently [12], they’ve pointed to [13] the Portland shopping mall rampage earlier in December, in which an armed civilian reportedly drew his gun but thought twice about potentially hurting an innocent bystander and ducked for cover instead of firing. The assailant suddenly got scared of this retreating good guy with the gun, they claim, and promptly shot himself dead. Obviously.

Another favorite tactic is to blame so called “gun-free zones” for the carnage—as if a disturbed kid shoots up a school, or a disgruntled employee executes his coworkers, or a neo-Nazi guns down Sikhs at worship simply because he has identified the safest place to go open fire. All we need to do is make sure lots of citizens have guns in these locations, and voilà, problem solved!

For their part, law enforcement officials overwhelmingly hate the idea of armed civilians getting involved. As a senior FBI agent told me [8], it would make their jobs more difficult if they had to figure out which of the shooters at an active crime scene was the bad guy. And while they train rigorously for responding in confined and chaotic situations, the danger to innocent bystanders from ordinary civilians whipping out firearms is obvious. Exhibit A: the gun-wielding citizen who admitted to coming within a split second of shooting an innocent person [14] as the Tucson massacre unfolded, after initially mistaking that person for the killer, Jared Loughner.

The NRA’s LaPierre was also eager to blame violent video games and movies for what happened in Newtown, and to demonize the “unknown number of genuine monsters” walking among us. Never mind that the failure to recognize and treat mental health problems is a crucial factor in this dark equation: Of the 62 mass shootings we examined, 36 of them were murder-suicides, while assailants in seven other cases died in police shootouts, widely considered to have been “suicide by cop.”

Those who are serious about contending with the problem of mass shootings understand that collecting and studying data is crucial. Since we began our investigation after the attack in Aurora in July, we’ve heard from numerous academic researchers, legislative aides, and others wanting access to our full data set. We’ve now published it here [9].

The question now isn’t whether most Americans will take seriously the idea of turning every grammar school in the nation into a citadel. (Here, too, the NRA’s argument falls apart; an armed sheriff’s deputy at Columbine and a robust security force at Virginia Tech didn’t stop those slaughters from occurring.) Now that we’ve just witnessed the worst year for mass shootings in memory, including 20 of the most innocent of lives snuffed out, what remains to be seen is whether real reform is finally on the way on Capitol Hill. Despite years of this kind of carnage, next to nothing has been changed in our legal system with respect to how easy it is for a disturbed young man to get his hands on a military-style assault rifle and a stockpile of highly lethal ammunition.

Sen. Diane Feinstein has vowed to introduce a new ban on assault weapons when Congress reconvenes in January. President Obama has signaled that the gun issue will be a real priority going forward. But once the raw emotion of Newtown dissipates there will be the danger of slipping back into the same inertia and political stalemate so successfully cultivated by the pro-gun ideologues. Soon lawmakers will start eyeing their 2014 reelection campaigns and thinking about how much money the NRA has in its coffers to take aim at them with should they dare to dissent. This time, have we finally had enough?


Source URL: http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/12/nra-mass-shootings-myth

Links:
[1] http://news.yahoo.com/no-rise-mass-killings-impact-huge-185700637.html
[2] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/07/mass-shootings-map
[3] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/12/mass-shootings-victims-2012
[4] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/12/nra-mass-shootings-myth
[5] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/09/mass-shootings-investigation
[6] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/12/armed-civilians-do-not-stop-mass-shootings
[7] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2013/01/high-capacity-magazines-mass-shootings
[8] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/11/jared-loughner-mass-shootings-mental-illness
[9] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/12/mass-shootings-mother-jones-full-data
[10] http://www.motherjones.com/special-reports/2012/12/guns-in-america-mass-shootings
[11] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/09/map-gun-laws-2009-2012
[12] http://dailycaller.com/2012/12/19/we-know-how-to-stop-school-shootings/
[13] http://www.mrctv.org/videos/media-blackout-oregon-mall-shooting-stopped-licensed-gun-carrier
[14] http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/human_nature/2011/01/friendly_firearms.html

« Previous Page — Next Page »

WPMU Theme pack by WPMU-DEV.