Forés @ UVPress






         Universitat de València PRESS -UVPress- weblog for research uses

April 30, 2012

05 Eurodämmerung: el crepúsculo del euro

Filed under: economía,future,Holístico,módulo básico — fores @ 2:34 pm
NOVEDAD EDITORIAL

Eurodämmerung: el crepúsculo del euro

Paul Krugman analiza en su último libro,”¡Acabad ya con esta crisis!”, la profunda depresión que atraviesa el mundo desarrollado

29 ABR 2012 – 00:01 CET117

Durante los últimos años, comparar la evolución económica de Europa y la de EE UU se asemejaba a una carrera de cojos contra rengos; o, si lo prefieren de otro modo, una competición sobre quién puede pifiarla más a la hora de dar una respuesta a la crisis. Mientras escribo estas páginas, Europa parece llevar un pie de ventaja en la carrera hacia el desastre; pero démosle tiempo.

Si esto les parece despiadado, o suena a regodeo desde EE UU, permítanme ser más claro: las dificultades económicas que está sufriendo Europa son indudablemente terribles, y no solo por el sufrimiento que provocan, sino también por sus implicaciones políticas. Durante unos 60 años, Europa se ha entregado a un noble experimento: un intento de reformar, mediante la integración económica, un continente azotado por la guerra, para situarlo de forma permanente en el camino de la paz y de la democracia. Al mundo entero le interesa que el experimento sea un éxito y el mundo entero padecerá si fracasa.

El experimento comenzó en 1951, con la creación de la Comunidad Europea del Carbón y del Acero (CECA). El nombre es prosaico, pero se trataba de un intento de muy nobles ideales, concebido para que la guerra resultara imposible en Europa. Al establecer el libre comercio en, vaya, el carbón y el acero —esto es, se eliminaron todos los aranceles y restricciones que gravaban los envíos económicos transfronterizos, de modo que las acerías pudieran comprar carbón al productor más cercano, aunque estuviera al otro lado de la frontera—, el pacto generaba beneficios económicos. Pero, al mismo tiempo, se garantizaba que las acerías francesas dependieran del carbón alemán, y viceversa; se esperaba que, así, cualquier futura hostilidad entre los países fuera tan tremendamente perjudicial que resultara impensable.

La CECA fue un gran éxito y sirvió de modelo para una serie de medidas similares. En 1957, seis países europeos fundaron la Comunidad Económica Europea, una unión aduanera con libre comercio entre sus miembros y aranceles comunes sobre las importaciones del exterior. En los años setenta, se unieron al grupo Reino Unido, Irlanda y Dinamarca; mientras tanto, la Comunidad Europea iba ampliando su papel, prestando ayuda a las regiones más pobres y fomentando los Gobiernos democráticos por toda Europa. A lo largo de los años ochenta, Grecia, España y Portugal, liberadas ya de sus dictadores, recibieron como recompensa la incorporación a la comunidad; y los países de Europa estrecharon sus lazos económicos armonizando las regulaciones económicas, eliminando puestos fronterizos y garantizando la libre circulación de sus trabajadores.

En cada estadio, los beneficios económicos derivados de una integración más profunda avanzaban parejos con un nivel cada vez más estrecho de integración política. Las políticas económicas nunca trataron solo de economía; siempre intentaban promocionar, además, la unidad europea. Por ejemplo, la utilidad económica del libre comercio entre España y Francia era igual de obvia durante el mandato de Franco que tras su muerte (y los problemas que supuso la entrada de España fueron tan reales tras su muerte como lo habrían sido antes), pero añadir al proyecto europeo una España democrática era un objetivo que valía la pena, y el libre comercio con un dictador, en cambio, no lo era. Y esto contribuye a explicar lo que ahora parece un error fatídico: la decisión de pasar a una moneda común. Las élites europeas estaban tan embelesadas con la idea de crear un poderoso símbolo de unidad que exageraron los beneficios de una moneda única e hicieron caso omiso de las advertencias al respecto de un inconveniente importante.

El problema de la moneda (única)

Existen, por supuesto, costes reales derivados del uso de varias monedas; costes que pueden evitarse si se adopta una moneda común. Los negocios entre dos países fronterizos son más caros si hay que cambiar divisas, tener a mano distintas monedas o mantener cuentas bancarias multidivisa. Los posibles tipos de cambio introducen incertidumbre; la planificación se complica y la contabilidad es más confusa cuando los ingresos y los gastos no están siempre en las mismas unidades. Cuantos más negocios haga una unidad política con sus vecinos, más problemático será que tenga una moneda independiente; es la razón que explica por qué sería una mala idea que Brooklyn, por decir algo, contase con su dólar propio, como sí hace Canadá.

La decisión de adoptar una moneda común parece ahora

un error fatídico

Pero tener moneda propia también supone algunas ventajas nada desdeñables; la más conocida es cómo la devaluación —reducir el valor de la propia moneda en relación con las otras— puede, en ocasiones, facilitar el proceso de ajuste posterior a una crisis económica.

Situémonos ante el siguiente ejemplo, nada hipotético: España ha vivido buena parte de la última década fortalecida por un gigantesco auge inmobiliario, financiado por grandes entradas de capital proveniente de Alemania. Este auge ha alimentado la inflación y ha hecho subir los sueldos españoles en relación con los de Alemania. Pero, al final, resulta que el auge estaba hinchado por una burbuja que ahora ha estallado. Ahora, España tiene que reorientar su economía, dejando a un lado la construcción y volviendo otra vez a la industria. En este punto, sin embargo, la industria española no es competitiva, porque los sueldos españoles son demasiado altos comparados con los alemanes. ¿Cómo puede recuperar España su competitividad?

Una forma sería convencer a los trabajadores españoles de que acepten sueldos inferiores (o exigirles que lo hagan). Es la única vía real de la que disponer si España y Alemania comparten moneda, o si, como consecuencia de una directriz política no modificable, la moneda española se ha fijado frente a la moneda alemana.

Pero si España tiene su propia moneda, y está dispuesta a dejarla caer, para conservar sus sueldos le basta con devaluar la moneda. Si pasamos de 80 pesetas por marco alemán a 100 pesetas por marco, aunque los sueldos españoles en pesetas no cambien, habremos reducido de golpe los sueldos españoles un 20% en relación con los alemanes.

¿Por qué tiene que ser más fácil así que si negociamos una bajada de sueldos? La mejor explicación la ofrece Milton Friedman —ni más ni menos—, quien defendió los tipos de cambio flexibles en un artículo clásico de 1953 (The case for flexible exchange rates, en Essays in Positive Economics). Decía Friedman:

La defensa de los tipos de cambio flexibles es, por curioso que parezca, casi idéntica a la del cambio de hora en verano. ¿No resulta absurdo cambiar el reloj en verano cuando se podría conseguir exactamente lo mismo si cada persona cambiase sus costumbres? Lo único que se precisa es que cada persona decida llegar a la oficina una hora antes, comer una hora antes, etc. Pero, obviamente, es mucho más sencillo cambiar el reloj que guía a todas estas personas, en lugar de pretender que cada individuo por separado cambie sus costumbres de reacción ante el reloj, por más que todos quieran hacerlo. La situación es exactamente igual a la del mercado de divisas. Es mucho más simple permitir que un precio cambie —el precio de una divisa extranjera— que confiar en que se modifique una multitud de precios que constituyen, todos juntos, la estructura interna del precio.

Sin duda, Friedman está en lo cierto. Los trabajadores siempre se muestran reticentes a aceptar recortes en sus salarios, pero sobre todo se niegan si no están seguros de que otros trabajadores vayan a aceptar otros recortes similares y que el coste de la vida vaya a rebajarse igual que bajan los costes laborales. No conozco ningún país cuyas instituciones y mercado laboral le faciliten responder a la situación que acabo de describir para España por la vía del recorte salarial generalizado. Pero los países sí pueden sufrir, y de hecho sufren, importantes disminuciones de sus sueldos relativos de forma más o menos repentina, por la vía de la devaluación de la moneda; y lo hacen con trastornos relativamente menores.

Las élites estaban tan embelesadas que desoyeron

las advertencias

Por lo tanto, fijar una moneda única implica ciertos sacrificios. De un lado, compartir moneda aumenta los rendimientos: disminuyen los costes empresariales y, es de suponer, mejora la planificación de los negocios. Del otro, se pierde flexibilidad, lo cual puede acarrear serios problemas si llegan a producirse choques asimétricos como el hundimiento de un boom inmobiliario cuando tiene lugar solo en algunos países, no en todos.

Es difícil cuantificar el valor de la flexibilidad económica. Y es aún más difícil cuantificar los beneficios obtenidos por compartir moneda. Disponemos, no obstante, de abundantes estudios económicos sobre los criterios para determinar una zona monetaria óptima, un tecnicismo feo, pero útil, para aludir a un grupo de países que se beneficiarían de una fusión de sus monedas. ¿Qué dicen esos textos?

En primer lugar, no tiene sentido que unos países compartan moneda de no ser que entre ellos exista un gran comercio. En la década de 1990, Argentina fijó el valor del peso en 1 dólar estadounidense, en teoría de forma permanente, lo cual, aunque no significaba lo mismo que abandonar su moneda, se pretendía que fuese lo más parecido. Sin embargo, resultó ser una operación abocada al fracaso que terminó en devaluación e impago. Y una de las razones por las que estaba condenada al fracaso era que Argentina no mantenía un vínculo económico tan estrecho con EE UU, que solo supone el 11% de sus importaciones y el 5% de las exportaciones. Así, por una parte, cualesquiera que fuesen los beneficios obtenidos al otorgar seguridad empresarial en lo tocante al tipo de cambio dólar-peso, estos quedaron en poco porque Argentina comerciaba escasamente con EE UU. Por otra parte, Argentina estaba sometida al mismo tiempo a las fluctuaciones de otras monedas, en especial a las grandes caídas frente al dólar tanto del euro como del real brasileño, lo que implicaba precios excesivos para las exportaciones argentinas.

A este respecto, a Europa no parecía irle mal: los países europeos realizan aproximadamente el 60% de su comercio entre sí, y el suyo es un comercio muy profuso. Sin embargo, atendiendo a otros dos criterios importantes —la movilidad laboral y la integración fiscal—, Europa no parecía ni de lejos tan bien preparada para asumir una moneda única.

La industria española no es competitiva porque los sueldos son demasiado altos

La movilidad laboral ocupaba un primer plano en el artículo que dio origen a todo el campo de estudio de la zona monetaria óptima, escrito en 1961 por el economista de origen canadiense Robert Mundell. Un resumen a grandes rasgos de la tesis de Mundell diría que los problemas de ajustarse a un boom en Saskatchewan y una depresión simultánea en la Columbia Británica (o viceversa) se reducirían bastante si los trabajadores se desplazaran libremente allí donde están los empleos. Y, de hecho, la mano de obra se mueve libremente por las provincias canadienses, exceptuando Quebec; y se mueve libremente por los distintos Estados de EE UU. Sin embargo, no se mueve libremente por los países de Europa. Aunque los europeos tienen, desde 1992, derecho legal a trabajar en cualquier parte de la Unión Europea, las divisiones lingüísticas y culturales son suficientemente grandes como para que incluso grandes diferencias en las tasas de desempleo ocasionen unas tasas migratorias muy modestas.

La importancia de la integración fiscal fue subrayada por Peter Kenen, de Princeton, pocos años después de la publicación del artículo de Mundell. Para ilustrar el punto de vista de Kenen, imaginemos una comparación entre dos economías que —dejando a un lado los paisajes— se parecen mucho en la actualidad: Irlanda y Nevada. Ambas tuvieron enormes burbujas inmobiliarias que han estallado, ambas cayeron en profundas recesiones que dispararon las tasas de desempleo y en ambos casos hay una elevada morosidad en las hipotecas de la vivienda.

Pero en el caso de Nevada, las crisis se han visto amortiguadas, en gran medida, gracias al Gobierno federal. Ahora Nevada está pagando muchos menos impuestos a Washington, pero los jubilados del Estado siguen cobrando los cheques de la Seguridad Social, y Medicare sigue pagándoles las facturas sanitarias; en consecuencia, la realidad es que el Estado está recibiendo mucha ayuda. Además, los depósitos de los bancos de Nevada están garantizados por una agencia federal, la Corporación Federal de Seguros de Depósitos (FDIC en sus siglas inglesas), y algunas pérdidas derivadas de la morosidad hipotecaria recaen sobre Fannie y Freddie, que cuentan con el respaldo del Gobierno federal.

Irlanda, por el contrario, está principalmente sola: tiene que rescatar a sus bancos, pagar las jubilaciones y costear la Sanidad a partir de sus propios ingresos, muy disminuidos. Por tanto, aunque la situación es dura en ambos lugares, Irlanda no está pasando por la crisis igual que Nevada.

Y nada de todo esto debería sorprendernos. Hace 20 años, a medida que la idea de pasar a una moneda común en Europa iba tomando visos de realidad, ya se comprendía perfectamente que la moneda única europea era problemática. De hecho, se desató un prolongado debate académico sobre la cuestión (en el que tuve ocasión de participar) y los economistas estadounidenses allí presentes se mostraron, en general, escépticos con respecto al euro; sobre todo porque EE UU parecía ofrecer un buen modelo de lo que se necesita para que una economía pueda contar con una moneda única, y Europa quedaba muy lejos de aquel modelo. La movilidad laboral, según creíamos, era demasiado escasa; y la ausencia de un Gobierno central, junto con la protección automática que habría ofrecido un Gobierno de esas características, se sumaba a las dudas.

Pero aquellas advertencias se pasaron por alto. El glamour —si es que podemos llamarlo así— de la idea del euro, la sensación de que Europa estaba dando un paso trascendental para terminar definitivamente con su historia bélica y convertirse en baluarte de la democracia fue, sencillamente, demasiado fuerte.

El Gran Escaño es creer que la crisis se deba a la irresponsabilidad fiscal

Cuando uno preguntaba cómo manejaría Europa las situaciones en las que algunas economías funcionasen bien al tiempo que otras se hundían —como sucede en la actualidad con Alemania y España— la respuesta oficial, más o menos, era que todos los países de la zona euro seguirían políticas fiables, de modo que no se producirían tales “choques asimétricos”; y, si de algún modo llegaba a darse un caso así, la reforma estructural flexibilizaría lo suficiente las economías europeas para permitir los ajustes necesarios.

Pero lo que ha ocurrido, en realidad, ha sido el mayor de todos los choques asimétricos. Y se debió a la propia creación del euro.

La euroburbuja

Oficialmente, el euro empezó a existir a principios de 1999, aunque los billetes y las monedas de euro no llegaron hasta tres años después. (También oficialmente, el franco, el marco, la lira, la peseta, etcétera, se convirtieron en valores del euro: 1 franco francés equivalía a 6,5597 euros, 1 marco alemán era igual a 1,95583 euros y así todas las demás monedas).

Y el euro tuvo un efecto inmediato fatídico: hizo que los inversores se sintieran seguros.

Más concretamente, hizo que los inversores se sintieran seguros al poner su dinero en países que antes se consideraban de riesgo. Los tipos de interés en el sur de Europa habían sido, históricamente, más altos que en Alemania, porque los inversores exigían una prima como seguro ante el riesgo de devaluación o mora. Con la llegada del euro, esas primas se desmoronaron: la deuda de España, de Italia, incluso la griega, se trataba como si fuera tan segura, o casi, como la deuda alemana.

Eso supuso un fuerte descenso en el coste del dinero prestado en el sur de Europa; y provocó enormes explosiones inmobiliarias que pronto se convirtieron en enormes burbujas inmobiliarias.

El mecanismo de estos auges y estas burbujas inmobiliarias es un poco distinto del que vivió la burbuja de EE UU: hubo menos extravagancias financieras, con mucho más peso de los préstamos directos por parte de bancos convencionales. No obstante, los bancos locales no tenían, ni de lejos, depósitos suficientes para respaldar el volumen de préstamo que movían, de modo que se volcaron en el mercado mayorista y solicitaron préstamos a los bancos del corazón de Europa —de Alemania, sobre todo—, que no estaba atravesando un auge comparable. Por tanto, hubo enormes flujos de dinero desde el corazón de Europa hacia su floreciente periferia.

Esa afluencia de capital alimentó auges que, a su vez, provocaron un aumento de sueldos: en la década siguiente a la creación del euro, el coste unitario de la mano de obra (con sueldos ajustados a la productividad) ascendió cerca de un 35% en el sur de Europa, comparado con el incremento de solo un 9% en Alemania. La industria del sur de Europa dejó de ser competitiva, lo cual a su vez significó que los países que estaban atrayendo grandes cantidades de dinero empezaron a registrar, a su vez, grandes déficits comerciales. Para que el lector se haga una idea de lo que sucedía —y del lío que ahora hay que desliar—, el cuadro adjunto indica el incremento de los desequilibrios comerciales dentro de Europa tras la introducción del euro. Una línea muestra el saldo de la balanza por cuenta corriente de Alemania (medida aproximada de la balanza comercial); la otra indica la balanza por cuenta corriente combinada de los países GIPSI (Grecia, Irlanda, Portugal, España e Italia). Esta ampliación del diferencial se halla en el núcleo de los problemas de Europa.

España es un caso emblemático de la crisis económica del euro

Pero pocos se dieron cuenta del gran peligro que suponía este proceso. Más bien al contrario, la mayoría mostraba una satisfacción que bordeaba la euforia. Hasta que la burbuja reventó.

La crisis financiera en EE UU fue el desencadenante del derrumbe europeo; pero este hundimiento habría llegado igualmente, más tarde o más temprano. Y, de repente, el euro se vio ante un enorme choque asimétrico, que se agravó mucho por la falta de una integración fiscal.

Pues el estallido de estas burbujas inmobiliarias —que se produjo algo más tarde que en EE UU, pero que en 2008 ya había recorrido un buen trecho— hizo más que hundir a los países de las burbujas en una recesión: además ha colocado sus presupuestos bajo una terrible presión. Los ingresos cayeron a la vez que caían la producción y el empleo; el gasto en los subsidios de desempleo se disparó,; y los Gobiernos se encontraron (o se colocaron ellos mismos) en una peligrosa posición a consecuencia de los gravosos rescates de los bancos, puesto que no solo garantizaron los depósitos, sino también, en numerosos casos, las deudas que sus bancos habían contraído con otros bancos en países acreedores. Por lo tanto, también se dispararon la deuda y el déficit, y los inversores se inquietaron. En vísperas de la crisis, los tipos de interés de la deuda irlandesa a largo plazo estaban ligeramente por debajo de las tasas de interés aplicadas a la deuda alemana, y las de España, solo un poco por encima; mientras estoy escribiendo estas palabras, las tasas españolas multiplican por 2,5 las alemanas, y las irlandesas llegan a cuadruplicarlas.

No tardaré en ocuparme de la respuesta política. Pero antes debo detenerme en algunos mitos muy extendidos. Pues la historia que probablemente haya oído usted acerca de los problemas de Europa —la historia que se ha convertido de facto en el argumento con el que se explica la política europea— es bastante distinta de la que acabo de contar.

El Gran Engaño europeo

En el capítulo 4 de este libro describí y desarmé la Gran Mentira sobre la crisis de EE UU: la que sostenía que los organismos gubernamentales habían provocado la crisis en su desacertado intento de ayudar a los pobres. Bien; Europa también tiene su propia narración distorsionada, un relato falso de las causas de la crisis que no solo interfiere en el camino de las soluciones reales sino que, de hecho, termina llevando a políticas que solo empeoran la situación.

No creo que quienes han extendido el falso relato sobre Europa sean tan cínicos como sus equivalentes de EE UU; no veo tanta deliberación para amañar los datos y sospecho que la mayoría cree realmente lo que dice. Por tanto, llamémoslo el Gran Engaño, mejor que la Gran Mentira. Aunque no está claro que esto mejore las cosas: sigue siendo un perfecto error y la gente que difunde esta doctrina tiene tan poco interés en escuchar pruebas contrarias como la derecha de EE UU.

He aquí, pues, el Gran Engaño europeo: la creencia de que la crisis europea se debe ante todo a la irresponsabilidad fiscal. Los países incurren en déficits presupuestarios excesivos —nos dice el cuento— y se endeudan en exceso, por lo que ahora lo importante es establecer unas normas que impidan que la historia se vuelva a repetir.

Pero seguro que algunos lectores están preguntándose ahora si esto no se parece mucho a lo que sucedió en Grecia. Y la respuesta es que sí, aunque hasta la historia de Grecia es más complicada. La cuestión, sin embargo, es que no se trata de lo que pasó en otros países en crisis; y, además, si todo esto no fuese más que un problema griego, no tendríamos la crisis que tenemos. Porque la de Grecia es una economía menor, que representa menos del 3% del PIB de los países del euro y solo cerca del 8% del PIB conjunto de los países del euro que están en crisis.

La esencia del problema español es el reajuste de costes y precios

¿Hasta qué punto confunde la helenización del discurso en Europa? Tal vez se podría aducir irresponsabilidad fiscal también en el caso de Portugal, aunque en un grado distinto. Pero justo antes de la crisis, Irlanda tenía superávit presupuestario y una deuda baja; en 2006, George Osborne, que ahora dirige la política económica de Reino Unido, la calificó de “brillante ejemplo del arte de lo posible en la formulación de políticas económicas a largo plazo”. España también tenía superávit presupuestario y una deuda baja. Italia había heredado un elevado nivel de deuda de los años setenta y ochenta, cuando se practicaba una política verdaderamente irresponsable, pero aun así la deuda en cuanto porcentaje del PIB iba disminuyendo de forma constante.

¿Cómo se suma todo esto? En el segundo cuadro adjunto se indica la deuda como porcentaje del PIB para un país promedio de entre los países que ahora están en crisis: un promedio, ponderado en función del PIB, de las proporciones de deuda/PIB en los cinco países GIPSI (recordemos: Grecia, Irlanda, Portugal, España e Italia). Hasta 2007 inclusive, este promedio descendía de forma sostenida; o sea que, en lugar de transmitir una imagen de derrochadores, parecía que el grupo de los GIPSI, con el tiempo, mejoraría su situación fiscal. La deuda se disparó solo tras la llegada de la crisis.

Pero muchos europeos en puestos clave —sobre todo destacados políticos y funcionarios alemanes, aunque también los dirigentes del Banco Central Europeo y líderes de opinión de todo el mundo de las finanzas y la banca— están totalmente comprometidos con el Gran Engaño y ninguna prueba esgrimida en su contra les afectará. En consecuencia, el problema de hacer frente a esta crisis suele formularse en términos morales: los países tienen problemas porque han pecado, y ahora tienen que redimirse a través del sufrimiento.

Y este enfoque es funesto, a la hora de abordar los problemas reales a los que se enfrenta Europa.

Si contemplamos Europa, o más concretamente la zona euro, como un conglomerado, o sea, sumando las cifras de todos los países que usan el euro, no parece que tuvieran que encontrarse tan mal. Tanto la deuda privada como la pública son algo inferiores a las de EE UU, lo que hace pensar que deberían contar con más margen de maniobra; las cifras de inflación se parecen a las nuestras y no se aprecia el menor rastro de una crisis inflacionaria; y, por lo que añada el dato, Europa en su conjunto tiene un balance por cuenta corriente más o menos equilibrado, lo que significa que no necesita atraer capital de ninguna otra parte.

Pero Europa no es un conglomerado. Es una colección de países, cada uno con sus presupuestos (porque hay muy poca integración fiscal) y sus propios mercados laborales (porque hay poca movilidad laboral), pero sin sus propias monedas. Y esto ha provocado una crisis.

Pensemos en el caso de España, que, a mi modo de ver, es un caso emblemático de la crisis económica del euro; y dejemos de lado, por un momento, la cuestión del presupuesto gubernamental. Como ya hemos visto, durante los primeros ocho años de vida del euro, España recibió grandes flujos de dinero, que alimentaron una enorme burbuja inmobiliaria y, además, provocaron un considerable aumento de sueldos y precios en relación con las economías del núcleo de Europa. La esencia del problema español —de donde proviene todo lo demás— es la necesidad de reajustar los costes y los precios. ¿Cómo puede hacerse algo así?

Bien, podría conseguirse mediante la inflación en las economías de los países centrales. Supongamos que el Banco Central Europeo siguiera una política de dinero barato mientras el Gobierno alemán proponía un estímulo fiscal; esto supondría pleno empleo dentro de Alemania, aunque en España las tasas de desempleo continuaran siendo aún elevadas. Por lo tanto, los sueldos españoles no subirían mucho, si es que llegaban a subir, mientras que los alemanes sí crecerían bastante; de este modo, los costes españoles se mantendrían al mismo nivel mientras que los costes alemanes aumentarían. Y este ajuste, en el caso español, sería relativamente sencillo; no digo sencillo, solo relativamente sencillo.

Romper el euro ahora que ya existe se pagaría

muy caro

Pero los alemanes sienten un odio verdaderamente profundo hacia la inflación, debido al recuerdo de la gran inflación de los primeros años veinte. (Curiosamente, recuerdan mucho menos las políticas deflacionistas de los primeros años treinta, que en realidad fueron las que abonaron el terreno para la ascensión al poder de el-lector-ya-sabe-quién. Volveremos sobre ello en el capítulo 11. Y quizá sea relevante, de forma más directa, que el Banco Central Europeo se constituyó con el mandato de mantener la estabilidad de los precios; y punto. Hasta qué extremo es vinculante este mandato es una pregunta abierta; yo sospecho que el BCE podría dar con un modo de justificar una inflación moderada, diga lo que diga su carta fundacional. Sin embargo, el ánimo que impera concibe la inflación como un demonio terrible, sin tomar en consideración las consecuencias que puede tener una política de inflación reducida.

Pensemos ahora en lo que esto implica para España; a saber, que tiene que ajustar los costes por medio de la deflación, que en la eurojerga se conoce como devaluación interna. Y eso sí es muy difícil de conseguir, porque los sueldos son casi rígidos, cuando se trata de bajarlos: solo caen despacio y de mala gana, por mucho que el país se enfrente a un fuerte desempleo.

Si hubiera dudas en torno a esta rigidez, la historia de Europa las disipará todas. Tomemos el caso de Irlanda, por lo general considerada una nación con mercados laborales muy flexibles (otro eufemismo para hablar de una economía en la que los patrones pueden despedir a los trabajadores, o recortarles los sueldos, con suma facilidad). Pese a que Irlanda lleva varios años sufriendo unas tasas de paro muy elevadas (próximas al 14%, en el momento de escribir estas páginas), los sueldos irlandeses solo han caído un 4% desde su pico más elevado. Es decir, Irlanda está consiguiendo una devaluación interna, en efecto; pero muy despacio. Es una historia parecida a la de Lituania, que no está en el euro pero ha rechazado la posibilidad de devaluar la moneda. En cuanto a España, el salario medio ha llegado a aumentar ligeramente pese a la fuerte tasa de desempleo, aunque tal vez solo se trate, en parte, de una ilusión estadística.

Y, por cierto, si quieren un ejemplo de la tesis de Milton Friedman —cuando afirmaba que, para recortar precios y salarios, lo más sencillo, con diferencia, es devaluar la moneda—, miren el caso de Islandia. Este pequeño país insular saltó a la fama por la magnitud de su desastre financiero, y quizá podríamos haber esperado que ahora estuviese aún peor que Irlanda. Pero Islandia declaró que no era responsable de las deudas de sus banqueros desbocados, y además contaba con la grandísima ventaja de tener aún su propia moneda, lo cual le facilitó mucho el camino para recuperar la competitividad: se limitaron a dejar caer la corona y, solo con eso, recortaron sus sueldos en un 25% en relación con el euro.

Sin embargo, en España no hay moneda propia. Esto significa que, para ajustar el nivel de costes, España y otros países tendrán que atravesar un largo periodo de tiempo con tasas de desempleo elevadísimas, lo suficientemente altas como para que vayan forzando una muy lenta reducción salarial. Y aquí no termina todo. Los países que ahora se ven obligados a ajustar los costes son los mismos que tuvieron la mayor acumulación de deuda privada antes de la crisis. Ahora se enfrentan a la deflación, que incrementará el peso real de aquel endeudamiento.

Pero ¿qué pasa con la crisis fiscal, las tasas de interés aplicadas a la deuda gubernamental, que se han disparado en el sur de Europa? En gran medida, esta crisis fiscal es un producto derivado del estallido de las burbujas y el descontrol de los costes. Cuando estalló la crisis, el déficit se puso por las nubes, y la deuda también aumentó mucho de golpe cuando los países con problemas actuaron para rescatar sus sistemas bancarios. Y la vía a la que los Gobiernos recurren habitualmente para abordar las cargas del endeudamiento —una combinación de inflación y crecimiento, tal que reduzca la deuda en relación con el PIB— no es un camino viable para los países de la zona euro, que, por el contrario, están condenados a años de deflación y estancamiento. No debe sorprendernos, entonces, que los inversores se pregunten si los países del sur de Europa estarán dispuestos a devolver todas sus deudas, o si serán capaces de hacerlo.

Pero la historia tampoco acaba aquí. Aún hay otro elemento en la crisis del euro, otra debilidad causada por la moneda común, que ha cogido a muchas personas por sorpresa; y aquí me incluyo entre ellas. Resulta que los países sin moneda propia son muy vulnerables a caer víctimas de un pánico que acarrea su propio cumplimiento; un pánico en el que el empeño de los inversores por evitar pérdidas por impago termina desencadenando precisamente el impago temido.

El primero en señalarlo fue el economista belga Paul de Grawe, cuando hizo ver que las tasas de interés de la deuda británica son muy inferiores a las de la española —el 2% frente al 5%, respectivamente, en el momento de escribir—, pese a que Reino Unido tiene más deuda y más déficit y, posiblemente, una perspectiva fiscal peor que la española, aun teniendo en cuenta la deflación de España. Pero tal como apuntó De Grawe, España se enfrenta a un riesgo del que Reino Unido está libre: la congelación de la liquidez.

¿Qué quiere decir esto? Casi todos los Gobiernos modernos tienen una deuda cuantiosa, y no toda son bonos a treinta años; hay mucha deuda a cortísimo plazo, con un vencimiento de tan solo unos meses, además de bonos a dos, tres o cinco años, un buen número de los cuales vence en cualquier año dado. Los Gobiernos dependen de su capacidad de refinanciar la mayor parte de esta deuda; de hecho, venden bonos nuevos para pagar los viejos. Si, por alguna razón, los inversores se negasen a comprar bonos nuevos, hasta un Gobierno esencialmente solvente podría verse obligado al impago.

¿Puede suceder algo así en EE UU? No, en realidad, no; porque la Reserva Federal podría intervenir, y lo haría, comprando la deuda federal, imprimiendo de hecho más dinero para pagar las facturas del Gobierno. Tampoco podría ocurrirle a Reino Unido, a Japón o a cualquier otro país que pide prestado el dinero en su propia moneda y dispone de su propio banco central. Pero sí les puede suceder a cualquiera de los países que están ahora en la zona euro, que no pueden contar con que el Banco Central Europeo les dé efectivo en caso de emergencia. Y si un país de la zona euro se ve obligado a no pagar sus deudas por esta clase de restricción del efectivo, tal vez nunca logre devolver la deuda por completo.

Esto crea, inmediatamente, la posibilidad de una crisis que acarree su propio cumplimiento, en la que el temor de los inversores ante un posible impago derivado de la falta de efectivo les llevaría a rechazar los bonos de ese país, lo cual provocaría la misma falta de dinero que temían. Y pese a que todavía no se ha producido una crisis de este tipo, es fácil ver cómo la inquietud constante ante la posibilidad de que estalle una de ellas puede llevar a los inversores a pedir tasas de interés más elevadas para mantener la deuda de los países susceptibles, en potencia, de caer en esta clase de pánico autorrealizante.

Evidentemente, desde principios de 2011, el euro ha supuesto una clara penalización: los países que usan el euro tienen que afrontar costes de préstamo más elevados que otros países con un panorama económico y fiscal parecido, pero que mantienen la moneda propia. No se trata solamente de España frente a Reino Unido; mi comparación favorita reúne a los tres países escandinavos: Finlandia, Suecia y Dinamarca. Aunque todos ellos son dignos de considerarse países de alta solvencia, sin embargo, Finlandia (que está dentro del euro) ha visto cómo sus costes de préstamo se incrementan sustancialmente más que los de Suecia (que ha conservado su moneda propia, con libre flotación) e incluso los de Dinamarca (que mantiene un tipo de cambio fijo con respecto al euro, pero conserva su moneda y, por tanto, la posibilidad de salir por sí sola del apuro, si falta el efectivo).

Salvar el euro

Dados los problemas que está sufriendo el euro en la actualidad, se diría que los euroescépticos —los que advirtieron a Europa de que, en realidad, no estaba bien preparada para tener una moneda única— estaban en lo cierto. Además, aquellos países que decidieron no adoptar el euro —Reino Unido, Suecia— lo están pasando mucho menos mal que sus vecinos del euro. Así pues, los países europeos que ahora tienen problemas ¿deberían invertir el curso, sencillamente, y volver a sus monedas independientes?

No necesariamente. Hasta los euroescépticos como yo nos damos cuenta de que romper el euro ahora que ya existe se pagaría muy caro.

En primer lugar, cualquier país que pareciera candidato a abandonar el euro se enfrentaría, de inmediato, a una descomunal estampida bancaria, puesto que los depositantes correrían a desplazar sus fondos a otras euronaciones más sólidas. Y la vuelta del dracma o de la peseta provocaría enormes problemas legales, cuando todo el mundo intentara esclarecer el significado de las deudas y los contratos expresados en euros.

Además, un cambio de postura radical en relación con el euro representaría una derrota política terrible para el proyecto europeo más amplio de unidad y democracia a través de la integración económica; y este proyecto, como dije al principio, es muy importante no solo para Europa sino para el mundo entero.

En consecuencia, sería mejor encontrar una forma de salvar al euro. ¿Cómo se podría conseguir?

Lo primero, y más urgente, es que Europa ponga coto a los ataques de pánico. De un modo u otro, tiene que haber garantías de una liquidez adecuada —garantías de que los Gobiernos no se quedarán sin dinero a consecuencia del pánico en el mercado—, comparables a las que existen en la práctica para los Gobiernos que asumen préstamos en su propia moneda. La forma más clara de lograrlo sería que el Banco Central Europeo estuviera preparado para comprar bonos gubernamentales de los países del euro.

En segundo lugar, esos países cuyos costes y precios se deben ajustar —los países europeos que han venido generando grandes déficits comerciales, pero que no pueden continuar haciéndolo— necesitan vías realistas de retorno a la competitividad. A corto plazo, los países con excedente tienen que ser la fuente de una gran demanda de exportaciones. Y, con el tiempo, si este camino no termina conllevando una deflación carísima en los países deficitarios, tendrá que implicar una inflación moderada, pero significativa, en los países excedentarios, y una tasa de inflación algo menor pero aún importante —digamos de un 3% o 4%— para la zona euro en su conjunto. Todo esto exige una política monetaria muy expansiva por parte del Banco Central Europeo, además de un estímulo fiscal en Alemania y unos pocos países más pequeños.

Por último, aunque las cuestiones fiscales no están en el meollo del problema, en el punto actual los países deficitarios tienen problemas de déficit y endeudamiento y tendrán que poner en práctica medidas de considerable austeridad fiscal, durante un tiempo, para ordenar sus sistemas fiscales.

Esto es lo que se necesitaría, probablemente, para salvar el euro. Pero ¿qué posibilidades hay de que lo veamos?

El Banco Central Europeo nos ha sorprendido de manera positiva desde que Mario Draghi relevó a Jean-Claude Trichet en la presidencia. Cierto es que Draghi se negó en redondo a admitir que el banco comprara bonos procedentes de los países en crisis. Pero encontró un modo de conseguir un resultado más o menos similar por la puerta de atrás: anunció un programa por el cual el BCE avanzaría préstamos ilimitados a los bancos privados y aceptaría bonos de los Gobiernos europeos como garantía secundaria. El resultado ha sido que, en el panorama general (al menos, mientras escribo estas páginas), el pánico autorrealizante parece menos inminente y, con ello, las tasas de interés de los bonos europeos se han reducido.

Pese a esto, sin embargo, los casos más extremos —Grecia, Portugal e Irlanda— siguen excluidos de los mercados de capital privado. Por lo tanto, han dependido de una serie de programas de préstamo ad hoc, establecidos por una troika compuesta por los Gobiernos europeos más fuertes, el BCE y el Fondo Monetario Internacional. Por desgracia, la troika siempre ha proporcionado el dinero en cantidad insuficiente y sin la celeridad necesaria. Además, a cambio de estos préstamos de emergencia, los países deficitarios se han visto obligados a imponer programas de recorte de gastos inmediatos y draconianos, además de subidas de los impuestos. En consecuencia, estos programas los empujan a pozos aún más hondos y siguen siendo demasiado escasos aun en términos exclusivamente presupuestarios, ya que las economías en recesión también sufren la caída de los ingresos tributarios.

Mientras tanto, no se ha hecho nada para ofrecer un entorno en el que los países deficitarios encuentren una vía razonable para recuperar su competitividad. Mientras los países con déficit se ven forzados a adoptar medidas de austeridad salvajes, los países con superávit se han metido por su cuenta en programas de austeridad, lo cual socava las esperanzas de un crecimiento de las exportaciones. Y en lugar de admitir que la inflación tiene que ser un poco más alta, el Banco Central Europeo subió los tipos de interés en la primera mitad de 2011, para responder a una amenaza de inflación que solo existía en su imaginación (más adelante dio marcha atrás al incremento de los tipos, pero para entonces ya se había hecho mucho daño).

¿Por qué Europa ha respondido tan mal a su crisis? Ya he apuntado parte de la respuesta: muchos dirigentes del continente parecen decididos a helenizar el cuento y creer que quienes atraviesan dificultades —no solo Grecia— han llegado ahí por culpa de la irresponsabilidad fiscal. Y, con esta premisa falsa, se busca un remedio falso: si el problema era el despilfarro fiscal, la rectitud fiscal debería ser la solución. Se presenta la economía como una obra moral, pero con otra vuelta de tuerca: en realidad, los pecados por los que se pena jamás tuvieron lugar.

Pero esta es solo una parte de la historia. Que Europa sea incapaz de afrontar sus problemas reales, y que insista en enfrentarse a fantasmas inexistentes, no es en modo alguno exclusiva de este continente. En 2010, buena parte de la élite que determina las políticas a ambos lados del Atlántico se enamoró perdidamente de una serie relacionada de falacias sobre la deuda, la inflación y el crecimiento. Trataré de explicar las falacias y abordaré, también, una tarea mucho más ardua: clarificar por qué tantas personas importantes decidieron apoyar esas falacias. Pero será ya en el capítulo siguiente.


05 Let’s just say it: The Republicans are the problem.

Filed under: economía,future,módulo básico,política — fores @ 4:02 am

Back to previous page


Let’s just say it: The Republicans are the problem.

By Thomas E. Mann and Norman J. Ornstein, Published: April 27

Rep. Allen West, a Florida Republican, was recently captured on video asserting that there are “78 to 81” Democrats in Congress who are members of the Communist Party. Of course, it’s not unusual for some renegade lawmaker from either side of the aisle to say something outrageous. What made West’s comment — right out of the McCarthyite playbook of the 1950s — so striking was the almost complete lack of condemnation from Republican congressional leaders or other major party figures, including the remaining presidential candidates.

It’s not that the GOP leadership agrees with West; it is that such extreme remarks and views are now taken for granted.

We have been studying Washington politics and Congress for more than 40 years, and never have we seen them this dysfunctional. In our past writings, we have criticized both parties when we believed it was warranted. Today, however, we have no choice but to acknowledge that the core of the problem lies with the Republican Party.

The GOP has become an insurgent outlier in American politics. It is ideologically extreme; scornful of compromise; unmoved by conventional understanding of facts, evidence and science; and dismissive of the legitimacy of its political opposition.

When one party moves this far from the mainstream, it makes it nearly impossible for the political system to deal constructively with the country’s challenges.

“Both sides do it” or “There is plenty of blame to go around” are the traditional refuges for an American news media intent on proving its lack of bias, while political scientists prefer generality and neutrality when discussing partisan polarization. Many self-styled bipartisan groups, in their search for common ground, propose solutions that move both sides to the center, a strategy that is simply untenable when one side is so far out of reach.

It is clear that the center of gravity in the Republican Party has shifted sharply to the right. Its once-legendary moderate and center-right legislators in the House and the Senate — think Bob Michel, Mickey Edwards, John Danforth, Chuck Hagel — are virtually extinct.

The post-McGovern Democratic Party, by contrast, while losing the bulk of its conservative Dixiecrat contingent in the decades after the civil rights revolution, has retained a more diverse base. Since the Clinton presidency, it has hewed to the center-left on issues from welfare reform to fiscal policy. While the Democrats may have moved from their 40-yard line to their 25, the Republicans have gone from their 40 to somewhere behind their goal post.

What happened? Of course, there were larger forces at work beyond the realignment of the South. They included the mobilization of social conservatives after the 1973Roe v. Wade decision, the anti-tax movement launched in 1978 by California’s Proposition 13, the rise of conservative talk radio after a congressional pay raise in 1989, and the emergence of Fox News and right-wing blogs. But the real move to the bedrock right starts with two names: Newt Gingrich and Grover Norquist.

From the day he entered Congress in 1979, Gingrich had a strategy to create a Republican majority in the House: convincing voters that the institution was so corrupt that anyone would be better than the incumbents, especially those in the Democratic majority. It took him 16 years, but by bringing ethics charges against Democratic leaders; provoking them into overreactions that enraged Republicans and united them to vote against Democratic initiatives; exploiting scandals to create even more public disgust with politicians; and then recruiting GOP candidates around the country to run against Washington, Democrats and Congress, Gingrich accomplished his goal.

Ironically, after becoming speaker, Gingrich wanted to enhance Congress’s reputation and was content to compromise with President Bill Clinton when it served his interests. But the forces Gingrich unleashed destroyed whatever comity existed across party lines, activated an extreme and virulently anti-Washington base — most recently represented by tea party activists — and helped drive moderate Republicans out of Congress. (Some of his progeny, elected in the early 1990s, moved to the Senate and polarized its culture in the same way.)

Norquist, meanwhile, founded Americans for Tax Reform in 1985 and rolled out his Taxpayer Protection Pledge the following year. The pledge, which binds its signers to never support a tax increase (that includes closing tax loopholes), had been signed as of last year by 238 of the 242 House Republicans and 41 of the 47 GOP senators, according to ATR. The Norquist tax pledge has led to other pledges, on issues such as climate change, that create additional litmus tests that box in moderates and make cross-party coalitions nearly impossible. For Republicans concerned about a primary challenge from the right, the failure to sign such pledges is simply too risky.

Today, thanks to the GOP, compromise has gone out the window in Washington. In the first two years of the Obama administration, nearly every presidential initiative met with vehement, rancorous and unanimous Republican opposition in the House and the Senate, followed by efforts to delegitimize the results and repeal the policies. The filibuster, once relegated to a handful of major national issues in a given Congress, became a routine weapon of obstruction, applied even to widely supported bills or presidential nominations. And Republicans in the Senate have abused the confirmation process to block any and every nominee to posts such as the head of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, solely to keep laws that were legitimately enacted from being implemented.

In the third and now fourth years of the Obama presidency, divided government has produced something closer to complete gridlock than we have ever seen in our time in Washington, with partisan divides even leading last year to America’s first credit downgrade.

On financial stabilization and economic recovery, on deficits and debt, on climate change and health-care reform, Republicans have been the force behind the widening ideological gaps and the strategic use of partisanship. In the presidential campaign and in Congress, GOP leaders have embraced fanciful policies on taxes and spending, kowtowing to their party’s most strident voices.

Republicans often dismiss nonpartisan analyses of the nature of problems and the impact of policies when those assessments don’t fit their ideology. In the face of the deepest economic downturn since the Great Depression, the party’s leaders and their outside acolytes insisted on obeisance to a supply-side view of economic growth — thus fulfilling Norquist’s pledge — while ignoring contrary considerations.

The results can border on the absurd: In early 2009, several of the eight Republican co-sponsors of a bipartisan health-care reform plan dropped their support; by early 2010, the others had turned on their own proposal so that there would be zero GOP backing for any bill that came within a mile of Obama’s reform initiative. As one co-sponsor, Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.), told The Washington Post’s Ezra Klein: “I liked it because it was bipartisan. I wouldn’t have voted for it.”

And seven Republican co-sponsors of a Senate resolution to create a debt-reduction panel voted in January 2010 against their own resolution, solely to keep it from getting to the 60-vote threshold Republicans demanded and thus denying the president a seeming victory.

This attitude filters down far deeper than the party leadership. Rank-and-file GOP voters endorse the strategy that the party’s elites have adopted, eschewing compromise to solve problems and insisting on principle, even if it leads to gridlock. Democratic voters, by contrast, along with self-identified independents, are more likely to favor deal-making over deadlock.

Democrats are hardly blameless, and they have their own extreme wing and their own predilection for hardball politics. But these tendencies do not routinely veer outside the normal bounds of robust politics. If anything, under the presidencies of Clinton and Obama, the Democrats have become more of a status-quo party. They are centrist protectors of government, reluctantly willing to revamp programs and trim retirement and health benefits to maintain its central commitments in the face of fiscal pressures.

No doubt, Democrats were not exactly warm and fuzzy toward George W. Bush during his presidency. But recall that they worked hand in glove with the Republican president on the No Child Left Behind Act, provided crucial votes in the Senate for his tax cuts, joined with Republicans for all the steps taken after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks and supplied the key votes for the Bush administration’s financial bailout at the height of the economic crisis in 2008. The difference is striking.

The GOP’s evolution has become too much for some longtime Republicans. Former senator Chuck Hagel of Nebraskacalled his party “irresponsible” in an interview with the Financial Times in August, at the height of the debt-ceiling battle. “I think the Republican Party is captive to political movements that are very ideological, that are very narrow,” he said. “I’ve never seen so much intolerance as I see today in American politics.”

And Mike Lofgren, a veteran Republican congressional staffer, wrote an anguished diatribe last year about why he was ending his career on the Hill after nearly three decades. “The Republican Party is becoming less and less like a traditional political party in a representative democracy and becoming more like an apocalyptic cult, or one of the intensely ideological authoritarian parties of 20th century Europe,” he wrote on the Truthout Web site.

Shortly before Rep. West went off the rails with his accusations of communism in the Democratic Party, political scientists Keith Poole and Howard Rosenthal, who have long tracked historical trends in political polarization, said their studies of congressional votes found that Republicans are now more conservative than they have been in more than a century. Their data show a dramatic uptick in polarization, mostly caused by the sharp rightward move of the GOP.

If our democracy is to regain its health and vitality, the culture and ideological center of the Republican Party must change. In the short run, without a massive (and unlikely) across-the-board rejection of the GOP at the polls, that will not happen. If anything, Washington’s ideological divide will probably grow after the 2012 elections.

In the House, some of the remaining centrist and conservative “Blue Dog” Democrats have been targeted for extinction by redistricting, while even ardent tea party Republicans, such as freshman Rep. Alan Nunnelee (Miss.), have faced primary challenges from the right for being too accommodationist. And Mitt Romney’s rhetoric and positions offer no indication that he would govern differently if his party captures the White House and both chambers of Congress.

We understand the values of mainstream journalists, including the effort to report both sides of a story. But a balanced treatment of an unbalanced phenomenon distorts reality. If the political dynamics of Washington are unlikely to change anytime soon, at least we should change the way that reality is portrayed to the public.

Our advice to the press: Don’t seek professional safety through the even-handed, unfiltered presentation of opposing views. Which politician is telling the truth? Who is taking hostages, at what risks and to what ends?

Also, stop lending legitimacy to Senate filibusters by treating a 60-vote hurdle as routine. The framers certainly didn’t intend it to be. Report individual senators’ abusive use of holds and identify every time the minority party uses a filibuster to kill a bill or nomination with majority support.

Look ahead to the likely consequences of voters’ choices in the November elections. How would the candidates govern? What could they accomplish? What differences can people expect from a unified Republican or Democratic government, or one divided between the parties?

In the end, while the press can make certain political choices understandable, it is up to voters to decide. If they can punish ideological extremism at the polls and look skeptically upon candidates who profess to reject all dialogue and bargaining with opponents, then an insurgent outlier party will have some impetus to return to the center. Otherwise, our politics will get worse before it gets better.

tmann@brookings.edu

nornstein@aei.org

Thomas E. Mann is a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, and Norman J. Ornstein is a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute. This essay is adapted from their book “It’s Even Worse Than It Looks: How the American Constitutional System Collided With the New Politics of Extremism,” which will be available Tuesday.

April 27, 2012

05 Cispa cybersecurity bill passed by House of Representatives

Filed under: economía,future,Holístico,política,tecnología — fores @ 3:29 pm

Cispa cybersecurity bill passed by House of Representatives

Republican-controlled House defies Obama over legislation to prevent electronic attacks on US

    • Share 106 Associated Press in Washington
    • guardian.co.uk, Friday 27 April 2012 05.12 EDT
    • Article history
    • John Boehner


      House speaker John Boehner: ‘The White House believes the government ought to control the internet.’ Photograph: Jacquelyn Martin/AP

      The House of Representatives has ignored objections from Barack Obama’s administration and approved legislation aimed at helping to thwart electronic attacks on critical US infrastructure and private companies.

      On a bipartisan vote of 248-168, the Republican-controlled House backed the Cyber Intelligence Sharing and Protection Act (Cispa), which would encourage companies and the federal government to share information collected on the internet to prevent electronic attacks from cybercriminals, foreign governments and terrorists.

      “This is the last bastion of things we need to do to protect this country,” Republican Mike Rogers, chairman of the House intelligence committee, said after more than five hours of debate.

      More than 10 years after the September  11 terror attacks in 2001, proponents cast the bill as an initial step to deal with an evolving threat of the internet age. The information-sharing would be voluntary to avoid imposing new regulations on businesses, an imperative for Republicans.

      The legislation would allow the government to relay cyber threat information to a company to prevent attacks from Russia or China. In the private sector, corporations could alert the government and provide data that could stop an attack intended to disrupt the country’s water supply or take down the banking system.

      The Obama administration has threatened a veto of the House bill, preferring a Senate measure that would give the homeland security department the primary role in overseeing domestic cybersecurity and the authority to set security standards. That Senate bill remains stalled.

      The Republican House speaker, John Boehner, said the administration’s approach was misguided.

      “The White House believes the government ought to control the internet, government ought to set standards and government ought to take care of everything that’s needed for cybersecurity,” Boehner told reporters at his weekly news conference. “They’re in a camp all by themselves.”

      Faced with widespread privacy concerns, Rogers and Republican CA “Dutch” Ruppersberger , the intelligence panel’s top Democrat, pulled together an amendment that limits the government’s use of threat information to five specific purposes: cybersecurity; investigation and prosecution of cybersecurity crimes; protection of individuals from death or serious bodily harm; protection of minors from child pornography; and the protection of national security.

      The House passed the amendment by 410 votes to three.

      The White House, along with a coalition of liberal and conservative groups and lawmakers, strongly opposed the measure, complaining that Americans’ privacy could be violated. They argued that companies could share an employee’s personal information with the government, data that could end up in the hands of officials from the National Security Agency or the defence department. They also challenged the bill’s liability waiver for private companies that disclose information, complaining it was too broad.

      “Once in government hands, this information can be used for undefined ‘national security’ purposes unrelated to cybersecurity,” a coalition that included the American Civil Liberties Union and former conservative Republican representative Bob Barr, lawmakers said on Thursday.

      Echoing those concerns were several Republicans and Democrats who warned of potential government spying on its citizens with the help of employers.

      “In an effort to foster information sharing, this bill would erode the privacy protections of every single American using the internet. It would create a ‘wild west’ of information sharing,” said Republican Bennie Thompson of Mississippi, the leading Democrat on the House homeland security committee.

      Republican representative Joe Barton said: “Until we protect the privacy rights of our citizens, the solution is worse than the problem.”

      Countering criticism of Big Brother run amok, proponents argued that the bill does not allow the government to monitor private networks, read private emails or close a website. It urges companies that share data to remove personal information.

      “There is no government surveillance, none, not any in this bill,” Rogers said.

      Among the amendments the House approved was one by Republican Justin Amash that put certain personal information off limits: library, medical and gun sale records, tax returns and education documents.

      “I don’t know why the government would want to snoop through library records or tax returns to counter the cybersecurity threat,” Amash said.

      The House approved his amendment by 415-0.

      Trumping any privacy concerns were the national security argument, always powerful in an election year, and Republicans’ political desire to complete a bill that would then force the Democratic-led Senate to act.

      The Obama administration backs a Senate bill sponsored by senators Joe Lieberman, an Independent, and Republican Susan Collins, that gives homeland security the authority to establish security standards.

      However, that legislation faces opposition from senior Senate Republicans.

      Arizona senator John McCain, the leading Republican on the Senate armed services committee, said during a hearing last month that the homeland security department was “probably the most inefficient bureaucracy that I have ever encountered” and was ill-equipped to determine how best to secure the nation’s essential infrastructure. McCain has introduced a competing bill.

      • This article was amended on Friday 27 April to correct a mistake in the headline. It originally said the bill had been passed by the Senate. This has been corrected.

April 24, 2012

05 Occupy Wall Street: what is to be done next?

Filed under: future,George Lakoff,Holístico,módulo básico,política — fores @ 3:53 pm

Occupy Wall Street: what is to be done next?

How to think past the paradox of a protest movement without a programme confronting a capitalist system that defies reform

  • occupy oakland november


    A demonstrator in Oakland holds a sign on 2 November, 2011. Photograph: Eric Thayer/Getty Images

    What to do in the aftermath of the Occupy Wall Street movement, when the protests that started far away – in the Middle East, Greece, Spain, UK – reached the centre, and are now reinforced and rolling out all around the world?

    In a San Francisco echo of the OWS movement on 16 October 2011, a guy addressed the crowd with an invitation to participate in it as if it were a happening in the hippy style of the 1960s:

    “They are asking us what is our program. We have no program. We are here to have a good time.”

    Such statements display one of the great dangers the protesters are facing: the danger that they will fall in love with themselves, with the nice time they are having in the “occupied” places. Carnivals come cheap – the true test of their worth is what remains the day after, how our normal daily life will be changed. The protesters should fall in love with hard and patient work – they are the beginning, not the end. Their basic message is: the taboo is broken, we do not live in the best possible world; we are allowed, obliged even, to think about alternatives.

    In a kind of Hegelian triad, the western left has come full circle: after abandoning the so-called “class struggle essentialism” for the plurality of anti-racist, feminist etc struggles, “capitalism” is now clearly re-emerging as the name of the problem.

    The first two things one should prohibit are therefore the critique of corruption and the critique of financial capitalism. First, let us not blame people and their attitudes: the problem is not corruption or greed, the problem is the system that pushes you to be corrupt. The solution is neither Main Street nor Wall Street, but to change the system where Main Street cannot function without Wall Street. Public figures from the pope downward bombard us with injunctions to fight the culture of excessive greed and consummation – this disgusting spectacle of cheap moralization is an ideological operation, if there ever was one: the compulsion (to expand) inscribed into the system itself is translated into personal sin, into a private psychological propensity, or, as one of the theologians close to the pope put it:

    “The present crisis is not crisis of capitalism but the crisis of morality.”

    Let us recall the famous joke from Ernst Lubitch’s Ninotchka: the hero visits a cafeteria and orders coffee without cream; the waiter replies:

    “Sorry, but we have run out of cream, we only have milk. Can I bring you coffee without milk?”

    Was not a similar trick at work in the dissolution of the eastern european Communist regimes in 1990? The people who protested wanted freedom and democracy without corruption and exploitation, and what they got was freedom and democracy without solidarity and justice. Likewise, the Catholic theologian close to pope is carefully emphasizing that the protesters should target moral injustice, greed, consumerism etc, without capitalism. The self-propelling circulation of Capital remains more than ever the ultimate Real of our lives, a beast that by definition cannot be controlled.

    One should avoid the temptation of the narcissism of the lost cause, of admiring the sublime beauty of uprisings doomed to fail. What new positive order should replace the old one the day after, when the sublime enthusiasm of the uprising is over? It is at this crucial point that we encounter the fatal weakness of the protests: they express an authentic rage which is not able to transform itself into a minimal positive program of socio-political change. They express a spirit of revolt without revolution.

    Reacting to the Paris protests of 1968, Lacan said:

    “What you aspire to as revolutionaries is a new master. You will get one.”

    It seems that Lacan’s remark found its target (not only) in the indignados of Spain. Insofar as their protest remains at the level of a hysterical provocation of the master, without a positive program for the new order to replace the old one, it effectively functions as a call for a new master, albeit disavowed.

    We got the first glimpse of this new master in Greece and Italy, and Spain will probably follow. As if ironically answering the lack of expert programs of the protesters, the trend is now to replace politicians in the government with a “neutral” government of depoliticized technocrats (mostly bankers, as in Greece and Italy). Colorful “politicians” are out, grey experts are in. This trend is clearly moving towards a permanent emergency state and the suspension of political democracy.

    So we should see in this development also a challenge: it is not enough to reject the depoliticized expert rule as the most ruthless form of ideology; one should also begin to think seriously about what to propose instead of the predominant economic organization, to imagine and experiment with alternate forms of organization, to search for the germs of the New. Communism is not just or predominantly the carnival of the mass protest when the system is brought to a halt; Communism is also, above all, a new form of organization, discipline, hard work.

    The protesters should beware not only of enemies, but also of false friends who pretend to support them, but are already working hard to dilute the protest. In the same way we get coffee without caffeine, beer without alcohol, ice-cream without fat, they will try to make the protests into a harmless moralistic gesture. In boxing, to “clinch” means to hold the opponent’s body with one or both arms in order to prevent or hinder punches. Bill Clinton‘s reaction to the Wall Street protests is a perfect case of political clinching; Clinton thinks that the protests are “on balance … a positive thing”, but he is worried about the nebulousness of the cause. Clinton suggested the protesters get behind President Obama’s jobs plan, which he claimed would create “a couple million jobs in the next year and a half”. What one should resist at this stage is precisely such a quick translation of the energy of the protest into a set of “concrete” pragmatic demands. Yes, the protests did create a vacuum – a vacuum in the field of hegemonic ideology, and time is needed to fill this vacuum in in a proper way, since it is a pregnant vacuum, an opening for the truly New. The reason protesters went out is that they had enough of the world where to recycle your Coke cans, to give a couple of dollars for charity, or to buy Starbucks cappuccino where 1% goes for the third world troubles is enough to make them feel good.

    Economic globalization is gradually but inexorably undermining the legitimacy of western democracies. Due to their international character, large economic processes cannot be controlled by democratic mechanisms which are, by definition, limited to nation states. In this way, people more and more experience institutional democratic forms as unable to capture their vital interests.

    It is here that Marx’s key insight remains valid, today perhaps more than ever: for Marx, the question of freedom should not be located primarily into the political sphere proper. The key to actual freedom rather resides in the “apolitical” network of social relations, from the market to the family, where the change needed if we want an actual improvement is not a political reform, but a change in the “apolitical” social relations of production. We do not vote about who owns what, about relations in a factory, etc – all this is left to processes outside the sphere of the political. It is illusory to expect that one can effectively change things by “extending” democracy into this sphere, say, by organizing “democratic” banks under people’s control. In such “democratic” procedures (which, of course, can have a positive role to play), no matter how radical our anti-capitalism is, the solution is sought in applying the democratic mechanisms – which, one should never forget, are part of the state apparatuses of the “bourgeois” state that guarantees undisturbed functioning of the capitalist reproduction.

    The emergence of an international protest movement without a coherent program is therefore not an accident: it reflects a deeper crisis, one without an obvious solution. The situation is like that of psychoanalysis, where the patient knows the answer (his symptoms sare such answers) but doesn’t know to what they are answers, and the analyst has to formulate a question. Only through such a patient work a program will emerge.

    In an old joke from the defunct German Democratic Republic, a German worker gets a job in Siberia. Aaware of how all mail will be read by censors, he tells his friends:

    “Let’s establish a code: if a letter you will get from me is written in ordinary blue ink, it is true; if it is written in red ink, it is false.”

    After a month, his friends get the first letter written in blue ink:

    “Everything is wonderful here: stores are full, food is abundant, apartments are large and properly heated, movie theatres show films from the west, there are many beautiful girls ready for an affair – the only thing unavailable is red ink.”

    And is this not our situation till now? We have all the freedoms one wants – the only thing missing is the “red ink”: we feel free because we lack the very language to articulate our unfreedom. What this lack of red ink means is that, today, all the main terms we use to designate the present conflict – “war on terror”, “democracy and freedom”, “human rights”, etc – are false terms, mystifying our perception of the situation instead of allowing us to think it.

    The task today is to give the protesters red ink.

    NYPL logo

    • This article is based on remarks Slavoj Žižek will be making at an event at the New York Public Library on 25 April, ahead of publication of The Year of Dreaming Dangerously (2012).

  • Print this

April 21, 2012

05 The presence of Africans in Elizabethan England and the performance of Titus Andronicus

The presence of Africans in Elizabethan England and the performance of Titus Andronicus at Burley-on-the-Hill, 1595/96.


Link to this page

In 1594 Shakespeare confronted the Elizabethans with the dramatic figure of Aaron, a literate African trained in the classics. Shakespeare’s characterization of Aaron presented a striking departure from the established discourse of black inferiority. The novelty was calculated, in the first place, to unsettle the average Elizabethan theatergoer. It could not, however, have been a surprise to those playgoers who had a university education or to those courtiers and noblemen, like the Haringtons and Sidneys, who had been cultivating cultural relations with the Continent and had learned how to shape their beliefs and views in the light of the Spanish and Portuguese experience. There was, moreover, another category of spectators, the descendants of those English merchants who had pioneered slaveholding slave·hold·er  
n.
One who owns or holds slaves.


slaveholding adj. and dealng in early modern Andalusia from 1480 to 1532. The Mediterranean apprenticeship of slavery has been left unrecorded owing to owing to
prep.
Because of; on account of: I couldn’t attend, owing to illness.

owing to prep → debido a, por causa de  the one-sided attention of Africanists and historians to the development of English slavery in the seventeenth century. I am going to make some use of the material I have uncovered from Spanish archives at the end of the present paper.

We must, moreover, bear in mind that the Elizabethans had witnessed the haphazard attempts made by the authorities to accommodate the presence of black Africans and Moors to the structure of Elizabethan society. The black presence, particularly in the last decade of the sixteenth century, had raised anxieties about interbreeding interbreeding

crossbreeding, as between half-breds.  that asked to be addressed. This was the case particularly between 1592 and 1594, when the government was embroiled em·broil  
tr.v. em·broiled, em·broil·ing, em·broils
1. To involve in argument, contention, or hostile actions: “Avoid . . .  in the hitherto little noticed scandal caused by the legal and illegal importation of slaves from Guinea. I have, therefore, felt obliged to unfold the still poorly documented history of the black presence in Elizabethan England before turning my attention to Shakespeare’s Titus Andronicus Titus Andronicus

exacts revenge for crimes against his family. [Br. Lit.: Titus Andronicus]

See : Vengeance  as performed at Burley-on-the-Hill by the Chamberlain’s Men Chamberlain’s Men, Elizabethan theatrical company for which Shakespeare, a joint owner of the company, wrote his plays and served as actor. Organized in 1594, they performed at the Globe and at the Blackfriars theaters. Under the patronage of James I they became c.  on January 1, 1596. The per- formance had been designed by Sir John Harington Sir John Harington (August 4, 1561 – November 20, 1612) was a courtier and author. He became a prominent member of Queen Elizabeth I’s court, and was known as her ‘saucy Godson’.  to be the political and cultural climax of his lavish Christmas festivities

The Presence of Africans in Elizabethan England

The presence of Africans in early modern England has remained a subject in its infant stage of studies. As late as the 1980s, historians clung to the view that there is no way of establishing how many colored persons had been taken to or had settled in early modern England. However, Rosalyn L. Knutson has opened up new research strategies. She is the first to have undertaken systematic investigation and has succeeded in gathering fresh material from the entries of baptisms and burials kept in the London parish records. (1)

The major difficulty in gathering reliable information has proved the absence of a regulated slave trade slave trade

Capturing, selling, and buying of slaves. Slavery has existed throughout the world from ancient times, and trading in slaves has been equally universal. Slaves were taken from the Slavs and Iranians from antiquity to the 19th century, from the sub-Saharan  in early modern England. Whereas in Portugal and Spain the import of slaves was a government monopoly In economics, government monopoly (or public monopoly) is a form of coercive monopoly in which a government agency is the sole provider of a particular good or service and competition is prohibited by law. , England disposed of no legal code for operating a slave system under the Tudor monarchs. Hence there were no customs duties Tariffs or taxes payable on merchandise imported or exported from one country to another.

Customs laws seek to equalize the charges imposed by other countries, furnish income for the federal government, and preserve the financial stability of domestic industries.  levied on imported slaves. There was, however, an annual per capita [Latin, By the heads or polls.] A term used in the Descent and Distribution of the estate of one who dies without a will. It means to share and share alike according to the number of individuals. tax. This was, in effect, a poll tax of 8d levied by the municipal authorities. (2) The English authorities came close to conceding a royal monopoly on the import of slaves in the Guinea charter of 1588, a memorable event of its own that took place in the year of the Armada and that, surprisingly, Africanist historians have not taken any notice of (see below).

The majority of the Africans were black domestic slaves, a few were freedmen, and some of them were Moors, mostly Berbers from North Africa. The contemporary blanket term A blanket term is a word or phrase that is used to describe multiple groups of related things. The degree of relation may vary. Blanket terms often trade specificity for ease-of-use; in other words, a blanket term by itself gives little detail about the things that it describes or  for them all was blackamoor. The seeming absence of records documenting their presence would argue the case for the existence of a negligible number of colored servants. (3) On second thoughts, however, the marginalized African population must have assumed a sizable volume, conspicuous and large enough to be of concern to the government, which thought it opportune to take countermeasures. The “discontented dis·con·tent·ed  
adj.
Restlessly unhappy; malcontent.


discon·tent ” queen, in view of the “great numbers of Negars and Blackamoors Blackamoors may refer to:

  • Blackamoor, a device in heraldry
  • Blackamoor, a type of jewelry
  • Blackamoor, slang for a dark skinned person
  • Blackamoor, a small fish also called a black tetra (Gymnocorymbus ternetzi)
  • Blackamoors, sculptures of Negro figures

which … are crept into this realm,” issued two expulsion edicts in July 1596 and a third in 1601. The royal orders, however, were of no consequence, for as long as the Africans were granted no legal status and the owners enjoyed the freedom of an unregulated market, the queen’s policy of containment was simply ignored. The 1590s were a decade of poor harvests, food shortages, and poverty, but the queen’s anxiety that, I dare say, approximately half a percent of London’s population were taking jobs away from the English seems to be unwarranted. Similar concerns had been raised in Portugal in the 1560s when the African population of the Portuguese capital had risen to 10 percent. (4)

English Female Slaveholders

A good many misconceptions about the black and colored population in early modern England are due to the fact that the issue of the black presence has not yet overcome the difficulties and misconceptions of a nascent discipline. Thus the majority of the African servants were not curiosities, neither were they oddities nor status symbols, as some scholars would make us believe. On the contrary, they were like their cousins in Spain and Portugal hardworking domestic servants whom, to put it in Shylock’s terms, the Venetian (English) owners would “use in abject and in slavish slav·ish  
adj.
1. Of or characteristic of a slave or slavery; servile: Her slavish devotion to her job ruled her life.

2. parts.” Moreover, a serious oversimplification o·ver·sim·pli·fy  
v. o·ver·sim·pli·fied, o·ver·sim·pli·fy·ing, o·ver·sim·pli·fies

v.tr.
To simplify to the point of causing misrepresentation, misconception, or error.

v.intr. perpetrated by current historical work has been to neglect the problem of gender difference as regards both the slaves and the slave owners This list includes notable individuals for which there is a consensus of evidence of slave ownership. A

  • Abraham
  • Anedjib (Egyptian Pharaoh)

B

  • Simon Bolivar, Latin American independence leader

C

  • Augustus Caesar

. I have, therefore, thought it opportune to discuss some records that shed new light on the ignored gender issue. It is a most striking feature that Englishwomen of all social classes, from low to high class, and even to royalty, should emerge as slave owners as if they had been emulating their Spanish and Portuguese counterparts, who did not hesitate to attend public auctions, selling and buying slaves in great numbers. (5) Thus the queen kept black artists, Lady Ralegh called a black servant her own, Lady Anne Clifford Lady Anne Clifford (January 30, 1590 – March 22, 1676) was the only surviving child of George Clifford, 3rd Earl of Cumberland (1558–1605) by his wife Margaret Russell, daughter of Francis Russell, 2nd Earl of Bedford.  numbered Grace Robinson, a black laundress, and John Morocco, a black servant, among her household staff at Knole some time after 1609, and the seamstress Millicent Porter was present at the christening christening: see baptism.  of her black slave Mary Phillis in 1597. (6)

Grace Robinson has been singled out by Kim F. Hall, in her insightful article “Reading What Isn’t There” (see note 4), as an instance demonstrating that the personal histories of black women are bound to remain irretrievable and that the black female domestic servants, unnamed and stripped of a history of their own, are doomed to remain invisible. Grace Robinson’s alleged invisibility, I dare say, was a matter of social status rather than of color or ethnicity; for it is a commonplace that the personal histories of white female servants are equally difficult to recover. The black laundress Grace Robinson shared the fate of being elided from the narrative of Lady Anne Clifford’s Diary together with her white fellow laundresses. She stands nonetheless the chance of coming into her own if we attempt to pry into the position held by the laundry maids and into their daily work in the large household of Lady Anne Clifford, countess of Dorset after 1609 and countess of Montgomery and of Pembroke after 1630. (7)

From the inventory or “Catalogue of the Household and Family of the Right Honourable Richard, Earl of Dorset The title Earl of Dorset has been created at least four times in the Peerage of England. It was created in 1411 for Thomas Beaufort, who was later created Duke of Exeter. The peerages became extinct on his death. ,” which was begun in 1613 and completed on the earl’s death in 1624, it emerges that Grace Robinson was one of several dozen servants who are all mentioned by name and listed according to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3. their seating order at various tables, from the lord’s table, the parlor table, the clerks’ table, the long table, the laundry maids’ table, the nursery, the kitchen and scullery scul·ler·y  
n. pl. scul·ler·ies
A small room adjoining a kitchen, in which dishwashing and other kitchen chores are done.


[Middle English, from Old French escuelerie, from . (8) The comprehensive inventory, which still hangs framed under glass at Knole House Knole House (also Knowle House) is a stately home situated close to Sevenoaks in north-west Kent, surrounded by a large, 1000 acre deer park, Knole (or Knowle) Park. , Kent, is obviously conceived to convey to the reader the socializing policy of the earl of Dorset and his wife Lady Anne Clifford, who saw to it that all the members of their household, from the gentlemen ushers This page is a list of Gentlemen Ushers to the British Royal Household from the Restoration up to the present day. Gentlemen Ushers originally formed three classes: Gentlemen Ushers of the Privy Chamber, Gentlemen Ushers Daily Waiters, and Gentlemen Ushers Quarterly Waiters. , grooms of the great horse, to the brewers, gardeners, and huntsmen met in the dining hall on festive occasions. The members seated at the “Laundry Maids’ Table” were, besides Grace Robinson, Mrs Judith and Mrs Grace Simpton, obviously two gentlewomen overseeing the laundry; Penelope Tutty tut·ty  
n. pl. tut·ties
An impure zinc oxide obtained as a sublimate from the flues of zinc-smelting furnaces and used as a polishing powder. , the maid of Margaret Sackville, Lady Anne’s eldest daughter; Anne Mills, the dairymaid; the two goodwives Burton and Small; William Lewis William Lewis may be:

  • William Lewis (scientist) (fl. 1754), British scientist
  • William Lewis (politician) (1868–1959), American politician from Kentucky
  • William Lewis (athlete) (fl.

, porter; and what must have been the four fellow laundresses of Grace Robinson: Prudence Butcher, Anne Howse, Faith Husband, and Elinor Thompson. The catalogue reveals no trace of social or racial marginalization mar·gin·al·ize  
tr.v. mar·gin·al·ized, mar·gin·al·iz·ing, mar·gin·al·iz·es
To relegate or confine to a lower or outer limit or edge, as of social standing. , getting the message across to the reader that the “Blackamoor” laundress was well integrated in the Knole household.

Grace Robinson was indeed working in a team of five laundresses whose duties must have entailed washing, repairing, and possibly sewing the linen and clothes of the household. This was no doubt a burdensome task which demanded great skill and endurance. There is some evidence proving that Lady Anne developed a personal relationship with her personnel and maidservants. Thus in April 1617, she was lying ill in Judith Simpton’s chamber and in her old age, when she was too weak to attend divine service on Sundays, she used to send her four laundry maids and her washerwoman Isabel Jordan to attend the sermon preached by parson Samuel Grasty at Ninekirks Church, Wetsmoreland. A fortnight before she died at Brougham Castle Brougham Castle is about 2 miles to the south-east of Penrith, Cumbria (grid reference NY537290).

This castle was built in the early 13th century by Robert de Vieuxpont (Vipont), near the site of a Roman fort guarding the crossing of the River Eamont.  on March 23, 1676, she took the seamstress Margaret Montgomery, who had come from Penrith to make up twenty pairs of sheets and pillows, to her chamber, and kissed her and talked to her. (9)

Whether Lady Anne Clifford’s personal relations with Grace Robinson were as intimate as with the seamstress Margaret Montgomery remains unproven. But in view of the fact that she felt bound to take special care for the spiritual welfare of her laundresses, it is not unreasonable to assume that she must have developed a particular interest in an African maid who had become a Christian convert. There is historical precedent for the privileged treatment of black female converts by aristocratic women in Europe. Catherine of Austria, wife of the Portuguese king Joao III, who on average numbered some twenty-five black African and Amerindian slaves among her royal household, gave evidence of her particular concern for the welfare of her female maidservants in manumitting her three black laundresses Margarida da Silva, Clemencia da Santa Maria Santa Maria, city, Brazil
Santa Maria (sän`tə mərē`ə), city (1991 pop. 217,592), Rio Grande do Sul state, S Brazil. It is a major railroad terminus and the site of an important military base. , and Catarina da Cruz, in 1554. (10)

A female slaveholder of much lower social profile was Widow Stokes. She dwelt dwelt  
v.
A past tense and a past participle of dwell.  in the parish of All Hallows Barking, Tower Ward, London, where she paid an annual per capita tax of 8d for her servant “Clare, a Negra,” in October 1598 and 1599. (11) Widow Stokes may have exploited Clare as a single maid-of-all-work for the full range of household tasks and may thus have offered Clare immunity fro sexual abuse at the hand of fellow servants. Sleeping arrangements sleeping arrangements sleep npl → Bettenverteilung f still used to be mainly communal. Servants of either sex slept in the same room, and servants of the same sex often shared the bed, a fact that was well known to raise the female servants’ vulnerability to rape, seduction, and, worst of all, the specter of miscegenation Mixture of races. A term formerly applied to marriage between persons of different races. Statutes prohibiting marriage between persons of different races have been held to be invalid as contrary to the equal protection clause  . (12) The possibility that the bedrooms of early English Early English
Noun

a style of architecture used in England in the 12th and 13th centuries, characterized by narrow pointed arches and ornamental intersecting stonework in windows  households were immune to color discrimination cannot be ruled out. In Spain miscegenation was endemic among the servant class; in Elizabethan England it was certainly on the rise. The bold interracial in·ter·ra·cial  
adj.
Relating to, involving, or representing different races: interracial fellowship; an interracial neighborhood.  bedroom scene in Othello (act 5) may have been inspired by the reality experienced in middle-class English households.

A well documented case of a female slaveholder in early modern England is that of Millicent Porter, seamstress. It shows that also women at the lower scale of the social order knew how to take advantage of slaveholding. In January 1584, she was found guilty of “ffornication and adulterye” and was, against her will, “enioyned to make her canonycall purgation PURGATION. The clearing one’s self of an offence charged, by denying the guilt on oath or affirmation.
2. There were two sorts of purgation, the vulgar, and the canonical.
3. ” in the “consistorye place” in St Paul’s, London. After having done public penance, she returned to her parish of St Botolph Aldgate. When exactly the black slave Mary Phillis joined her household is not known, but we do know that on June 3, 1597, Millicent Porter attended the christening of the twenty-year-old Mary together with the curate’s wife, the sexton’s wife, and three other women who stood as godparents godparents npl the godparents → los padrinos

godparents npl the godparents → le parrain et la marraine

godparents npl to Mary Phillis. We have it on the authority of Thomas Harridaunce, the clerk of St Botolph Aldagte, that Mary Phillis answered the curate’s questions about her faith “verie Christenlyke,” and recited the Lord’s Prayer and the “articles of her beliefe.” Thereupon there·up·on  
adv.
1. Concerning that matter; upon that.

2. Directly following that; forthwith.

3. In consequence of that; therefore.  the curate CURATE, eccl. law. One who represents the incumbent of a church, person, or20 vicar, and takes care of the church, and performs divine service in his stead.  took Mary to the font and baptized bap·tize  
v. bap·tized, bap·tiz·ing, bap·tiz·es

v.tr.
1. To admit into Christianity by means of baptism.

2.
a. To cleanse or purify.

b. To initiate.

3. her. These two women, a black slave and what looks like a repentant re·pen·tant  
adj.
Characterized by or demonstrating repentance; penitent.


re·pentant·ly adv.

Adj. 1. prostitute, transcended the habitual relegation RELEGATION, civil law. Among the Romans relegation was a banishment to a certain place, and consequently was an interdiction of all places except the one designated.
2. It differed from deportation. (q.v.) Relegation and deportation agree u these particulars: 1.  of the black African females and of the female delinquents to the margins of society. (13)

The parishioners of St Botolph were certainly unaware of the fact that the christening of Mary was an infringement upon her African past. They looked upon the baptismal rite as conferring a new lease of life on an English-speaking Christian convert, who despite her new cultural and religious identity remained a slave. The presence of a curate officiating the ceremony in a London parish church is proof of the Anglican Church’s toleration TOLERATION. In some. countries, where religion is established by law, certain sects who do not agree with the established religion are nevertheless permitted to exist, and this permission is called toleration.  of slavery as a necessary evil. The Anglican authorities considered slavery as reprehensible rep·re·hen·si·ble  
adj.
Deserving rebuke or censure; blameworthy. See Synonyms at blameworthy.


[Middle English, from Old French, from Late Latin repreh only when English merchants were sold to the Muslims and enticed to convert.

The case of Mary Phillis does not correspond to the culturally defamed representations of the black female domestic figure in Elizabethan and Jacobean drama, nor does the hitherto unrecovered case of twelve-year-old Polonia. On May 5, 1597, Mrs Piers (“Peires”), the mistress of “Polonia, the blackmor maid,” consulted Simon Forman Simon Forman (December 30, 1552 – September, 1611) was a prominent English Elizabethan occultist, astrologist and herbalist active in London. Life
He was born in Quidhampton near Salisbury, Wiltshire.  about her servant’s illness. Forman, in the absence of the patient, cast an astrological figure and below it set down a humoral hu·mor·al
adj.
1. Relating to body fluids, especially serum.

2. Relating to or arising from any of the bodily humors.


Humoral
Pertaining to or derived from a body fluid.  diagnosis, according to which the poor girl was suffering from “Moch pane syd[e] stom[ach]” and was “Lyk to vomit.” Moreover, he found “a feuer in her bones” and diagnosed a “fa[i]nt harte, full of melancoly & cold humors mixed with collor,” i.e., choler choler
n.
1. Anger; irritability.

2. One of the four humors of ancient and medieval physiology, thought to cause anger and bad temper when present in excess. Also called yellow bile. . The remedy he prescribed for her cure was to “purg her of Neptune” and of her vapors. (14)

The absence of the patient during the medical consultation was nothing extraordinary. Of the 132 consultations for children in 1597, forty-five were visits of a parent on behalf of a sick child, and only in thirty-two cases was the child present for the consultation. (15) With the benefit of hindsight we may venture to put down the illness of the twelve-year-old Polonia to menstrual disorders Menstrual Disorders Definition

A menstrual disorder is a physical or emotional problem that interferes with the normal menstrual cycle, causing pain, unusually heavy or light bleeding, delayed menarche, or missed periods.  rather than to the social stress of deculturation.

Polonia’s case marks a watershed event in the annals of cross-cultural en-counters insofar in·so·far  
adv.
To such an extent.

Adv. 1. insofar – to the degree or extent that; “insofar as it can be ascertained, the horse lung is comparable to that of man”; “so far as it is reasonably practical he should practice  as it records the first rapprochement between a black African and a self-made London medical practitioner. Simon Forman, though much maligned ma·lign  
tr.v. ma·ligned, ma·lign·ing, ma·ligns
To make evil, harmful, and often untrue statements about; speak evil of.

adj.
1. Evil in disposition, nature, or intent.

2. and denounced by the College of Physicians as a quack, must be given his due for having treated Polonia as a patient irrespective of irrespective of
prep.
Without consideration of; regardless of.

irrespective of
preposition despite  race, ignoring the ethnic boundaries erected by the cultural discourse of white supremacy white supremacist
n.
One who believes that white people are racially superior to others and should therefore dominate society.


white supremacy n. . An unconventional man operating on the outer fringes of academic life, he seems to have been aware of the historic moment in his medical career, for he was meticulous about the patient’s identity, adding a definite article definite article
n.
A member of the class of determiners that restricts or particularizes a noun. In English, the is the definite article.  that seems to be charged emotionally: “Polonia, the blackmor maid at Mr Peires.” Forman’s professionally impeccable behavior is out of line with the depiction of non-European women in literary and other writings of the period as being “either dangerous … and needing to be … annihilated, or alienated from their own society and made tractable tractable

easy to manage; tolerable. , and therefore ready to be converted and assimiliated into European family and society.” (16)

Mrs Piers was aged twenty-one and had previously consulted Forman on May 3, 1597, regarding an illness of her own. She might also be the mother of “John Peire,” aged three, who had consulted Forman on April 14, 1597. (17) This young woman felt morally obliged to look after the well-being of her juvenile black maidservant although she must have known that black servants enjoyed no legal status in early modern England and therefore was under no legal obligation whatsoever to offer her servant medical treatment.

Polonia’s age profile is worth comment. In Europe the age of twelve was generally considered to mark a girl’s transition from childhood to adult life. Thus in early modern England, the age of consent for marriage was set at twelve for girls. The age of twelve years was also taken to be the ideal age for slave girls to be introduced to the household domestic chores as maids-of-all-work or as companions or nursemaids for young children. (18) This might have been Polonia’s lot if “John Peire,” aged three, was indeed the son of Mrs Peirs. But it was also an age fraught with the danger of a young girl being raped and becoming pregnant. The bawd in Shakespeare’s Pericles has brought up her daughters to the age of eleven and then has reduced them to serve in the brothel. (19) Juliet’s nurse swears by her own “maidenhead Maidenhead, city (1991 pop. 59,809), Windsor and Maidenhead, S central England, on the Thames River. It is a residential town with brewing and milling industries as well as a resort. The 13th-century stone bridge was rebuilt in the 1770s.  at twelve year old,” implying that she was deflowered as soon as she reached the age of twelve. (20) Launcelot, the primary go-between in the play, who shuttles between religious communities and ethnic minorities, commits an act of interracial sex in Portia’s domain at Belmont, impregnating the offstage Mooress, whose age must be put to twelve or thereabouts there·a·bouts   also there·a·bout
adv.
1. Near that place; about there: somewhere in Kansas or thereabouts.

2. About that number, amount, or time. . His impregnation impregnation /im·preg·na·tion/ (im?preg-na´shun)
1. fertilization.

2. saturation (1).


impregnation

1. the act of fertilizing or rendering pregnant.

2. saturation.  of the Mooress may have been meant to evoke a real-life incident in London. (21)

English Merchant Slaveholders

Slaveholding in early modern England was not gender bound; but whereas in the case of female slaveholders all the social classes seem to have participated in the business, in the case of men, slaveholding was mainly concentrated in the hands of the upper echelons of the merchant class. The English merchants stationed in Spain at the turn of the fifteenth/sixteenth century and John Hawkins’s ventures in the Guinea-Caribbean slave trade of 1562/63 and 1564/65 had prepared the ground for holding colored slaves in England, and the English merchants doing business in the Mediterranean and in West Africa West Africa

A region of western Africa between the Sahara Desert and the Gulf of Guinea. It was largely controlled by colonial powers until the 20th century.


West African adj. & n. in the closing decades of the sixteenth century took their cue from them. Among the foreign merchants residing in England, the Portuguese New Christians or conversos, who had been accustomed to keeping and handling slaves before they took refuge in England in the 1540s, enjoyed the privilege of keeping up their old lifestyle, practicing their Jewish rites on the sly, and developing their commercial networks with their old converso partners in Amsterdam, Antwerp, and Constantinople. (See below.)

The double-career men like the Gonsons, the Hawkinses, and the Winters, who had a lifelong experience as members of the inner circle of the naval administration in charge of the royal fleet, had no scruples to take advantage of their public offices to promote their private enterprises. They became involved in slaving voyages as investors, ship owners and seafaring businessmen and did not hesitate to staff their households with colored servants. Evidence, however, is scarce to come by, but as regards Sir William Winter

  • William Winter (author) (1836–1917), American drama critic and author
  • William Winter (chess player) (1898–1955), British chess player
  • William Winter (politician) (b.

(ca. 1525-89) it is conclusive.

William Winter, keeper of the naval records (1546), master of the naval ordnance (1557), invested in and sailed on Thomas Wyndham’s 1553 voyage to Guinea. He then joined the syndicate of Guinea merchants which in 1561 advanced the project of building a fort in Guinea. He was also one of the investors of John Hawkins’s second slaving voyage of 1564/65, and in 1565 he financed, in partnership with his brother George, the voyage of their ship the Mary Fortune, which the Portuguese sank off the Guinea coast, taking the crew prisoner. It is also on record that in 1570 one ship of a fleet of three, owned by William Winter and bound for Guinea to participate in the transatlantic slave trade, sailed back home without reaching the Caribbean. For his services rendered to the navy and for his private ventures he was knighted in 1573. (22)

Had Thomas Harridaunce, the parish clerk parish clerk
Noun

a person who assists in various church duties  of St Botolph Aldgate, not been keeping separate memoranda besides the ordinary parish registers, we might never have known that Sir William Winter even in his old age could not do without a Guinea slave or two working in his household. On August 17, 1587, Harridaunce recorded in his daybook the death of “Domingo Beinge a ginnye Negar” who was “servaunt to the Right worshipfull Sr William Winter” and had died in his London manor house at East Smithfield. (23) We do not know when Domingo entered Winter’s service, it may have been before or after 1570. He may have been part of Winter’s personal booty taken in Guinea from a former Portuguese owner, in which case Domingo would have been an institution among possible black fellow servants, or Winter may have bought him in London from a business partner any time after 1570.

The Guinea Charter of 1588-98

The diplomatic interventions of the Portuguese and the subsequent treaty signed by the English and the Portuguese governments in 1576 brought about a slump in the English Guinea trade. However, the exile of Dom Antonio, the claimant to the Portuguese throne, gave an unexpected impetus to the resumption of the Guinea or rather the Senegambian slave trade. Dom Antonio sought refuge in England in the aftermath of the Portuguese dynastic crisis of 1578/80, accompanied by a retinue of some forty-eight attendants, among them the mulatto MULATTO. A person born of one white and one black parent. 7 Mass. R. 88; 2 Bailey, 558.  Pedro Fernandes. The renewal of the slave trade under the auspices of the English government and Dom Antonio has passed unnoticed by English historians. A comprehensive study of the historical, cultural, and ethnic dimensions of the first Guinea charter (1588-98) remains a desideratum de·sid·er·a·tum  
n. pl. de·sid·er·a·ta
Something considered necessary or highly desirable: “The point is not that the artist has ‘penetrated the character’ of his sitter, that commonplace desideratum of . The following comments lay claim to being nothing more than a first step on the road to recovering a fascinating story of cross-cultural encounters, political machinations, and African dominance in imposing the terms of the slave export and foreign trade with the Portuguese, Spaniards, French, and English. (24)

On his arrival in England in July 1581, Dom Antonio was penniless pen·ni·less  
adj.
1. Entirely without money.

2. Very poor. See Synonyms at poor.


penni·less·ly adv. , but he had taken the precaution to seize the Portuguese crown jewels crown jewels

Ornaments used at the coronation of a monarch and the formal ensigns of monarchy worn or carried on state occasions, as well as collections of personal jewelry consolidated by European sovereigns as valuable assets of their royal houses and the offices they , the precious spoils of the Portuguese East and West Indies West Indies, archipelago, between North and South America, curving c.2,500 mi (4,020 km) from Florida to the coast of Venezuela and separating the Caribbean Sea and the Gulf of Mexico from the Atlantic Ocean. . Queen Elizabeth Queen Elizabeth, or Elizabeth, may refer to: Living people

  • Elizabeth II, Queen regnant of the Commonwealth Realms

Deceased people
Bohemia

welcomed Dom Antonio not as a claimant, but as a sovereign brother, and set her mind on making use of him as a trump card in the political trials of strength waged between the English, French, Spanish, and Moroccan courts. When Dom Antonio ran out of his financial resources, he resorted, with the approval of the English government, to unorthodox methods of financing his campaign to recover the Portuguese throne from Philip II Philip II, king of France
Philip II or Philip Augustus, 1165–1223, king of France (1180–1223), son of Louis VII. During his reign the royal domains were more than doubled, and the royal power was consolidated at the expense . (25)

The Guinea charter, signed on May 3/13, 1588, by the English government and on May 20/30, 1588 by Dom Antonio, was a contract concluded, in the first place, for the benefit of both sides and, in the second, as a warrant for Dom Antonio’s financial survival. It granted some English merchants of Exeter, Colyton, Barnstaple, and London, for the space of ten years, license to trade with Senegambia, that is, a stretch of the mainland littoral littoral /lit·to·ral/ (lit´ah-r’l) pertaining to the shore of a large body of water.


littoral

pertaining to the shore.  lying between the rivers Senegal and Gambia in Upper Guinea Upper Guinea or la Haute-Guinée is a large plain covering eastern Guinea, Sierra Leone, Liberia and extending into north western Côte d’Ivoire. Mostly forming the upper watershed of the River Niger, it is sparsely populated and is home to the Haut Niger National Park.  and some 240 miles long. The first 140 miles, reaching from the estuary of the Senagal to the peninsula of Cape Verde Cape Verde (vûd), Port. Cabo Verde, officially Republic of Cape Verde, republic (2005 est. pop. 418,000), c.1,560 sq mi (4,040 sq km), W Africa, in the Atlantic Ocean about 300 mi (480 km) W of Dakar, Senegal.  and known as the Great Coast, were inhospitable terrain without any ports and therefore irrelevant to the transatlantic trade. The international traffic was concentrated on the Small Coast, reaching from Cape Verde to the estuary of the Gambia. This part of the coast was dotted with a number of busy ports and slave emporia, the most important being Bezeguiche, Rufisque, Portudal, and Joal. (26)

Dom Antonio, though ousted from the Portuguese throne by Philip II, kept claiming the Senegambian littoral as his overseas possession. Thus he enjoined the English patentees to fit out three vessels bound for Guinea every year; to accept two Portuguese agents on board the English vessels to register the goods on the outward and homeward home·ward  
adv. & adj.
Toward or at home.


homewards adv. voyages; to pay duties of 5 percent on all the goods sold from ivory, hides, amber, wax, gold, and silver to slaves, and to hand the taxes over to Dr Rodrigo (Ruy) Lopez, the queen’s physician, whom the Privy Council Privy Council

Historically, the British sovereign’s private council. Once powerful, the Privy Council has long ceased to be an active body, having lost most of its judicial and political functions since the middle of the 17th century.  had appointed collector of the duties and had charged to use the incoming money to indemnify Dom Antonio’s English creditors. The debts Dom Antonio had incurred between 1581 and 1588 amounted to [pounds sterling]4000, and he was about to accrue further debts with the disastrous Portugal expedition of 1589 under the command of Sir Francis Drake and Sir John Norris John Norris may be:

  • Sir John Norreys (1547-1597), English soldier
  • Sir John Norris (Windsor MP), Member of Parliament for Windsor 1597–1601
  • John Norris (philosopher) (1657-1711), philosopher and poet

. (27)

The most prominent patentee PATENTEE. He to whom a patent has been granted. The term is usually applied to one who has obtained letters-patent for a new invention.
2. His rights are, 1.  to sign the Guinea charter was the Barbary merchant Anthony Dassell. He staked his money on the vessels which sailed under the command of his brother Thomas. The two brothers looked upon the resumption of the Guinea trade as a fat chance of lining their own pockets. They committed a number of violations, which were endemic among international slaving merchants, such as flouting the legal machinery set up to recover the import duties levied on the goods. Dom Antonio, therefore, brought a lawsuit against them for refusing to allow his agents to board their vessels in order to inspect the commodities and to remit the duties to Dr Lopez’s account. What is of utmost relevance to the present investigation is the attempt of the Dassell brothers to bypass the rules of the Guinea charter in surreptitiously sur·rep·ti·tious  
adj.
1. Obtained, done, or made by clandestine or stealthy means.

2. Acting with or marked by stealth. See Synonyms at secret.  importing black Africans and evading the import taxes to the detriment of Dom Antonio and the English authorities. Thus it transpires from the interrogatory in·ter·rog·a·to·ry  
adj.
Asking a question; of the nature of a question; interrogative.

n. pl. in·ter·rog·a·to·ries Law
A formal or written question, as to a witness, usually requiring an answer under oath.  drawn up by the High Court of Admiralty High Court of Admiralty

In England, formerly the court presided over by the deputy of the admiral of the fleet. It was established c. 1360 to deal with matters of discipline and cases of piracy and prizes (ships and goods captured at sea), but it eventually had  and put to four English sailors, who had obviously sailed to Guinea in 1592, that the Dassell brothers were suspected of smuggling smuggling, illegal transport across state or national boundaries of goods or persons liable to customs or to prohibition. Smuggling has been carried on in nearly all nations and has occasionally been adopted as an instrument of national policy, as by Great Britain  a considerable number of Guinea slaves into England. The four sailors summoned to appear before the judges of the High Court of Admiralty were to be questioned about the number of Africans transported on the two ships Two Ships is a single by the folk duet, The Sallyangie, released in 1969. Track listing

  1. “Two Ships” – (3:16)
  2. “Colours Of The World” – (2:28)

of the Dassells. The judges also wanted to know “what are their names and in whose custodye and keeping are they at this tyme, and whether were they transported with the good will and leave of their parents and frends and the leave of the kinge of the said cuntrye, yea or no, and of what account are such as are so transported in the saide cuntrye to your knowledge, or as you have hearde by credible reporte”. (28)

It emerges from the wording of the interrogatory (items 11 and 20) that Dom Antonio, in cooperation with the English government, was the instigator in·sti·gate  
tr.v. in·sti·gat·ed, in·sti·gat·ing, in·sti·gates
1. To urge on; goad.

2. To stir up; foment.


[Latin  of the resumption of the English Guinea slave trade in 1588. The English government tacitly approved of the view held by an exiled potentate POTENTATE. One who has a great power over, an extended country; a sovereign.
2. By the naturalization laws, an alien is required, before he can be naturalized, to renounce all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state, or sovereign whatever. , who had had a lasting experience in slaveholding, that exporting slaves from Guinea was a legal enterprise provided the European exporter secured a license from the native kings or chieftains. This is borne out by the accusation laid by Dom Antonio before the High Court of Admiralty against Anthony Dassell and his brother Thomas in 1592. Dom Antonio accused the Dassell brothers of having “cast in prison the king of Portingall his agent,” that is, his own Guinea agent, and of having “transported” to England two Africans “against the king[e] of that realme and his officers comma[u]ndements”. (29)

The two Africans were said to be “cheife yonge negroes, … sonnes to the cheife justice of that contrey.” Dom Antonio and the English authorities, therefore, feared that the Dassells’ fraudulent practices would bring about “the utter overthrow[e] and disturba[u]nce of that trade in those partes,” and awaken “the prejudice of other marchants of that societie, by reason wherof” the queen and Dom Antonio were bound to lose “tenn thowsand[e] crownes yearlye” (Nunes Costa, Document 40). Richard Kelley For a list of people with a similarly spelled name, see .

Richard Kelley (born 24 July 1904; died early 1984) was a British Labour Party politician.

Kelley was a miners’ union secretary and served as a councillor on the West Riding County Council 1949-59.  was one of the Guinea merchants who disapproved of Anthony Dassell’s behavior. He was afraid to return to Guinea because he believed that the two “Neygrose of some accompt” had been taken to England “against their wills.” He argued that “by suche indiscreete dealinge it is greatlye to be feared that the trade into those partes wilbe very muche hindred.” He was, therefore, not ready to return to Guinea unless “some order be taken for the saffe bringinge backe of the sayde ij Negrose into the sayde countrye” (National Archives National Archives, official depository for records of the U.S. federal government, established in 1934 by an act of Congress. Although displeasure concerning the method of keeping national records was voiced in Congress as early as 1810, the United States continued , Kew, HCA HCA,
n.pr See acid, hydroxycitric.  24/59/49-51).

In his defense, Anthony Dassell countered that the “two yonge negroes they of themselfes made sute to come, and voluntarie came to see England without any compulsion,” adding that their “good entertaynment heere wil be more benefficiall and comodius” to the queen “in regarde of the trade then all the serva[u]nts” of Dom Antonio “canne doe good in goinge thither thith·er  
adv.
To or toward that place; in that direction; there: running hither and thither.

adj. .” And to justify his blatant breach of the Guinea charter he went to the length of invoking the example set by the French, who had been trading in Guinea “above thirtie yeares” without paying “duties” to their king. No “nation” was “better beloved nor so well wellcome to the negroes” as the French, who “cheifflie proceded by bringinge negroes nowe and then into France and usinge them well” (Nunes Costa, Document 41).

Anthony Dassell’s violation of the Guinea charter and his brother’s resort to violence lends little credence to Anthony’s argument that the measures he had taken were inspired by altruistic motives in the interest of England’s economic development. He revealed his true turn of mind when he complained to the judges that he was now constrained to keep the two noble Africans in his own house at his great cost for the benefit of the queen and his country (Nunes Costa, Documents 44 and 45).

The documents uncovered so far in the English and Portuguese national archives yield only a fraction of the economic enterprises undertaken by the eight patentees of the Guinea charter, that is, by William Brayley, Gilbert Smith, Nicholas Spicer, John Derricott, all four of Exeter, John Young of Colyton (Devon), Richard Dodridge of Barnstaple (Devon), and Anthony Dassell and Nicholas Turner, both of London. Further investigations are likely to bring to light the actual number of the black Africans whom the Dassells illicitly imported into London and whom the other merchants may have legally freighted to England, paying the export licenses issued by the African chiefs and the import duties exacted by Dom Antonio and the English government.

Two contemporary witnesses and chroniclers of the arrival of the English merchants in Senegambia in the early 1590s, one a Portuguese and the other an Englishman, throw some additional light on the memorable encounters between the English and some African kings as well as on the nature and conditions of the trade. It emerges from the chronicle of Andre Alvares d’ Almada, citizen of Sao Tiago São Tia·go  

An island of southern Cape Verde in the northern Atlantic Ocean. It is the largest island in the group and the site of the capital, Praia. , the principal among the Cape Verde Islands Noun 1. Cape Verde Islands – a group of islands in the Atlantic off of the coast of Senegal
Cape Verde, Republic of Cape Verde – an island country in the Atlantic off the coast of Senegal , and from the report of Richard Rainolds, one of the factors on Anthony Dassell’s ship the Nightingale, that Dom Antonio was woefully woe·ful also wo·ful
adj.
1. Affected by or full of woe; mournful.

2. Causing or involving woe.

3. Deplorably bad or wretched:  out of touch with the realities in Senegambia. The Portuguese and the Spaniards had lost the favor of the native kings, who since the 1570s had been encouraging the French and, in the 1590s, the English, among them Thomas Dassell, to trade with them directly irrespective of the regulations of the 1588 Guinea charter, which obliged the English merchants to sail under the supervision of Dom Antonio’s agents. (30)

Alvares d’Almada provides invaluable information on the profitable and successful relations between the Creolized Luso-Africans or Afro-Portuguese and the English merchants who had chosen Bezeguiche (Beseguiache in Rainolds) on the Cape Verde Peninsula, its large bay sheltered by the islet islet /is·let/ (-lit) an island.


islets of Langerhans irregular microscopic structures scattered throughout the pancreas and comprising its endocrine portion.  of Palma Palma or Palma de Mallorca (päl`mä thā mälyôr`kä), city (1990 pop. 325,120), capital of Majorca island and of Baleares prov., Spain, on the Bay of Palma. , as their favorite port of call. The Luso-Africans, disdainfully dis·dain·ful  
adj.
Expressive of disdain; scornful and contemptuous. See Synonyms at proud.


dis·dainful·ly adv. dismissed by the Portuguese authorities as “lancados,” were the middlemen who specialized in bartering goods between the Africans and the foreign merchants, the Spaniards, French, and English. They became the main purveyors of slaves when the monopoly of the Portuguese began to decline after 1570. The business partners were in a festive mood when the deals were concluded and the goods handed over to the foreign traders. The English used to banquet the Luso-Africans, entertaining them with music played on viols and other instruments. (31)

Alvares d’ Almada also raises the issue of sending Senegambians to England. He records that owing to the amicable relations established between the Bawal kingdom and the English merchants some Africans went to England to learn English and to visit the country. It was the governor of Portudal (Porto d’ Ally in Rainolds), also acting as overseer of king Amar Malik’s exchequer, who had given the order. This statement seems to contradict the accusation, brought against the Dassell brothers by Dom Antonio, of having conveyed to London two noble Africans, the sons of the chief justice, against the orders of king Amar Malik (or Mamalik) and his officials. (32) The case of the Dassells looks very much like being a precedent of the business venture to be arranged between some London Guinea merchants and the king of the river of Cess in Upper Guinea. The king sent his son Derij laquoah to London, where he was baptized in the church of St Mildred Poultry on January 1, 1611, some of the English merchants attending the ceremony of the baptism as godparents and sureties. John laquoah, the new convert, was obviously trimmed as a black Christian factor in the hope of boosting the shipment of goods, presumably pre·sum·a·ble  
adj.
That can be presumed or taken for granted; reasonable as a supposition: presumable causes of the disaster.  slaves, between England, Guinea, and the Caribbean. (33)

The Senegambians participated in the Atlantic trade as equal partners. Rainolds in his travel account does not tire of foregrounding the understanding and amity am·i·ty  
n. pl. am·i·ties
Peaceful relations, as between nations; friendship.


[Middle English amite, from Old French, from Vulgar Latin *am between the African rulers, the state officials, and the English merchants. One of the first professional obligations Rainolds fulfilled in November 1591 after landing at the islet of Palma, which he calls the “litle Iland … of liberty,” was to receive the governor of Beseguiache. The governor came “with a great traine … aboord in their canoas” to collect king Melek Zamba’s “dueties for ankerage.” Rainolds rose to the occasion, giving the governor “and all his company courteous entertainment” so as “to purchase the more love.” The governor then conducted Rainolds and his company to his “house” on the mainland at Beseguiache, where the English merchants “were gently and friendly feasted after their maner, and with some presents returned safe aboord againe.” These ceremonies, observed on the occasion of what was the official opening of trade relations, were concluded the following day when the governor came aboard the English ship “to wil” Rainolds “to send some yron and other commodities … to traffike with the Negros.” The same procedure was repeated at Rufisque (Refisca) and at Portudal. Portudal was ruled by king Amar Malik, son of Melek Zamba, whose subjects “befriended and favoured” the English and were “ready to ayde, succor and defend” them against the hostile followers of Dom Antonio. “In” these Africans, Rainolds commented, “appeared more confident love and goodwill towards us, then ever we shall finde either of Spaniards or Portugals.” (34)

The alleged influx of Guinea slaves in the early 1590s, whether legal or illegal in terms of the Guinea charter of 1588, generated a sense of anxiety about the black presence in late Elizabethan London. The government, therefore, took measures to defuse the situation. In the wake of the investigations conducted by the High Court of Admiralty in 1592-94, the queen under the pretext of a threat to economic stability, was induced to issue the ineffective deportation acts of 1596, 1599, and 1601. It is one of history’s ironies that the English government, put under pressure by Dom Antonio’s impecunious im·pe·cu·ni·ous  
adj.
Lacking money; penniless. See Synonyms at poor.


[in-1 + pecunious, rich (from Middle English, from Old French pecunios, from Latin  circumstances, should have condoned the import of Guinea slaves. Government measures alone were not sufficient to allay the fear of the citizens. By 1594 the Londoners had come to perceive the presence of Africans as an anomaly within the social body of their city and country which asked to be confronted on a public platform. This was the moment for Shakespeare to step in to make an attempt to defuse the situation by confronting his contemporary audiences with the extraordinary figure of Aaron, a literate African, in 1594.

The Mediterranean Traders

Besides Guinea as an export region of black slaves, the countries bordering the Mediterranean were another frequent source of supply. Trade in the Mediterranean and later on in the West Indies afforded Paul Banning or Bayning (d. September 30, 1616), member of the Grocers’ Company, alderman of Farringdon Without Coordinates:  Farringdon Without is a ward in the City of London, England.

The ward covers the area east of Chancery Lane including Middle Temple, Inner Temple and Smithfield market,[1] and is the largest of the 25 City wards. , called Fleet Street Ward (1593-1602), the opportunity to build up a vast business empire. Banning was one of the dominant figures of the Venice Company (1583-89) and the Levant Company In English trading history, the Levant Company, or Turkey Company, was a chartered company formed in 1581,[1] after London merchants petitioned Queen Elizabeth I in 1580 for a charter to begin trading in the Levant, a trade that had fallen away to near nothing in , also known as the Turkey Company (1581-88), which was granted a new charter in 1592. As a merchant promoting privateering privateering, former usage of war permitting privately owned and operated war vessels (privateers) under commission of a belligerent government to capture enemy shipping. , he had a powerful galleon galleon, oceangoing warship used by the European naval powers in the 15th and 16th cent. A large, cumbersome vessel, the galleon was three-masted and square-rigged, usually with two decks, and with its main batteries in broadsides.  built, the Golden Phoenix, designed with an eye to war and trade. At the turn of the century, he pursued a policy of investing the capital, which he had accumulated while trading in Venice and Turkey in the 1580s, in the first expedition of the East India Company. (35) He was treasurer of the East India Company 1600-1602.

The head of a vast household made up of many retainers, clerks, and servants, Banning had by 1593 bought at least three “blakamores,” all of them female domestic servants, who constituted a high-risk group high-risk group Epidemiology A group of people in the community with a higher-than-expected risk for developing a particular disease, which may be defined on a measurable parameter–eg, an inherited genetic defect, physical attribute, lifestyle, habit,  in his crowded household. He is the only English merchant known so far to own more than one black servant except for the naturalized nat·u·ral·ize  
v. nat·u·ral·ized, nat·u·ral·iz·ing, nat·u·ral·iz·es

v.tr.
1. To grant full citizenship to (one of foreign birth).

2. To adopt (something foreign) into general use.  Portuguese conversos dwelling in England. A fourth black household servant was “Iulyane,” twenty-two years old when she was christened in St Mary Bothaw on March 29, 1601, and “namyd” Mary by her godparents. These were obviously responsible for her integration into Banning’s teeming teem 1
v. teemed, teem·ing, teems

v.intr.
1. To be full of things; abound or swarm: A drop of water teems with microorganisms.

2. household and for her assimilation of English cultural values. (36)

The Portuguese New Christians as Slaveholders in England

The most experienced slaveholders in early modern England were the Portuguese New Christians or conversos who sought refuge in English ports when in 1536 Portugal, under Spanish pressure, established an Inquisition of its own and instituted the purity of blood statutes. The community of the Portuguese conversos reached its peak in the last decades of queen Elizabeth’s reign when it numbered between eighty and ninety members. Their presence was most welcome in England because of their widespread international commercial networks, their inveterate inveterate /in·vet·er·ate/ (-vet´er-at) confirmed and chronic; long-established and difficult to cure.


in·vet·er·ate
adj.
1. Firmly and long established; deep-rooted.

2. disapproval of Spain’s annexation of Portugal in 1580, and their unanimous backing of Dom Antonio’s cause. Their impressive performances won them much acclaim among the English circles of power and secured them long-lasting government backing and many a special privilege, the most important being the tacit acceptance by the English authorities of their commitment to rejudaization. (37)

The dominant converso families maintained their old elite lifestyle in their new English New English
n.
See Modern English.  environment. The ingrained legacy of their self-image as prominent bankers, merchants, ship owners, physicians, diplomats, and court astronomers stood them in good stead when they struggled to pursue their old careers in England. (38) The way of life led by the wealthy Portuguese conversos, whether they settled in London, Amsterdam, or Antwerp, required running large households, staffed by native and foreign male and female servants. The foreign domestic personnel of the Portuguese merchants of Antwerp were mostly black African servants. Their presence in Jewish Antwerp households is rather well documented; as for London converso households it is, unfortunaley, poorly documented. (39)

Dr Hector Nunes [Nunez] (1520-91) scored an unparalleled success as one of the most prominent multi-career Portuguese conversos to opt for exile in England. He was a renowned court physician, an enterprising merchant, shipowner Ship´own`er

n. 1. Owner of a ship or ships.

Noun 1. shipowner – someone who owns a ship or a share in a ship , marine insurance broker, intelligencer in·tel·li·genc·er  
n.
1. One who conveys news or information.

2. A secret agent, an informer, or a spy. , and banker who supported the cause of Dom Antonio, the pretender to the Portuguese throne. He was monitoring anti-Spanish resistance from his exile in England, besides being secretary Walsingham’s accredited accredited

recognition by an appropriate authority that the performance of a particular institution has satisfied a prestated set of criteria.


accredited herds
cattle herds which have achieved a low level of reactors to, e.g.  negotiator in putting out secret peace feelers in 1585/86 in order to assess the mounting preparations made for the sailing of the Spanish Armada. As head of the Portuguese community in London, he was running a syndicate of converso merchants linked by close family ties. Their policy was to pioneer commercial relations with the Mediterranean countries, Morocco included. He and his partners were among the first to import Moroccan sugar, molasses molasses, sugar byproduct, the brownish liquid residue left after heat crystallization of sucrose (commercial sugar) in the process of refining. Molasses contains chiefly the uncrystallizable sugars as well as some remnant sucrose. , paneles (brown unpurified Adj. 1. unpurified – not made pure
impure – combined with extraneous elements  sugar), and rameals (inferior sugar), via Antwerp in ships flying the Moroccan flag in the late 1560s. In March 1571, he and his partner William Curtis invested money in a voyage to Guinea, obviously with an eye on seizing slaves, but the Portuguese ambassador put the Privy Council under pressure to stop the enterprise. There is also evidence that he suffered serious financial setbacks due to daring commercial ventures and to the dangers of Anglo/Spanish hostilities. (40)

In 1582, Dr Nunes’s household consisted of his wife Leonor Freire of Antwerp, a butler, three clerks, all of them Portuguese New Christians (Fernando Alvarez

See Fernando Álvarez de Toledo, 3rd Duke of Alba for the medieval Spanish general.

Fernando Alvarez is a macroeconomist. He is a professor of economics at the University of Chicago. He received his Ph.D. from the University of Minnesota in 1994. , senior, Francisco Alvarez, and Francisco de Tapia), and two black female domestics, Gratia and Elizabeth Anegro. Elizabeth obviously bore the name of Dr Nunes’s sister-in-law Elizabeth Freire, who in 1582 married Alvaro de Lima de Lima or d’Lima is a Portuguese surname. It is also a Spanish name meaning ‘of Lima’

de Lima is either:

  • Ronaldo, Real Madrid and Brazilian footballer
  • Vanderlei de Lima, a Brazilian athlete
  • Augusto de Lima, a Brazilian journalist

, and Gratia, the name of Grace Freire, another sister-in-law, who had died in 1578. Gratia died a young woman; she was buried in the parish of St Olave Hart Street St Olave Hart Street is an Anglican church in the City of London, located on Hart Street near Fenchurch Street railway station.

The church is one of the smallest in the City and is one of only a handful of medieval City churches that escaped the Great Fire of London in 1666.  on July 13, 1590. (41)

Elizabeth and Gratia Anegro, who were members of the Anglican Church, were to play a decisive role in confirming the accusation that the Nunes and Alvarez households were practicing Jewish observances in secret. While Dr Nunes saw to the worldly and economic affairs of his household, he left the daily observance of religious conduct to his wife and his brother-in-law Fernando Alvarez, the husband of Philippa Freire. Dr Nunes had been endenizened as an English subject in 1579 and then had publicly conformed to the Church of England Church of England: see England, Church of.  while allowing the members of his family to practise Judaism in the privacy of his house. The evidence that his was a judaizing family is unmistakable. His wife had obviously assumed the role of judaizer since in rabbinic rab·bin·i·cal   also rab·bin·ic
adj.
Of, relating to, or characteristic of rabbis.


[From obsolete rabbin, rabbi, from French, from Old French rabain, probably from Aramaic  law it was held that Jewishness was transmitted through the mother. (42)

As a slaveholder the distinguished physician was surprisingly out of touch with the legal realities in Tudor England. After having spent some forty years in England, Dr Nunes assumed that there were laws regulating the slave traffic as there had been in his native Portugal. Thus, in 1587, he submitted a formal complaint to the Court of Requests, stating that he had bought an Ethiopian, meaning a black African, from an English mariner at a price of [pounds sterling]4 10s. The slave, however, “vtterly” refused “to tarry tarry /tar·ry/ (tahr´e)
1. filled with or covered by tar.

2. thick, dark; resembling tar.


tarry

said of feces that are black and glutinous. See also melena.  and serve him.” Dr Nunes apparently made the painful experience that he had “not any ordinarye remedie at and by the course of the comon Lawes” unless the queen through her secretaries in the Court of Requests would “compell the sayde Ethiopian to serve him during his liffe.” Should the court refuse to oblige the African to serve him, he requested the court to “Recover this sayd ffowre poundes Tenne Ten`ne´

n. 1. (Her.) A tincture, rarely employed, which is considered as an orange color or bright brown. It is represented by diagonal lines from sinister to dexter, crossed by vertical lines.  shillinges” from the English mariner who had sold him the slave.

This case confirms that owing to the absence of a black slave’s legal status in early modern England the law courts and even the secretaries of state in the Court of Requests, some of whom were personally acquainted with Dr Nunes, had no authority to intervene. The conclusion of Rosalyn L. Knutson, who has unearthed Unearthed is the name of a Triple J project to find and “dig up” (hence the name) hidden talent in regional Australia.

Unearthed has had three incarnations – they first visited each region of Australia where Triple J had a transmitter – 41 regions in all.  the document, that the English slaveowner who bought a black slave at the market “did not have the help of the law of England to enforce the bond at the level of enslavement en·slave  
tr.v. en·slaved, en·slav·ing, en·slaves
To make into or as if into a slave.


en·slavement n. , though they may well have had other kinds of power,” is quite relevant. It was precisely the absence of the legal status of a slave that offered the slave a loophole to refuse and at the same time gave the owner free hand to enslave en·slave  
tr.v. en·slaved, en·slav·ing, en·slaves
To make into or as if into a slave.


en·slavement n. his black African, exploiting him or her as an unpaid domestic servant. (43)

The complaint lodged by Dr Nunes casts a fresh perspective on the hazards of an unregulated black slave market in early modern England. The black slave took advantage of his legally undefined status in refusing to accept the sale and serve Dr Nunes for the rest of his life. He may have been a second-generation African, born in Europe, who had created an image of himself and did not hesitate to challenge European concepts of ownership. Dr Nunes’s complaint, moreover, reveals for the first time in an English document what was the actual market value of a black male slave in 1587 London.

Dr Nunes’s leadership went uncontested among the Portuguese New Christians in Elizabethan London. His merits, however, have remained undervalued Undervalued

A stock or other security that is trading below its true value.

Notes:
The difficulty is knowing what the “true” value actually is. Analysts will usually recommend an undervalued stock with a strong buy rating.  by literary and cultural scholars, who have preferred to focus their attention on another Portuguese converso, on Dr Rodrigo (Ruy) Lopez, physician and collector of the customs duties which the patentees of the Guinea charter owed Dom Antonio. His execution, on June 7, 1594, on a charge of being a secret judaizer plotting to poison the queen has been more newsworthy. C. J. Sisson holds the view that the judaizing New Christians of Portuguese descent Shakespeare is likely to have met in London were not Shylocks but men like Dr Nunes. (44)

The Performance of Titus Andronicus: Sir John Harington’s Political and Cultural Credo

My first article on Titus Andronicus was, as it were, the by-product by·prod·uct or by-prod·uct
n.
1. Something produced in the making of something else.

2. A secondary result; a side effect.


by-product
Noun

1.  of my extensive researches into Antonio Perez’s exile in Essex House Essex House can refer to:

  • Essex House (publisher) – publisher of erotic writing [1]

Buildings

  • Essex House (London) – a historic house in London
  • Jumeirah Essex House – a luxury hotel in New York City

References

1. , London (1593-95). The historic defection of the astute secretary to Philip II and the secret royal audiences he was granted by queen Elizabeth aroused the indignation of the Spanish court. His defection, however, as seen through the prism of English history, was a marginal event worth comment but of little consequence for Elizabethan foreign policy. Even as a man of letters man of letters
n. pl. men of letters
A man who is devoted to literary or scholarly pursuits.

Noun 1. man of letters – a man devoted to literary or scholarly activities , as a leading aphorist aph·o·rism  
n.
1. A tersely phrased statement of a truth or opinion; an adage. See Synonyms at saying.

2. A brief statement of a principle.  and Tacitist in his day, Antonio Perez has remained underrated in Spain. Surprisingly, though officially a persona non grata in the eyes of the Elizabethan authorities, he was championed as Spain’s foremost Tacitean writer by the learned secretaries of the earl of Essex Earl of Essex is a title that has been held by several families and individuals, of which the best-known and most closely associated with the title was Robert Devereux, 2nd Earl of Essex (1566 – 1601). . (45)

Most of the earl of Essex’s secretaries and advisers had taken to Tacitism as a mode of political inquiry and, while Perez was dwelling in London, were pooling their resources to disseminate the Spaniard’s writings among the members of the Essex faction and the Elizabethan court. They even went to the length of harnessing the skills of Richard Field, Shakespeare’s first printer, to publish Perez’s famous Pedacos de Historia o Relaciones (1594) in a cross-border campaign framed to exonerate the notorious exile at home. In the Pedacos de Historia, Perez drew on Tacitus’s histories in order to provide ideological justification for tyrannicide and for the Aragonese rebellion against Philip II, which had been unleashed by Perez’s imprisonment Imprisonment
See also Isolation.

Alcatraz Island

former federal maximum security penitentiary, near San Francisco; “escapeproof.” [Am. Hist.: Flexner, 218]

Altmark, the

German prison ship in World War II. [Br. Hist.  in Zaragoza. Perez escaped from his Aragonese prison to the court of Navarre and, in 1593, to the French embassy in London until he eventually took refuge in Essex House. There a set of like-minded scholars came together in the earl’s secretariat; one of them, Henry Wotton, produced an English synthesis of the book; another, Arthur Atey, turned out an English translation under the supervision of Anthony Bacon, the earl’s foreign secretary.

While Perez, as a politician, was ignored by the English court or rather, the English court pretended to ignore Perez, he was held in high esteem by the Tacitean scholars in the service of the Essex faction. To them Perez offered a model for studying the rule of a tyrant. In his Pedacos de Historia, Perez posed as the favorite who had fallen victim to Philip II’s tyranny. Thus what they read in Tacitus and in Perez sustained their republican principles of imposing legal limits on royal power. In their opinion, to put it in terms of John Guy, the queen’s capriciousness, especially in the matter of favorites, bore the “distinguishing mark of tyranny.” (46)

Perez also made a name for himself as an epistolomaniac. He used to shower the English courtiers and the followers of the Essex circle, male as well as female, with epistles EPISTLES, civil law. The name given to a species of rescript. Epistles were the answers given by the prince, when magistrates submitted to him a question of law. Vicle Rescripts. , penned in Latin and Spanish, which he used to lard with political aphorisms. His favorite English muse was Penelope Devereux, Lady Rich, to whom he addressed at least five Spanish letters. The climax of Perez’s literary and social prestige was, no doubt, his three-day visit to Cambridge, which was stage-managed by the earl of Essex. On the occasion of the B.A.Commencement at the end of February 1595, which was celebrated with the performance of several plays at Trinity and Queens Colleges and a series of academic disputations, over a dozen guests of the earl of Essex, among them noblemen and courtiers, were awarded honorary M.A. degrees. Among the honorands were Antonio Perez and Giovanni Battista Basadonna. (47)

Giovanni Battista Basadonna was a patrician merchant, whom the republic of Venice The Most Serene Republic of Venice (Italian: Serenissima Repubblica di Venezia, Venetian: Republica de Venesia had despatched to England as agent to the Elizabethan court. A nobleman with some literary pretensions, who presided over a miniature court in the city of London, which used to be frequented by Anthony Bacon in his capacity as foreign secretray to Essex, he acted as a banker to Perez and assisted him in erecting, on behalf of the earl of Essex, an intelligence service in Italy. The pregnant news that this “royal merchant,” as he is called in contemporary documents, kept among the records of the Court of Admiralty COURT OF ADMIRALTY. A court having jurisdiction of all maritime causes. Vide Admiralty; Courts of the United States; Instance Courts; Prize Court; 2 Chit. Pr. 508 to 538. , was building up an impressive merchant fleet of his own, has gone unnoticed by scholars. His vessels, manned with English and Italian sailors, were flying the Venetian flag while navigating the waters of the Thames in those years in which Shakespeare happened to be writing The Merchant of Venice. (48)

For Richard Field printing a book coming from the pen of the expatriate Spaniard, who was biding bide  
v. bid·ed or bode , bid·ed, bid·ing, bides

v.intr.
1. To remain in a condition or state.

2.
a. To wait; tarry.

b. his time in Essex House, in a quarto quar·to  
n. pl. quar·tos
1. The page size obtained by folding a whole sheet into four leaves.

2. A book composed of pages of this size.  edition of over 389 pages with a faked imprint, was quite an outstanding professional achievement. An address of the printer, “E1 Impressor a Todos” (sig. Ddd3r-Ddd4v), is appended at the end of the book, in which Field declares, “Yo he Impresso este libro con poca noticia de la lengua Espanola” (I have printed the book with little knowledge of the Spanish language). This was not quite true. (49)

Bearing in mind that Richard Field had been commissioned by the Essex faction to print the Pedacos de Historia and that the earl of Essex had subsidized its printing, it is not rash to speculate that one of the earl’s secretaries may have suggested to Shakespeare to pen a stage portrait of the notorious Spaniard for the entertainment of the Essex followers. In my study A Spaniard in Elizabethan England I have marshaled various arguments to bring home to the modern reader that Shakespeare conceived Don Adriano de Armado in Love’s Labour’s Lost as a downgraded stage portrait of Antonio Perez. Shakespeare’s parody of Perez as an insider of Spanish history endowed with rare linguistic accomplishments is grafted on the dramatic stock figure of the Spanish braggart, who originally strutted on the stage of the commedia dell’arte. I have not changed my mind since the 1970s and still hold, to put it in terms of A. L. Rowse Alfred Leslie Rowse, CH FBA (December 4, 1903 – October 3, 1997), known professionally as A. L. Rowse and to his friends and family as Leslie, was a prolific British historian. , that Shakespeare’s stage portrait of Antonio Perez is “very near the bone.” (50) The original audience of the comedy was invited to take King Ferdinand of Navarre’s description of Armado at face value:

  Our court, you know, is haunted
    With a refined traveller of Spain,
  A man in all the world's new fashion planted,
    That hath a mint of phrases in his brain,
  One who the music of his own vain tongue
    Doth ravish like enchanting harmony,
  A man of compliments, whom right and wrong
    Have chose as umpire of their mutiny.
  This child of fancy, that Armado hight,
    For interin to our studies shall relate
  In high born words the worth of many a knight
    From tawny Spain, lost in the world's debate.
  How you delight, my lords, I know not, I,
  But I protest I love to hear him lie,
  And I will use him for my minstrelsy. (51)

There are, admittedly, other candidates for Shakespeare’s satirical portrait of Armado, the Spanish braggart. Thus Tom Cain has demonstrated that the play was written within the tradition of representing recognizable contemporaries in a satirical vein. His candidate for Armado is Gabriel Harvey, the Cambridge scholar. But unlike Perez, Harvey simply does not fit in with King Ferdinand of Navarre’s description of the “refined traveller of Spain.” (52) It was none other than Perez, hailed as the “refined” exile “of Spain,” who was haunting the Elizabethan court. Perez had taken refuge at the court of Navarre before haunting the court of Queen Elizabeth. Stage-cast in the shape of Armado, he finds access to the court of Navarre and its noblemen who have vowed to impose on themselves a three-year exile as students. Some commentators have noted that the king’s promise of an excursion into Spanish history is not fulfilled in the play. It was probably never meant to be fulfilled, for Shakespeare apparently assumed that the play’s original audience, that is, the members of the Essex faction and the Inns of Court students and lawyers, did know that “the worth of many a knight / From tawny Spain, lost in the world’s debate” was inscribed in·scribe  
tr.v. in·scribed, in·scrib·ing, in·scribes
1.
a. To write, print, carve, or engrave (words or letters) on or in a surface.

b. To mark or engrave (a surface) with words or letters.  in the London edition of the Pedacos de Historia, a handwritten hand·write  
tr.v. hand·wrote , hand·writ·ten , hand·writ·ing, hand·writes
To write by hand.


[Back-formation from handwritten.]

Adj. 1. English and even Latin translation of which were available to them.

What may clinch the controversy over the satire’s target in favor of Antonio Perez is the following argument I forgot to advance in my study of 1976: the closeness of Love’s Labour’s Lost to the Inns of Court culture of wit and satire which fostered the mock recitation rec·i·ta·tion  
n.
1.
a. The act of reciting memorized materials in a public performance.

b. The material so presented.

2.
a. Oral delivery of prepared lessons by a pupil.

b. of private correspondence. Given that Perez was a frequent visitor to Gray’s Inn, where he shared Francis Bacon’s private rooms, as well as a guest of the Gray’s Inn revels of 1594, which climaxed with the performance of Shakespeare’s The Comedy of Errors on December 28, it is not far-fetched to assume that the inmates, the lawyers, and the law students of Gray’s Inn had more than a passing knowledge of the Spaniard as an obtrusive ob·tru·sive  
adj.
1. Thrusting out; protruding: an obtrusive rock formation.

2. Tending to push self-assertively forward; brash: a spoiled child’s obtrusive behavior.  epistolomaniac and Tacitean historian a la mode, whose advocacy of limited sovereignty was deemed subversive by the Elizabethan authorities. His epistles are likely to have been made the object of quipping comments circulating among the Inn’s members, such as the poet Francis Davison, who were in close touch with the Bacons and the followers of the earl of Essex. Armado’s pretentious letter, read out in act 1 before the court of Navarre by King Ferdinand, sounds like a concerted take-off of Perez’s overblown o·ver·blown  
v.
Past participle of overblow.

adj.
1.
a. Done to excess; overdone: overblown decorations.

b. epistolary e·pis·to·lar·y  
adj.
1. Of or associated with letters or the writing of letters.

2. Being in the form of a letter: epistolary exchanges.

3. style. (53)

Antonio Perez was an exacting exile. His political expectations, demands, and whims inevitably put an unbearable strain on Anthony Bacon’s frail physical condition. Bacon therefore appointed, with the approval of the earl of Essex, a string of servants to attend upon the “refined” Spaniard, who in his heyday had commanded an army of officials to see to his business and body of curators to look after his famous collection of Titians, Correggios, and Parmigianino’s Cupid. (54) One of them was the Gascon Gascon

inhabitant of Gascony, France; people noted for their bragging. [Fr. Hist.: NCE, 1049]

See : Boastfulness  Jacques Petit, who prided himself on being blessed with an academic turn of mind that stood him in good stead while he was in attendance upon Perez.

After the Spaniard’s departure for France in July 1595, Anthony Bacon commissioned Petit to repair to Burley-on-the-Hill, Rutland, and there to further the French studies of Sir John Harington’s son and heir John, a three-year-old child prodigy. While in Rutland, Petit maintained a steady correspondence with his master in London which discloses some nuggets Nuggets can refer to several branches of interest:

  • , a compilation of U.S. psychedelic rock released between 1965 and 1968
  • , a Rhino Records box set of non-U.S.

of precious information on the Christmas festivities celebrated at Burley-on-the-Hill in December 1595/January 1596. Thus Sir John Harington, though beset with economic difficulties after marrying his adolescent daughter Lucy to Edward Russell, third earl of Bedford, in December 1594, lavishly and generously entertained some two hundred private guests, many of them his relatives, and up to nine hundred neighbors, copyholders, and tenants. Petit likened the vast concourse of aristocratic Christmas revelers to a “royal” court. It looks as if in 1595/96 Sir John inaugurated a series of Christmas festivities which John Chamberlain in 1602 was to qualify as “royal.”

The memorable Christmas celebrations climaxed with a double bill on New Year’s Day New Year’s Day, among ancient peoples the first day of the year frequently corresponded to the vernal or autumnal equinox, or to the summer or winter solstice. In the Middle Ages it was celebrated among Christians usually on Mar. 25. , first, with the amateur performance of a masque masque, courtly form of dramatic spectacle, popular in England in the first half of the 17th cent. The masque developed from the early 16th-century disguising, or mummery, in which disguised guests bearing presents would break into a festival and then join with their  written by Sir Edward Wingfield, Sir John’s brother-in-law, obviously with an eye to offering his young niece, the countess of Bedford, a stage debut among her relatives, and second, with a professional performance of Shakespeare’s Titus Andronicus, given by the Chamberlain’s Men. (55) Petit, our informant, failed to live up to the importance of the event. An uninspired onlooker, he contented himself with the terse comment that “Les commediens de Londres son[t] venus icy po[u]r en auoir leur p[ar]t … on a aussi ioue la tragedie de Titus Andronicus mais la monstre a plus valeu q[ue] le suiect.” (56) Petit did not even bother to find out what had induced Sir John to commission the Chamberlain’s Men to stage Titus Andronicus for the entertainment of his guests. He haughtily haugh·ty  
adj. haugh·ti·er, haugh·ti·est
Scornfully and condescendingly proud. See Synonyms at proud.


[From Middle English haut, from Old French haut, halt assumed the pose of a would-be chronicler who looked down on dramatic entertainments as products of minor quality, missing the opportunity to record the emotional impact the play made on the select audience. On the other hand, he had felt it his bounden bound·en  
adj.
1. Obligatory: their bounden duty.

2. Archaic Being under obligation; obliged.  duty, on the occasion of Antonio Perez’s departure for France, to compose a doggerel dog·ger·el   also dog·grel
n.
Crudely or irregularly fashioned verse, often of a humorous or burlesque nature.


[From Middle English, poor, worthless, from dogge, dog; see  farewell sonnet and two adulatory ad·u·late  
tr.v. ad·u·lat·ed, ad·u·lat·ing, ad·u·lates
To praise or admire excessively; fawn on.


[Back-formation from adulation.  lamentations each couched in an execrable quatrain quat·rain  
n.
A stanza or poem of four lines.


[French, from Old French, from quatre, four, from Latin quattuor; see kwetwer- in Indo-European roots. . In the first quatrain, he deplores Perez’s absence “Manquant le medecin qui chassoit mon esmoy”; in the second, he laments that he will no longer be able to converse with Perez and his “dons celestes.” (57)

The play Sir John Harington had commissioned for the entertainment of his Christmas guests at Burley-on-the-Hill was not brand-new considering that its first performance had already been given on January 24, 1594. But the play’s political message, which argues the case for a more constitutional form of government capable of making up for individual failure as well as for the failure of political institutions in Rome and, by implication, in Elizabethan England, had not lost its immediacy in 1595/96. (58) In 1594, the earl of Essex had been positioning himself to weather the imminent issue of succession, aspiring to change England’s destiny on the queen’s death. (59) In 1594/95, the earl had also been championing the international campaign raised by the exiled Antonio Perez, who as Spain’s leading Tacitean historian and former secretary to Philip II had adopted a critical discourse to reveal the machinations of Philip II’s government against him. Sir John Harington had always been gravitating toward the Leicester/Essex nexus. He had been a staunch supporter of the earl of Leicester, who as second husband of Lettice Knollys (1578-88) had been stepfather of the earl of Essex. (60) Sir John’s scheme to stage Titus Andronicus as the climax of the Christmas festivities at Burley-on-the-Hill in 1595/96 was no doubt motivated by political considerations. It looks as if the Christmas festivities in Rutland served him as an instrument for letting his entourage know in public that he was positioning himself as a member of the Essex faction. His extravagant twenty-two-year-old son-in-law, Edward Russell, earl of Bedford (1572-1627), who on December 12, 1594, had married his daughter Lucy a month before her fourteenth birthday, followed suit. In February 1601, the earl was tried and heavily fined for being implicated im·pli·cate  
tr.v. im·pli·cat·ed, im·pli·cat·ing, im·pli·cates
1. To involve or connect intimately or incriminatingly: evidence that implicates others in the plot.

2. in the rebellion of the earl of Essex.

Besides the contemporary relevance of the play’s political message, Titus Andronicus broke new ground in its attempt to cast doubt on the conventional perception of the African other as an inferior being. The racial discourse had not lost its immediacy in 1595/96. The foundation of the Guinea Company in 1588 had led to an increased influx of black Africans and by 1593/94, when Shakespeare was writing the play in the form it has come down to us, the black presence in Elizabethan England had reached a peak. The illicit arrival of two young African notables, the sons of the chief justice of Senegambia, and of some black students to be indoctrinated in English culture, was a conspicuous event, which alarmed the English government (see above). Shakespeare responded to these social, legal, and ethnic tensions in staging forms of cross-cultural encounters that called in question the entrenched en·trench   also in·trench
v. en·trenched, en·trench·ing, en·trench·es

v.tr.
1. To provide with a trench, especially for the purpose of fortifying or defending.

2. English position on racial hierarchies; and George Peele, considered by some scholars as coauthor of Titus Andronicus, seized the opportunity to publish his old play on The Battle of Alcazar alcazar
Spanish alcázar

Form of military architecture of medieval Spain, generally rectangular with defensible walls and massive corner towers. Inside was an open space (patio) surrounded by chapels, salons, hospitals, and sometimes gardens.  with its Moroccan and European settings, which he had written in 1589 as a caveat against the imminent dangers of an English alliance with a Muslim country. (61)

Titus Andronicus, besides being Shakespeare’s first revenge tragedy, can claim to be the first Elizabethan play to undercut the racial discourse of positioning white over black. It challenges the ideological assumptions about the black man’s racial inferiority. Aaron, the black outsider, does not correspond to the black African slaves the Londoners had come to know in increasing numbers after 1588. His most salient deviation from the real-life enslaved blackamores kept in London households is his literacy. Aaron is a literate black African well versed in the classics. He knows Ovid and Horace better than the sons of Tamora, the white queen of the Goths Goths: see Ostrogoths; Visigoths. . Moreover, Aaron’s sexual behavior sexual behavior A person’s sexual practices–ie, whether he/she engages in heterosexual or homosexual activity. See Sex life, Sexual life.  does not conform to the entrenched belief and stereotyped representation of a black man’s uncontrollable sexuality. Whereas Tamora herself and her two sons are figures of unrestrained sexuality, Aaron is capable of practicing sexual restraint. He thereby contradicts the current notion of the black man’s boundless sexual potency. He also outdoes the Romans in setting examples of moderation and self-discipline and in acting as a vehicle of moral commentary. (62) As a father he is pitted against Titus Andronicus, an embodiment of Roman values, who does not hesitate to resort to infanticide infanticide (ĭnfăn`təsīd) [Lat.,=child murder], the putting to death of the newborn with the consent of the parent, family, or community. Infanticide often occurs among peoples whose food supply is insecure (e.g.  for political and moral considerations. Aaron, however, poses as a paragon of paternal love in his frantic attempt to save his son’s life. The assumption that civilized Rome cannot be barbaric is shown to be incorrect.

The play’s two miscegenated babies, I think, must be seen as projections of contemporary cultural anxieties about miscegenation: a black baby, the biological product of a black man (Aaron) and a white woman (Tamora), and an offstage “fair” baby, begotten be·got·ten  
v.
A past participle of beget.


begotten
Verb

a past participle of beget

Adj. 1. by a black African (Muly) on the body of his white wife. However, the different skin color of the two babies goes against one of the basic tenets of the racial discourse that black men invariably in·var·i·a·ble  
adj.
Not changing or subject to change; constant.


in·vari·a·bil produce black children. The play’s daring instance of nature’s waywardness was obviously orchestrated by Shakespeare to cast doubt on the popular view, spread by George Best in the True Discourse of the Late Voyages of Discoverie (1578), that he had seen a black baby born on English soil to an Englishwoman and an Ethiopian, “whereby it seemeth this blacknes proceedeth rather of some natural infection of that man, which was so strong, that neither the nature” of the salubrious salubrious /sa·lu·bri·ous/ (sah-loo´bre-us) conducive to health; wholesome.


sa·lu·bri·ous
adj.
Conducive or favorable to health or well-being.  English climate, nor the fair “complexion of the mother concurring, coulde any thing alter” (262). In passing off the anomaly of interbreeding as an “infection,” Best, of course, touched a sensitive nerve: his country’s fear of losing its identity.

In contrast to Best, Shakespeare’s play suggests what Sir Thomas Browne was to formulate in his Pseudodoxia Epidemica (1646) that the Blacks descend from “the seed of Adam” just as the English and are endowed with the powers of body and mind to do good and bad things. Thus the play gives the liminal liminal /lim·i·nal/ (lim´i-n’l) barely perceptible; pertaining to a threshold.


lim·i·nal
adj.
Relating to a threshold.


liminal

barely perceptible; pertaining to a threshold.  Aaron a public platform to voice his bottomless pride in blackness. “Coal-black,” he speaks out undauntedly “is better than another hue / In that it scorns to bear another hue.” (63) He does not hesitate to mount a counterattack Attacking an attacker. Even though a criminal hacker or other agent is attempting to penetrate a security perimeter or damage systems, the counterattack must not violate applicable laws.  to bring home to Tamora, to the nurse, and emphatically to Tamora’s sons that far from being “as loathsome as a toad” (4.2.69) the black baby is their brother “sensibly fed / Of that self blood that first gave life” to them (4.2.124-25). This is not meant to be a humanitarian plea, but rather a challenge to drop their “exclusiveness and see in themselves” the consanguineous con·san·guin·e·ous
adj.
Exhibiting consanguinity.


consanguineous adjective Referring to a blood relationship–ie, descendent from a common ancestor  “evil they see in their black brother.” (64)

Sir Thomas Browne’s position was not a novelty in the context of European cultural history, nor was Shakespeare’s. Thus Greek ceramicists and vase painters used to give voice to their belief in the equality of Blacks and Whites in creating janiform kantharoi, two-headed drinking-jugs, representing a white and a black head. The naked black Africans, romping around together with their white partners in Hieronymus Bosch’s The Garden of Earthly Delights (painted about 1510), convey the painter’s message to the world that humans born black are equal to those born white. His contemporary Albrecht Durer was most impressed by his encounters with black Africans when he was in Flanders in 1521. He portrayed two black domestic slaves, bringing their personalities to life with his masterful pencil strokes. The black slave is unnamed, but the female slave is identified as Katherina, aged twenty, serving in the household of Joao Brandao, commercial representative of the king of Portugal in Antwerp. (65)

Shakespeare’s approach to the imminent issues of cultural otherness must have struck a chord with Sir John Harington. The Haringtons had had close interconnections with the Spanish nobility since Margaret Harington, one of Sir John’s many sisters, had left England for Spain in July 1559 in the suite of her twenty-year-old cousin Jane Dormer, lady-in-waiting to the late queen Mary. Jane had been married in London to Gomez Suarez de Figueroa, fifth count of Feria fe·ri·a  
n. pl. fe·ri·as or fe·ri·ae
A weekday on a church calendar on which no feast is observed.


[Medieval Latin f , on December 29, 1558. The Feria household in Madrid was to become the hub of the English recusants RECUSANTS, or POPISH RECUSANTS, Eng. law. Persons who refuse to make the declarations against popery, and such as promote, encourage, or profess the popish religion.
2.  in Spain, the countess relentlessly supporting the activities of the English Catholics on the Continent besides keeping her Protestant cousins in England, the Haringtons and Sidneys, au courant Cou`rant´   

a. 1. (Her.) Represented as running; – said of a beast borne in a coat of arms.
n. 1. A piece of music in triple time; also, a lively dance; a coranto.
2. with the latest flourishing of Spanish culture. Margaret Harington remained affiliated to her cousin’s retinue until 1588 when she married don Benito de Cisneros, a member of a prominent Castilian family. As a present Jane gave her cousin Margaret a dowry dowry (dou`rē), the property that a woman brings to her husband at the time of the marriage. The dowry apparently originated in the giving of a marriage gift by the family of the bridegroom to the bride and the bestowal of money upon the bride by . (66)

Bearing in mind that Sir John Harington was a patron of the arts who had a cousin, a sister, and a brother-in-law, the three of them members of the Spanish nobility, it is obvious that his family connections singled him out as one of the best informed English noblemen about Spanish matters. We can, therefore, be almost certain that he knew that Portugal had brought forth a mulatto dramatist, Afonso Alvares, and Spain a black neo-Latin poet, Juan Latino, who was the first Afroeuropean writer to construct a Latin discourse of black pride. (67) Given the absence of his sister Margaret and his Spanish brother-in-law, who had not been able to honor the invitation to join the Harington reunion at Burley-on-the-Hill in December 1595, Sir John was, no doubt, the best qualified playgoer, watching the performance of Titus Andronicus and ready to awaken the response of his numerous private guests, among them his relatives, friends, and neighbors, to the play’s ethnic position. He may indeed have succeeded in bringing home to his select audience the redeeming qualities of Aaron as a father as well as his outstanding literacy and grounding in classical authors, which entitle him to shed the image of a barbarian. Both the fictional Aaron and the real-life Juan Latino defined themselves by their classical literacy as a measure of human worth. The Latinity was for the two of them a means to fashion their own identities and in the case of Aaron even to claim cultural superiority.

It is not possible to do justice to the play’s attempt to question the hostile response to the African in Elizabethan England without taking into account, besides the black presence, the early history of English slavery, the whole body of experience made by the English slaveholders and dealers dwelling in early modern Spain, which cultural historians, literary scholars, and Africanists have brushed aside as nonexistent non·ex·is·tence  
n.
1. The condition of not existing.

2. Something that does not exist.


non . Ignorance of early English real-life encounters with Africans has spawned Winthrop Jordan’s long-harbored and infectious myth that the encounter of the early modern English Early Modern English refers to the stage of the English language used from about the end of the Middle English period (the latter half of the 15th century) to 1650. Thus, the first edition of the King James Bible and the works of William Shakespeare both belong to the late phase  with Blacks was a traumatic experience–for the English. (68)

The historical records I have uncovered open up a new dimension in assessing the cross-cultural encounters between the Africans and the English merchants residing on the Christian/Muslim frontier, the European/African intersection in the Mediterranean ports of early modern Spain. It emerges from the documents retrieved from Spanish archives that all the English merchants residing in lower Andalusia after 1480 were potential owners of domestic slaves, black Africans and Moors, and that they were deeply immersed in the slave trade as dealers in human merchandise. The most prominent of them, Thomas Malliard and Robert Thorne, operated as capitalist leaseholders of soap factories in Seville and Malliard as an early colonist and joint tenant of one of the first sugar farms in the Canaries, the two of them exploiting unskilled and skilled labor force from Africa for the industrial production of white soap and sugar. (69)

Despite the institutionalization Institutionalization

The gradual domination of financial markets by institutional investors, as opposed to individual investors. This process has occurred throughout the industrialized world.  of the slave market, which affected all social classes in Spain, from top to bottom, in buying and selling slaves, the foreign merchants included, there were moments in which the white masters did look beyond the immediate exploitation of their slaves, whom they were legally entitled to own as their chattels CHATTELS, property. A term which includes all hinds of property, except the freehold or things which are parcel of it. It is a more extensive term than goods or effects. Debtors taken in execution, captives, apprentices, are accounted chattels. Godol. Orph. Leg. part 3, chap. 6, Sec. 1. . Thus Robert Thorne, facing his sudden return to England, sold seven Berbers and six Negroes to Bartholomaus Welser and Heinrich Gessler on May 2, 1531, and manumitted his two Berber master soap makers on May 10, 1531. He was somehow looking beyond harnessing their skills for the sole purpose of exploiting them as pieces of productive property. But it was still a “manumissio sub conditione.” (70) There is also unmistakable evidence that the authorities in England were disposed to acknowledge the black man’s human nature and personhood per·son·hood  
n.
The state or condition of being a person, especially having those qualities that confer distinct individuality: “finding her own personhood as a campus activist”  . The judges of the High Court of Admiralty in a London lawsuit of 1548 granted the Guinea diver Jacques Francis the status of a witness against the fierce opposition of some Italian merchants resident in Southampton. (See my paper on the Guinea diver Jacques Francis.)

Richard Hakluyt, the historian of England’s maritime ventures and collector of travel narratives, unlike his Spanish and Portuguese colleagues, who were eloquent chroniclers of the incipient slave trade in their countries, failed to record the experiences made by the English merchants as slave dealers in early modern Spain. It looks as if the chaplain-turned-geographer pursued an editorial policy of withholding information in order to protect his compatriots against being lumped together with the ignominious ig·no·min·i·ous  
adj.
1. Marked by shame or disgrace: “It was an ignominious end … as a desperate mutiny by a handful of soldiers blossomed into full-scale revolt” Angus Deming.  record of the Spaniards and Portuguese. His nationalist discourse of discovery was primarily aimed at glorifying his country’s naval achievements and praising its moral superiority. Thus in his Divers Voyages (1582), he edited Robert Thome’s text on the polar passage to Cathay and another on “A declaration of the Indies” without making a reference to Thome as an experienced slaveholder. (71)

Despite Hakluyt’s reticence about England’s early Mediterranean experience with black slaves, the extensive involvement in the slave business of William de la Founte, Thomas Malliard, Robert Thorne, his brother Nicholas Thorne, Roger Barlow, Nicholas Arnold, Thomas Bridges, Francis Bawd-wyn, Emmanuel Lucar (1494-1574), William Ostriche, Henry Patmer, Martin Pollard, Thomas Waters, (Guatres) and many other English merchants cannot have completely been lost on their English partners, colleagues, friends, and acquaintances in England.

When Robert Thorne was back in England in 1531, he took like most of his wealthy partners testamentary measures to preserve the survival of his memory in perpetuity Of endless duration; not subject to termination.

The phrase in perpetuity is often used in the grant of an Easement to a utility company.


in perpetuity adj. forever, as in one’s right to keep the profits from the land in perpetuity. . In his will he donated [pounds sterling]300 toward the foundation of St Bartholomew Grammar School, Bristol. This foundation was an expression of the wish “he shared with his brother Nicholas from adolescence, as they both tried to establish navigational instruction and foreign language tuition in the city of Bristol.” (See entry on Robert Thome in ODNB ODNB Oxford Dictionary of National Biography .) What the two brothers in their capacity as mercantile and intellectual go-betweens envisaged was obviously a transfer of scientific knowledge of modern navigation and cartography cartography: see map.


cartography
or mapmaking

Art and science of representing a geographic area graphically, usually by means of a map or chart. Political, cultural, or other nongeographic features may be superimposed.  from Spain to England, a transfer that was eventually to be brought about after 1547, when Sebastian Cabot, Robert Thome’s old partner, settled in England. (72) Thorne’s endowment of the grammar school was apparently financed by money he had made by holding and selling slaves.

Emmanuel Lucar, Robert Thome’s onetime apprentice, later on partner and overseer of the Seville soap factory, turned out to be a competent go-between and transmitter of past events. He returned to England in 1531, though Thorne had commissioned him to look after the two manumitted Berber master soap makers, who had been sold to the German Welser Company and were bound to work on for another five years. Thorne, who died in 1532, and Lucar were members of the Merchant Taylors’ Company. Lucar was elected master of the Company in 1560/61, the year in which the famous Merchant Taylors’ School There are three schools in England known as ‘Merchant Taylors’ School’:

  • Merchant Taylors’ School, Crosby
  • Merchant Taylors’ School, Northwood
  • Merchant Taylors’ Girls’ School, Crosby


See also: Worshipful Company of Merchant Taylors

was founded. He was in an ideal position to keep alive the memory, legacy, and life story of his former master Robert Thorne. His son, Ciprian Lucar, is said to have transmitted the Thorne papers to John Dee and Richard Hakluyt. (73)

In my essay on “Portia and the Prince of Morocco Prince of Morocco can refer to:

  • a character in William Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice

or a member of the Moroccan Royal Family. Currently these include:

  • Moulay Hassan, Crown Prince of Morocco
  • Prince Moulay Abdallah of Morocco

,” I argue that the Davenants, who were members of the Merchant Taylors’ Company, called Shakespeare’s attention to the story of the Gores, who have gone down in the annals of the Merchant Taylors as the first Anglo-Moroccan family. The involvement of the Gores in the bankruptcy of the prominent Moroccan Jew Isaac Cabeca and in the ensuing lawsuit, which dragged on in the High Court of Admiralty for over a decde, was common knowledge in London’s mercantile community. The numerous bankruptcies of English Christians and Moroccan Jews, who happened to be interlocked in transnational business partnerships and cross-border money lending, was quite alarming. The Gore/Cabeca partnership and subsequent lawsuit is, to my mind, a real-life contemporary parallel to the Antonio/Shylock bond. The involvement of English merchants in the slave trade of early modern Spain may likewise have been brought home to Shakespeare through his contacts with the members of the Merchant Taylors’ Company. It would help expalin why about 1592-94 Shakespeare, at the height of the scandal caused by the illicit import of Guinea slaves, embarked on a policy of facing up to the new cultural realities and of provoking changes in the Elizabethan perception of cultural otherness. He was to pursue his policy in the Mediterranean plays, The Merchant of Venice. (74) Othello, Anthony and Cleopatra, and The Tempest, addressing in all of these plays the hotly debated issues of cross-cultural marriages, miscegenation, and manumission MANUMISSION, contracts. The agreement by which the owner or master of a slave sets him free and at liberty; the written instrument which contains this agreement is also called a manumission.
2.  of slaves in The Tempest.

Notes

(1.) See Rosalyn L. Knutson, “A Caliban in St. Mildred Poultry,” in Shakespeare and Cultural Traditions. The Selected Proceedings of the International Shakespeare Association World Congress Tokyo 1991, ed. Tetsuo Kishi et al. (Newark: University of Delaware [3] The student body at the University of Delaware is largely an undergraduate population. Delaware students have a great deal of access to work and internship opportunities.  Press, 1994), 110-26. Imtiaz Habib of the Department of English Noun 1. department of English – the academic department responsible for teaching English and American literature
English department

academic department – a division of a school that is responsible for a given subject , Old Dominion University “ODU” redirects here. For other uses, see ODU (disambiguation).

The university was recently named one of the best colleges in the Southeast by The Princeton Review. , Norfolk, Virginia, is pursuing his search for black Africans in London parish records (see n. 14). The family of a freedman is recorded by Knutson and another instance is erroneously given by Habib. Habib, an authority on the colonial discourse in Shakespeare’s plays, has been misled by Folarin O. Shyllon’s study, Black People in Britain, 1556-1833 (London: Oxford University Press, 1972), into identifying a Spanish or Italian mercenary serving in the army of king Henry VIII as an African. The identification of Sir Peter Negro as a black officer does not take into account that the Negros were of Genoese descent. Dozens of them settled in Spain and Portugal in the course of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, far too many to be listed here. The factor Paolo di Negro, for whom Columbus was working in Madeira in 1479, may stand for the others. I have consulted all the available contemporary records in Spanish and English; none mentions that Sir Peter was black. I therefore can’t help concluding that the career of the mercenary Pedro Negro under king Henry VIII is quite irrelevant to the study of Othello. See Imtiaz Habib, Shakespeare and Race: Postcolonial Praxis in the Early Modern Period (Lanham: University Press of America, 2000), 128 ff.

(2.) For the confusion of the legal status of black Africans in England see Kenneth Little, Negroes in Britain. A Study of Racial Relations in English Society (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1972), 192-93. For the poll tax levied in the parish of All Hallows, Barking, Toward Ward, see W. E. Miller, “Negroes in Elizabethan London,” Notes and Queries Notes and Queries (originally subtitled “a medium of inter-communication for literary men, artists, antiquaries, genealogists, etc”) is a London-based, quarterly publication, part academic journal, part correspondence magazine, in which scholars and interested , n.s. 8 (April 1961): 138.

(3.) The view still prevails that black Africans were rarities in England until slaving reached its full development in the late seventeenth century. See William D. Phillips, Jr., Slavery from Roman Times to the Early Transatlantic Trade (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1985), 155.

(4.) For the expulsion edicts see James Walvin, Black and White: The Negro and English Society 1555-1945 (London: Allen Lane, The Penguin Press, 1973), 8-9; Carole Levin, The Reign of Elizabeth I (Basingstoke: Palgrave, 2002), chap. 6, 120-1, For the Portuguese complaints about the superfluity of slaves and alleged disruption of economic stability see A. C. de C.M. Saunders, A Social History of Black Slaves and Freedmen in Portugal 1441-1555 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Cambridge University Press (known colloquially as CUP) is a publisher given a Royal Charter by Henry VIII in 1534, and one of the two privileged presses (the other being Oxford University Press). , 1982), 48; and Didier Lahon, “Black African Slaves and Freedmen in Portugal during the Renaissance: Creating a New Pattern of Reality,” in Black Africans in Renaissance Europe, ed. T. F. Earle and K. J. P Lowe (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005), 261-79. For the issue of an immigrant coloured minority becoming the national scapegoat for an economic problem and Shakespeare’s ironic response to this issue through the figures of Launcelot and the Mooress in The Merchant of Venice see Kim F. Hall, “Reading What Isn’t There: ‘Black’ Studies in Early Modern England,” Stanford Humanities Review 3 (1993), 23-33.

(5.) Dona Catalina de Ribera is an extreme instance. On her death in 1505, she owned seventy-one slaves. See Alfonso Franco Silva, La esclavitud en Andalucia al termino de la edad media (Madrid: Pons, 1984), 145; Leonor de Guzman, duchess of Medina Sidonia, claimed thirty-three slaves in 1511. See Miguel-Angel Ladero Quesada, Los senores de Andalucia: Investigaciones sobre los nobles y senores en los siglos XIII a XV (Cadiz: Universidad de Cadiz, 1998), 252-53; Leonor de Aznar bought thirteen slaves on January 17, 1511 (Archivo Historico Provincial de Sevilla, legajo 3969).

(6.) For Lady Ralegh and Lady Clifford see Peter Fryer, Staying Power: The History of Black People in Britain (London: Pluto Press, 1984, rpt. 1992). Fryer makes the outdated statement that is was the privilege of titled and propertied prop·er·tied  
adj.
Owning land or securities as a principal source of revenue.

Adj. 1. propertied – owning land or securities as a principal source of revenue
property-owning  families to secure blacks as an exotic status symbol (p. 8). For Grace Robinson and John Morocco see Edward Scobie, Black Britannia: A Study of Blacks in Britain (Chicago: Johnson, 1972), 23. African musicians in the service of Tudor monarchs have been recorded by Africanist scholars. The “Blynd More,” one of the musicians in Leicester’s service in 1559, has not. See Simon Adams, ed., Household Accounts and Disbursement DISBURSEMENT. Literally, to take money out of a purse. Figuratively, to pay out money; to expend money; and sometimes it signifies to advance money.
2.  Books of Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester, 1558-61, 1584-86 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995).

(7.) The paucity of biographical records shedding light on the lived experience of ordinary black people has aroused the comment of James Walvin. Very little is known about black women and black family life in Britain. See James Walvin, “From the Fringes: The Emergence of British Black British black

see large black.  Historical Studies,” in Essays on the History of Blacks in Britain, ed. Jagdish S. Gundara and Ian Duffield (Aldershot: Avebury, 1992), 225-42.

(8.) See D. J. H. Clifford, ed., The Diaries of Lady Anne Clifford (Stroud: Alan Sutton, 1990), appendix 1. The Catalogue, I think, must have been drawn up by Edward Marsh, Lady Anne’s secretary.

(9.) D. J. H. Clifford, The Diaries, 53, 231, 234, 238, 241, 242, 244, 251, 254, 258, 264, 265.

(10.) For more information on the three black laundresses see Annemarie Jordan, “Images of Empire: Slaves in the Lisbon Household and the Court of Catherine of Austria,” in T. F. Earle, Black Africans in Renaissance Europe, chap. 7.

(11.) The other slaveowners listed as paying the same tax in the parish of All Hallows were Richard Woods, the owner of Mary; Oliver Skinner, the owner of Maria; and one Mr Mitons, obviously a Dutchman. See W.E. Miller, “Negroes in Elizabethan London,” Notes and Queries, n.s. 8 (1961): 138, and R. E. G. Kirk and Ernest P. Kirk, Returns of Aliens in the City and Suburbs of London, Publications of the Huguenot Society of London 10 (1907), pt. iii, 28, 54.

(12.) See Sara Mendelson and Patricia Crawford, Women in Early Modern England 1550-1720 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1998), 89, 106-7, who do not mention miscegenation.

(13.) For more detailed information on slave and slaveholder see Rosalyn L. Knutson, “A Caliban in St. Mildred Poultry,” 113, 120, 124.

(14.) Bodleian Library, MS. Ashmole 226, fol. 84v. A. L. Rowse in his study of The Case Books of Simon Forman: Sex and Society in Shakespeare’s Age (London: Picador, 1976) has ignored Polonia’s case. I have managed to read Forman’s hand but have failed to decipher his astrological shorthand. There is a cursory reference to this case in Imtiaz Habib’s article “Elizabethan Racial-Medical Psychology, Popular Drama, and the Social Programming of the Late-Tudor Black: Sketching an Exploratory Postcolonial Hypothesis,” in Disease, Diagnosis, and Cure on the Early Modern Stage, ed. Stephanie Moss and Kaara L. Peterson (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2004), 93-112.

(15.) See Barbara Howard Traister, The Notorious Astrological Physician of London. Works and Days Works and Days

long poem by Hesiod, considered a farmers’ almanac of ancient Greece. [Gk. Lit.: Benét, 1102]

See : Pastoralism  of Simon Forman (Chicago: University of Chicago Press The University of Chicago Press is the largest university press in the United States. It is operated by the University of Chicago and publishes a wide variety of academic titles, including The Chicago Manual of Style, dozens of academic journals, including , 2001), 64, 70.

(16.) Quotation from Ania Loomba, Shakespeare, Race and Colonization (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002), 28.

(17.) I owe this information to Dr. Lauren Kassell who has been so kind as to consult her microfilm of Forman’s case books. Dr. Kassell does not discuss Polonia’s case in her study Medicine and Magic in Elizabethan London. Simon Forman: Astrologer, Alchemist, Physician (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2005).

(18.) See Iris Origo, “The Domestic Enemy: The Eastern Slaves in Tuscony in the 14th and 15th Centuries,” Speculum 30 (1955), 321-66.

(19.) William Shakespeare, Pericles, The Arden Edition, ed. F. D. Hoeniger (London: Methuen, 1963), 4.2.13-16.

(20.) William Shakespeare, Romeo and Juliet Romeo and Juliet

star-crossed lovers die as teenagers. [Br. Lit.: Romeo and Juliet]

See : Death, Premature


Romeo and Juliet

archetypal star-crossed lovers. [Br. Lit. , The Oxford Shakespeare, ed. Jill L. Levenson (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000), 1.3.2-3. Juliet is fourteen years old.

(21.) William Shakespeare, The Merchant of Venice, The New Cambridge Shakespeare, ed. M. M. Mahood (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987), 3.5.30–35. For Launcelot’s role as go-between and advocate of religious, racial and sexual exchange see Steven R. Menth, “The Fiend Gives Friendly Counsel: Launcelot Gobbo and Polyglot pol·y·glot  
adj.
Speaking, writing, written in, or composed of several languages.

n.
1. A person having a speaking, reading, or writing knowledge of several languages.

2. Economics in The Merchant of Venice,” in Money and the Age of Shakespeare: Essays in New Economic Criticism, ed. Linda Woodbridge (Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan, 2003), 177-87. For Portia’s anxieties about miscegenation see my article on “Portia and the Prince of Morocco,” Shakespeare Studies 31 (2003): 89–126. Miscegenation was endemic among the servant class in Spain. See Ruth Pike, Aristocrats and Traders: Sevillian Society in the 16th Century (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1972), 188. It was on the increase in late Elizabethan London and in the Netherlands. The rudimentary bilingual word list Duyts-Guineets, appended to Pieter de Marees’ Beschryvinge ende historische verhael van het Gout gout, condition that manifests itself as recurrent attacks of acute arthritis, which may become chronic and deforming. It results from deposits of uric acid crystals in connective tissue or joints.  Koninckrijk van Gunea (Amsterdam, 1602), was challenging and novel in the sense that its language lessons conceived for the professional guidance of Dutch merchants in Guinea did not shy away from Verb 1. shy away from – avoid having to deal with some unpleasant task; “I shy away from this task”
avoid – stay clear from; keep away from; keep out of the way of someone or something; “Her former friends now avoid her”  raising the issue of sexual intercourse sexual intercourse
or coitus or copulation

Act in which the male reproductive organ enters the female reproductive tract (see reproductive system). , thus encourging the Dutch merchants, in conversational scraps, to pull down the racial and sexual barriers: “Give me a fine woman” and “Woman, do you want to sleep with me?” See the modern English translation Description and Historical Account of the Gold Kingdom of Guinea (1602), ed. Albert van Dantzig and Adam Jones (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1987), 246–59. The registers of St. Benet Fink St. Benet Fink was a church in the City of London located on what is now Threadneedle Street. Recorded since the 13th century, the church was destroyed in the Great Fire of 1666, then rebuilt by the office of Sir Christopher Wren. , London, record, on June 2, 1606, the christening of a boy born to a black woman. The father was supposed to be John Edwardes, a border in the house of William Connrador. See Rosalyn L. Knutson, “A Caliban in St. Mildred Poultry,” 113.

(22.) For William Winter’s career as a naval administrator see entry in the ODNB (2005); as a mercantile venturer exploiting the commecial resources of Guinea see John W. Blake, West Africa: Quest for God and Gold 1454–1578 (London: Curzon Press, 1977), 163-64, 172; Kenneth R. Andrews, Trade, Plunder TO PLUNDER. The capture of personal property on land by a public enemy, with a view of making it his own. The property so captured is called plunder. See Booty; Prize.  and Settlement. Maritime Enterprise and the Genesis of the British Empire, 1480–1630 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984, rpt. 1991), 105. The ODNB does not record Winter’s stake in the Guinea ventures.

(23.) Rosalyn L. Knutson, “A Caliban in St. Mildred Poultry,” 114-15. Sir William’s son, Edward, kept a black African working as his porter in Lydney, Gloucester shire, in the 1590s. Edward Winter dispossessed the African of his original identity, calling him his own under the name of Edward Swarthey. I owe this information to Miranda Kaufmann, Christ Church College, Oxford, who is working on “Africans in Britain 1500-1640.”

(24.) Kenneth R. Andrews in Trade, Plunder and Settlement, has argued that the possibility of English trade to Guinea returned in 1585 with the open outbreak of the Anglo-Spanish hostilities. The English slave trade, he noted, was not resumed until after 1650 (pp. 111/12). For the Portuguese members of Dom Antonio’s household in February 1585, see the inventory drawn up by one of Sir Francis Walsingham’s clerks and edited by E. M. Tenison, Elizabethan England, vol. 7 (Leamington Spa: 1940), 202-4. As a person of high rank Dom Antonio used to keep colored slaves in his household. Thus he brought from Tangiers, where he had been governor, the Muslim slave Antonio Luis, whom he kept to look after his stables in Portugal. See Jorge Fonseca, “Black Africans in Portugal during Cleynaert’s Visit 1533-1538,” ed. T.F. Earle and K. J. P Lowe, Black Africans in Europe, 113-21.

(25.) Thus he issued privateering letters and letters of marque letters of marque
pl.n.
1. A document issued by a nation allowing a private citizen to seize citizens or goods of another nation.

2. in 1582 and 1584. See Pauline Croft, “English Commerce with Spain and the Armada War, 1558-1603” and Simon Adams, “The Outbreak of the Elizabethan Naval War against the Spanish Empire: The Embargo of May 1585 and Sir Francis Drake’s West Indian Voyage,” both papers ed. M. J. Rodriguez-Salgado and Simon Adams, England, Spain and the Gran Armada, 1585-1604, 240 and 53, resp. For a financial memorandum Dom Antonio addressed to the English government in 1592 see E. M. Tenison, Elizabethan England, vol. 9, 165 ff, 269-75, 449ff.

(26.) For a short description of the two coasts see Jean Boulegue, Les anciens royaumes Wolof (Senegal), vol. I: Le Grand Jolof, XIIIe-XVIe siecle (Paris: Karthala, 1987), 124-29.

(27.) The documents concerning the renewal of the English Guinea trade in 1588 have been published by Mario Alberto Nunes Costa, “D. Antonio e o trato Ingles This article is about an American supermarket chain. For a town in Gran Canaria, see Playa del Inglés.

Ingles (NYSE: IMKTA) is a regional supermarket chain based in Asheville, North Carolina, where Robert “Bob” Ingle opened the first store in Asheville, NC in  da Guine (1587-1593), Boletim Cultural da Guine Portuguesa 8 (1953): 683-797. Nunes Costa has edited the material he found in the Portuguese National Archives, the Arquivo Nacional da Torre do Tombo The Arquivo Nacional da Torre do Tombo (English: National Archive of the Tower of the Tombo) is the Portuguese national archive established in 1378. It is located in Lisbon. External links

  • Official site

, but has not made use of the documents kept at the National Archives, at Kew, High Court of Admiralty, 24/59/28-51. The date 1587 as given by the Portuguese editor is in Old Style. The regulations of the charter provided that the proceedings from the sales of slaves, “qualquer dinheiro . . . de qualquer venda Venda (vĕnd`ə), former black “homeland” and nominal republic, NE South Africa. It comprised two connected areas near the Zimbabwe border in what is now Limpopo prov.  de escravos,” were to be inventoried. See the Portuguese text of the charter in Nunes Costa, document 4, pp. 711–17, resp.715-16. The English original text of the Guinea charter was published by Richard Hakluyt in The Principal Navigations, Viages and Discoveries of the English Nation (London, 1589), Hakluyt Society, Extra Series, no. 39, vol. 1 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1965), 240-42. Nunes Costa has edited the original French translation of the Guinea charter (see document 3). For a concise history of the Guinea charter see John Milner Gray, A History of Gambia (London: Frank Cass, 1966), chap. 3: “The arrival of the English in Gambia, 1588-1622;” William Robert Scott, The Constitution and Finances of English, Scottish, and Irish Joint-Stock Companies to 1720, 3 vols. (Cambridge, 1910-12), vol. 2, 10-14. The best informed English historian on the first Guinea Company is John William Blake. However, his study “English Trade with the Portuguese Empire in West Africa 1581–1629,” published in Quarto congreso do mundo portugues, vol. 4, t. 1 (Lisbon, 1940), 314–35, though meticulously researched, remains incomplete. Blake overlooked the important body of material which Nunes Costa was to recover from Portuguese archives. Blake’s article has been reedited by Jeremy Black in The Atlantic Slave Trade The Atlantic slave trade, also known as the Transatlantic slave trade, was the trade of African persons supplied to the colonies of the “New World” that occurred in and around the Atlantic Ocean. It lasted from the 16th century to the 19th century. : Origins-1600 (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2006), vol. 1, item 15.

(28.) Nunes Costa, document 43, pp. 776-78. A copy of the same document is also kept at the National Archives, at Kew, HCA 24/59/45-46. Evasion of duties was rampant among merchants and slavers operating on the upper Guinea coast. Under the Hispano-Portuguese regime the colony went through the golden years of trade in slaves and ivory. See Walter Rodney, “Portuguese Attempts at Monopoly on the Upper Guinea Coast, 1580-1650,” Journal of African History 6 (1965): 307-22.

(29.) Nunes Costa, documents 1, 37, 38.

(30.) Andre Alvares d’Almada, Tratado breve BREVE, practice. A writ in which the cause of action is briefly stated, hence its name. Fleta, lib. 2, c. 13, Sec. 25; Co. Lit. 73 b.
2. Writs are distributed into several classes. , dos rios de Guine do Cabo Verde (1594), ed. Antonio Brasio, Monumenta Misionaria, Africa Ocidental, 1570-1650, 5 vols. (Lisbon: Agencia Geral do Ultramar, 2a serie, 1958-79), vol. 3 (1964), 230-376, chap. 2, pp. 247ff. Richard Rainolds, “The voyage of Richard Rainolds and Thomas Dassel to the rivers of Senega sen·e·ga
n.
The dried roots of the Seneca snakeroot, used medicinally as an expectorant.


senega (seˑ·ni·g  and Gambra [sic] adjoyning upon Guinea, 1591, with a discourse of the treasons of certain of Don [sic] Antonio his servants and followers,” in Richard Hakluyt, The Principal Navigations, Traffiques and Discoveries of the English Nation (1598-1600), ed. with an Introduction by John Masefield, 8 vols. (London: J. M. Dent and Sons, 1927), vol. 5, 44-52.

(31.) To put it in terms of Alvares d’ Almada: “E o dia de eles receberem as pagas e entregarem as suas mercadorias, lhes dao os Ingleses em terra banquetes, com muita musica de violas de arco e outros instrumentos musicos. E por esta causa estao estes resgates de toda esta costa do Cabo Verde ate Rio de Gambia perdidos” (p. 251). For more information on the Luso-Africans see Walter Rodney, A History of the Upper Guinea Coast, 1545-1800 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1970), 74 ff; Jean Boulegue, Les Luso-Africains de Senegambie, xvi-xix siecles (Lisbon: Instituto de Investigacao Cientifica Tropical, 1989), 37-39; and the first chapters in Peter Mark, “Portuguese” Style and Luso-African Identity: Precolonial pre·co·lo·ni·al or pre-co·lo·ni·al
adj.
Of, relating to, or being the period of time before colonization of a region or territory.  Senegambia, SixteenthNineteenth Centuries (Bloomington: Indiana University Press Indiana University Press, also known as IU Press, is a publishing house at Indiana University that engages in academic publishing, specializing in the humanities and social sciences. It was founded in 1950. Its headquarters are located in Bloomington, Indiana. , 2002).

(32.) The relevant passage in Alvares d’ Almada reads: “e agora, depois de terem amizade com os Ingleses, foram ja alguns a Inglaterra aprender a lingua lingua /lin·gua/ (ling´gwah) pl. lin´guae [L.] tongue.lin´gual


lingua geogra´phica benign migratory glossitis.

lingua ni´gra black tongue.  Inglesa e ver a terra, por mandado do alcaide al·cai·de also al·cay·de
n.
The commander or governor of a fortress in Spain or Portugal.


[Spanish, from Arabic al-q de porto de Ale, que serve de veador da fazenda Fazenda is a Portuguese word for ‘farm’, but is used in the English language for the coffee estates that spread within the interior of Brazil between 1840 and 1896, which created major export commodities for Brazilian trade, but also led to intensification of slavery in Brazil.  de el-Rei” (p. 250). The earliest instance of five West Africans taken to England in order to be broken in as interpreters, in emulation of Portuguese practice to boost commercial relations, dates from 1555. See Peter Fryer, Staying Power, 5. The difference between the two events is that in 1555 the initiative was taken by the English, in 1592 obviously by the Africans.

(33.) See Rosalyn L. Knutson, “A Caliban in St. Mildred Poultry.”

(34.) See “The voyage of Richard Rainolds,” 46, 50, 51. The central theme of John Thornton’s incisive study Africa and Africans in the Making of the Atlantic World, 1400–1680 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998) is that “the Africans were active participants in the Atlantic world, both in African trade with Europe (including the slave trade) and as slaves in the New World” (p. 7). Slavery in Africa Slavery existed in Africa well before the Atlantic slave trade. There were several forms of slavery that existed in Africa. One is chattel slavery. Chattel slavery was the type of slavery practiced in the Americas during the time of the Trans Atlantic slave trade.  was endemic before the arrival of the Europeans; the Africans themselves were given to exporting slaves. As soon as the Portuguese abandoned their early strategy of raiding for commerce, exporting slaves took a dramatic turn upward (p. 95). It was African strength, not weakness, that became a key factor in shaping the transatlantic slave trade.

(35.) For Paul Banning’s career as a merchant and privateering magnate see Kenneth R. Andrews, Trade Plunder and Settlement, 98, 245-47, 251-52, 257, 261, 263; and T. S. Willan, “Some Aspects of English Trade with the Levant Levant (ləvănt`) [Ital.,=east], collective name for the countries of the eastern shore of the Mediterranean from Egypt to, and including, Turkey.  in the 16th Century,” The English Historical Review 70 (1955): 399-410.

(36.) The three black servants are listed in Irene Scouloudi, ed., Returns of Strangers in the Metropolis, 1593, 1627, 1635, 1639. A Study of an Active Minority, Proceedings of the Huguenot Society of London 16 (1937-41): 149. The christening of “Iulyane” has been retrieved by Rosalyn L. Knutson, “A Caliban in St. Mildred Poultry,” 113. For John Abel, one of Banning’s many retainers, who “purloined” [pounds sterling]70 from his wealthy master to squander squan·der  
tr.v. squan·dered, squan·der·ing, squan·ders
1. To spend wastefully or extravagantly; dissipate. See Synonyms at waste.

2. them on the maintenance of Mary Newborough see my article on “Prostitution in Late Elizabethan London: The Case of Mary Newborough,” Medieval and Renaissance Drama in England 15 (2003): 89-126, n. 74.

(37.) The groundwork for studying the Portuguese conversos in early modern England has been laid by Lucien Wolf in the “Jews in Elizabethan England,” Transactions of the Jewish Historical Society of England The Jewish Historical Society of England was founded in 1893 by several Anglo-Jewish scholars, including Lucien Wolf, who became the society’s first president. Early president of the JHSE included Hermann Adler, Joseph Jacobs, F. D. Mocatta, and Isidore Spielmann.  11 (1926): 1-91. For an overview of the Jewish presence see James Shapiro, Shakespeare and the Jews (New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of : Columbia University Press Columbia University Press is an academic press based in New York City and affiliated with Columbia University. It is currently directed by James D. Jordan (2004-present) and publishes titles in the humanities and sciences, including the fields of literary and cultural studies, , 1996), 68ff.

(38.) For a modern approach to defining converso identity see Miriam Bodian, ” ‘ Man of the Nation’: The Shaping of Converse Identity in Early Modern Europe The early modern period is a term used by historians to refer to the period in Western Europe and its first colonies which spans the two centuries between the Middle Ages and the Industrial Revolution. ,” Past and Present 143 (1994): 48-76; and Hebrews of the Portuguese Nation: Conversos and Community of Early Modern Amsterdam (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1997).

(39.) For the Antwerp Jews see Hans Pohl, “Die Portugiesen in Antwerp (1567-1648): zur Geschichte einer Minderheit,” Vierteljahrschrift fur Sozial- und Wirtschafts-geschichte 63 (1977): 1-439.

(40.) For Dr Nunes’s biography see the entry in the ODNB (2004), vol. 41, 274; and Lucien Wolf, “Jews in Elizabethan England,” 8-9, 23, 30, and appended documents. For the uncalendared Moroccan trade see my article on “Recovering a Black African’s Voice, in an English Lawsuit,” Medieval and Renaissance Drama in England 17 (2005): n. 38; and for the abortive abortive /abor·tive/ (ah-bor´tiv)
1. incompletely developed.

2. abortifacient (1).

3. cutting short the course of a disease.


a·bor·tive
adj.
1. Guinea voyage see John W. Blake, West Africa: Quest for God and Gold, 188. For his financial reverses see Charles Meyers and Edgar Samuel, “Debt in Elizabethan England: the Adventures of Dr Hector Nunez, Physician and Merchant,” Jewish Historical Studies 34 (1994-96): 125-40.

(41.) See Lucien Wolf, “Jews in Elizabethan England,” 8-9, 13. Gratia’s death is recorded by Rosalyn L. Knutson, “A Caliban in St. Mildred’s Poultry.” Knutson gives two burial dates, one is July 13, 1590 (p. 114), the other is September 13, 1591 (p. 115). For the role played by the Freire sisters within the international network of Jewish trade relations see Alan Stewart, “Portingale Women and Politics in Late Elizabethan London,” in Women and Politics in Early Modern England, 1450-1700, ed. James Daybell (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2004), chap. 5.

(42.) For the Alvarez household, which is said to have contained several black servants, and for the part played by Elizabeth Anegro see C. J. Sisson, “A Colony of Jews in Shakespeare’s London,” Essays and Studies 23 (1938): 38-51. Fernando Alvarez was a member of the Spanish Church of London and when it was disbanded in 1563, he joined the Italian Church under Girolamo Ferlito. See William McFadden, “The Life and Works of Antonio del Corro (1527-1591)” (PhD thesis, Faculty of Arts Historically the Faculty of Arts was one of the four traditional divisions of the teaching bodies of universities, the others being theology, law and medicine.[1] Nowadays it is a common name for the faculties teaching humanities. References

1.  of Queen’s University, Belfast, 1933), 2 vols, chap. 22; and Luigi Firpo, “La chiesa italiana di Londra nel cinquecento cin·que·cen·to  
n.
The 16th century, especially in Italian art and literature.


[Italian, from (mil) cinquecento, (one thousand) five hundred : cinque, five (from Latin  e i suoi rapporti con Ginevra,” in Ginevra e l’ Italia. Biblioteca Storica Sansoni, ed. Delio Cantimori et al. n.s., 34 (1959): 342.

(43.) The document has been unearthed and commented on by Rosalyn L. Knutson in “A Caliban in St. Mildred Poultry,” 116. Knutson has not realized that the misspelt name of the physician “Hector Novimeis” stands for Dr Nunes. Penal slavery did exist in early modern England under the anti-vagrancy and poor relief acts.

(44.) C. J. Sisson, “A Colony of Jews in Shakespeare’s London,” 38-51. Gondomar, the Spanish ambassador to the Jacobean court, was to allege that Dr Lopez had been innocent and unjustly executed. See the biographical entry of Dr Lopez in ODNB (2004).

(45.) On the earl of Essex’s secretaries and his patronage of Antonio Perez see Paul E. J. Hammer, “The Uses of Scholarship: The Secretariat of Robert Devereux, second Earl of Essex, ca. 1585-1601,” English Historical Review 109 (1994): 26-51, and The Polarisation of Elizabethan Politics. The Political Career of Robert Devereux, Second Earl of Essex, 1585-1597 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999). My article on the play is titled “An Unrecorded Elizabethan Performance of Titus Andronicus, ” Shakespeare Survey 14 (1961): 102-9.

(46.) John Guy, “The 1590s: The Second Reign of Elizabeth I?” ed. John Guy in The Reign of Queen Elizabeth I. Court and Culture in the Last Decade (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), 1-19.

(47.) The letters have been edited in Gustav Ungerer, A Spaniard in Elizabethan England: The Correspondence of Antonio Perez’s Exile (London: Tamesis Books Limited, 1 (1974), 2 (1976); see vol. i, nos. 41, 42, 44, 45, 48, 50. The visit to Cambridge has been uncovered by Paul Hammer in The Polarisation of Elizabethan Politics, 304.

(48.) Basadonna’s presence in London (1593-99) has been blotted out from Italian and English historiography. Some day I hope to write an essay on Basadonna’s embassy, his commercial and social activities, and his purchases of expensive vessels from London brokers. Basadonna was undoubtedly the best qualified Venetian in London to give an English author, such as Shakespeare, an insider’s account of Venice. He was in touch with John Byrd, brewer, of Southwark, and with Henry Stradling, draper, who in 1594 sold him three vessels, the Hopewell, the Elizabeth of London, alias the Golden Noble, of 240 tons, and the Bona Speranza, a “royally furnished ship,” of 280-300 tons, at a price of [pounds sterling]650. See my essay on “Prostitution in Late Elizabethan London: The Case of Mary Newborough,” Medieval and Renaissance Drama in England 15 (2003): 138-223, n. 71.

(49.) Richard Field had already some experience in publishing a Spanish/English language manual. In 1591, he had printed William Stepney’s The Spanish Schoole-master and between 1596 and 1600 he was to print several books of the Spanish reformer Cipriano de Valera Cipriano de Valera was the editor of the first major revision of the Spanish Bible translation of Casiodoro de Reina. First published in 1602, this version of the bible continues to be called the Reina-Valera, even after latter revisions.  under the imprint “En casa de Ricardo del Campo.” See Gustav Ungerer, “The Printing of Spanish Books in Elizabethan England, The Library, 5th ser. 20 (1965): 177-229.

The presence of Perez in London and the publication of his book under the pseudonym of Raphael Peregrino were reason enough for the Essexians to learn Spanish. In his instructions to Robert Naunton, Essex wrote that “to have Signor Perez willingly helpe yow yow  
interj.
Used to express alarm, pain, or surprise.  in the Spanishe yow must pretende to studye the tonge as well, be- cause it is hys, as for the excellencye of itselfe … If you will use an amplificacion, yow maye saye yow learne Spanishe to understande Raphael Peregrino’s booke as well as Bartas did Englishe to understande Sir Philip Sydney’s Arcadia.” See Hammer, The Polarisation of Elizabethan Politics, 310, n. 215.

(50.) A. L. Rowse, Shakespeare’s Globe. His Intellectual and Moral Outlook (London, 1981), 117.

(51.) William Shakespeare, Love’s Labour’s Lost, ed. G. R. Hibbard in The Oxford Shakespeare (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990), 1.1.161-75.

(52.) Tom Cain, “‘Comparisons and wounding flouts’: Love’s Labour’s Lost and the Tradition of Personal Satire,” ed. John Batcheler, Tom Cain, and Claire Lamont in Shakespearean Continuities: Essays in Honour of E. A. J. Honigmann (London: Macmillan, 1997), 193-205. Not Armado but the Spanish braggart Huanebango in George Peele’s play The Old Wives Tale (1593-94) is in part a parody of Gabriel Harvey’s style.

(53.) On the play’s similarity to the Inns of Court culture see Lynne Magnusson, “Scoff Power in Love’s Labour’s Lost and the Inns of Court Language in Context,” Shakespeare Survey 57 (2004): 196-208. On Francis Davison’s acquaintance with Perez, his obvious knowledge of Spanish and participation in the Gray’s Inn Revels of December 1594 see Gustav Ungerer, A Spaniard in Elizabethan England, i, 256-57.

(54.) For Perez’s famous collection of paintings see Gustav Ungerer, A Spaniard in Elizabethan England, i, 193.

(55.) I have addressed the issues raised by the performance of the Chamberlain’s Men in Rutland and those by the Christmas festivities sponsored by Sir John Harington in two separate papers. The first, dating from 1961, focuses on the identification of the London company of players (see note 45). The second deals with the social and economic dimensions of the Christmas festivities and with the great drain the financial resources of Sir John Harington which was caused by his ambitious life style. It was published by the Rutland Record Society under the title “Shakespeare In Rutland,” Rutland Record 7 (1987): 242-48. The original French text of Jacques Petit has been dropped by the editor and replaced by my English translations.

(56.) Jacques Petit’s letter containing the reference to Titus Andronicus can be read in the original French in the appendix to my 1961 essay and in a modern English version in Daphne du Maurier’s Golden Lads. A Study of Anthony Bacon, Francis and Their Friends (London: Victor Gollancz, 1975), 146-47. A team of record agents under the supervision of Mrs St. George Saunders has transcribed over three hundred original letters. The quality of the transcriptions is very uneven and occasionally quite inaccurate. See, for instance, A. Bacon’s letter in Golden Lads, p. 160, and my transcript in A Spaniard in Elizabethan England, i, 276-77.

(57.) Petit’s sonnet and lamentations can be read in A Spaniard in Elizabethan England, i, 238-40. While Petit immersed himself in effusions of second-rate farewell verses, the earl of Essex was constrained to borrow [pounds sterling]500 from the Dutch jeweler and stonecutter Peter van Lore in order to finance Perez’s return to Henry IV in Paris. (See my essay on “Prostitution in Late Elizabethan London,” n. 33). Medical tropes were fashionable in the Elizabethan age. When Thomas Platter, the physician from Basel, visited White Hall Palace in September 1599, he was ushered into a hall which jutted out over the Thames and which was crammed with emblematic devices. One of them in Latin hexameters praised the queen as the writer’s “medicine,” light, and fountain. See Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie (born 1929) is a noted French historian whose work is mainly focused upon Languedoc in the ancien regime, focusing on the history of the peasantry. He is a noted pioneer in the fields of history from below and microhistory. , ed., L’Europe de Thomas Platter: France, Angle-terre, Pays-Bas, 1500-1600. Le siecle des Platter III (Paris: Fayard, 2006), 362, n. 579.

(58.) See Andrew Hadfield, Shakespeare and Republicanism (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005), 165-67. Quentin Taylor, “‘To order well the state’: The Politics of Titus Andronicus,” Interpretation: A Journal of Political Philosophy 32 (2005): 125-50

(59.) Paul E. J. Hammer, The Polarisation of Elizabethan Politics, 168-69.

(60.) For Sir John’s relations with Leicester see Jan Broadway’s entry of Sir John in ODNB, vol. 25.

(61.) Accurate figures of black slaves in England are hard to come by. Further investigations into the mercantile and legal activities of the Guinea Company are bound to yield reliable figures. The year 1593 happens to be the year in which the mortality rate of black domestic servants in London was high. Four black servants are entered as having been buried in the parish of St Botolph Aldgate: Suzanna Pearis, servant to John Despinois, on August 8; Simon Valencia on August 20; Cassangoe, servant to Thomas Barbor, merchant, on October 8; and Robert, servant to William Matthew, gentleman, on November 29. See Rosalyn L. Knutson, “A Caliban in St. Mildred Poultry,” 113-14.

(62.) Glenn Odom and Bryan Reynolds, “Becomings Roman/Comings-to-be Villain: Pressurized pres·sur·ize  
tr.v. pres·sur·ized, pres·sur·iz·ing, pres·sur·iz·es
1. To maintain normal air pressure in (an enclosure, as an aircraft or submarine).

2. Belongings and the Coding of Ethnicity, Religion, and Nationality in Peele and Shakespeare’s Titus Andronicus,” ed. Bryan Reynolds, Transversal Enterprises in the Drama of Shakespeare and his Contemporaries. Fugitive Explorations (Houndmills: Palgrave/Macmillan, 2006), chap. 8. Francesca T. Royster, “White-Limed Walls: Whiteness and Gothic Extremism in Shakespeare’s Titus Andronicus,” Shakespeare Quarterly 51 (2000): 432-55.

(63.) William Shakespeare, Titus AndronIcus, The Arden Shakespeare, ed. Jonathan Bate (London: Routledge, 1995), 4.2.101-2. In his article on “Kind and Unkindness: Aaron in Titus Andronicus,” Brian Boyd holds the view that nowhere in the play does Shakespeare presume “that the blackness of race means vileness of character” (69). Boyd has edited his article in Words that Count. Essays on Early Modern Authorship in Honor of MacDonald P. Jackson (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 2004), 51-77. The governments of Bridewell Bridewell (brīd`wəl), area in London, England, between Fleet St. and the Thames River. The Bridewell house of correction, demolished in 1863, was on the site of a palace built under Henry VIII and given by Edward VI to the City of London in  have recorded a number of cases which disprove disprove,
v to refute or to prove false by affirmative evidence to the contrary.  that the fear of “naturall infection” was inhibitive. The taboo of sex between a white woman and a black man was repeatedly broken in the London brothels BROTHELS, crim. law. Bawdy-houses, the common habitations of prostitutes; such places have always been deemed common nuisances in the United States, and the keepers of them may be fined and imprisoned.
2. . Thus alone in 1577 Jane Thompson, obviously a prostitute, was detained in Bridewell for committing “whoredome” with “Anthonye, a blackmoreblackamore;” and Rose Brown for admitting “dyvers & many blackamores” as customers to her establishment; and Margery Williams confessed to the governors that she had sexual intercourse with Peter Peringoe, a “blackamore.” In 1604, the governors issued a warrant to arrest a London hatmaker “whoe had gott the blacke more with child.” See Duncan Salkeld’s review of Michael Neill’s edition of Shakespeare’ Othello in The Times Literary Supplement, August 18/25, 2006, p. 26. A thorough search for further evidence among the Bridewell Court Books is a desideratum. Were the black customers slaves or freedmen? Did these white prostitutes give rise to the fashion of deriding harlots as “dark ladies” which was in vogue among the Inns of Court sutdents in the 1580s and 1590s?

(64.) Quotation taken from Alexander Leggatt, Shakespeare’s Tragedies: Violation and Identity (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005), 15.

(65.) Ladislas Bugner, general ed., L’image du noir dans l’art occidental, vol. ii Des premiers siecles chretiens aux grandes decouvertes, ed. Jean Devisse and Michel Mollat, Les Africains dans l’ordonnance chretienne du monde n. 1. The world; a globe as an ensign of royalty.
Le beau monde
fashionable society. See Beau monde.
Demi monde
See Demimonde. , 14e-16eI4e–I6e siecle (Fri-bourg: Office du Livre li·vre  
n.
1. See Table at currency.

2. A money of account formerly used in France and originally worth a pound of silver. , 1979).

(66.) See Albert J. Loomie, S.J., The Spanish Elizabethans: The English Exiles at the Court of Philip II (New York: Fordham University Press The Fordham University Press is a publishing house, a division of Fordham University, that publishes primarily in the humanities and the social sciences. Fordham University Press was established in 1907 and is headquartered in the Canisius Hall building in the Rose Hill Campus of , 1963), 107; ODNB, vol. 53, under Suarez de Figueroa, Jane and Suarez de Figueroa, Gomez. Don Benito de Cisneros must have been a descendant of Don Benito Jimenez de Cisneros Jiménez de Cis·ne·ros   , Francisco 1436-1517.

Spanish prelate and political leader. The confessor of Isabella I, he imposed conversion to Christianity on the Moors of Granada, leading to an uprising (1499-1500), and was appointed grand inquisitor , nephew of Francisco Jimenez de Cisneros Noun 1. Francisco Jimenez de Cisneros – prelate who was the confessor of Isabella I and who was later appointed Grand Inquisitor (1436-1517)
Jimenez de Cisneros  (1436-1517), primate and regent of Spain, grand inquisitor INQUISITOR. A designation of sheriffs, coroners, super visum corporis, and the like, who have power to inquire into certain matters.
2. The name, of an officer, among ecclesiastics, who is authorized to inquire into heresies, and the like, and to punish them. , initiator of the mass conversion of the Moors, the guiding spirit behind the Spanish campaign in North Africa (1505-10), and patron of the Complutensian Polyglot Bible The Complutensian Polyglot Bible is the name given to the first printed polyglot of the entire Bible, initiated and financed by Cardinal Francisco Jimenez de Cisneros (1436-1517). . Bartholomew Yong (1560-1612), the son of a Roman Catholic family, known as translator of Jorge de Montemayor’s pastoral novel Diana, had “conference with the duchess of Feria” while he was touring Spain (1578-80). The subject of the conference remains unknown. See Dale B. J. Randall, The Golden Tapestry. A Critical Survey of Non-chivalric Spanish Fiction in English Translation, 1543-1657 (Durham: Duke University Press, 1963), 77ff. Yong may have been introduced to Sir Philip Sidney after he had completed his translation. See Judith M. Kennedy, A Critical Edition of Yong’s Translation of George of Montemayor’s Diana and Gil Polo’s Enamoured enamoured or US enamored
Adjective

enamoured of
a. in love with

b. very fond of and impressed by: he is not enamoured of Moscow [Latin amor love]  Diana (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1968), lix, n. 8. There is an entry on B. Yong in ODNB.

(67.) On Juan Latino’s classical literacy see Baltasar Fra-Molinero, “Juan Latino and His Racial Difference,” ed. T. F. Earle, Black Africans, chap. 15; on Diego Jimenez de Enciso’s seventeenth-century play on Juan Latino’s life and career see the same author, La imagen de los negros en el teatro del Siglo de Oro (Madrid: Siglo XXI, 1995), chap. 6; on Afonso Alvares see T. F. Earle, “Black Africans versus Jews: Religious and Racial Tension in a Portuguese Saint’s Play,” ed. T. F. Earle, Black Africans, chap. 16. Juan Latino’s work that stood the greatest chance of being known in sixteenth-century England and Scotland was his poem Austrias Carmen Carmen

throws over lover for another. [Fr. Lit.: Carmen; Fr. Opera: Bizet, Carmen, Westerman, 189–190]

See : Faithlessness


Carmen

the cards repeatedly spell her death. [Fr.  (1573), a panegyric panegyric

Eulogistic oration or laudatory discourse. The panegyric originally was a speech delivered at an ancient Greek general assembly (panegyris), such as the Olympic and Panathenaic festivals.  in hexameters praising don John of Austria John of Austria, 1545–78, Spanish admiral and general
John of Austria, 1545–78, Spanish admiral and general; illegitimate son of Holy Roman Emperor Charles V.  as victor of the battle of Lepanto in 1571, putting an end to the myth of Turkish naval invincibility. King James composed a poem on Lepanto about 1584. The British Library copy of Juan Latino’s panegyric, which has an accession stamp of 1872, has the following handwritten title page motto: “Satiabor cum apparuerit gloria tua 1573.” I owe this information to Dr Barry Taylor, Curator of the Hispanic Collections 1501-1850.

(68.) Winthrop Jordan, White Over Black: American Attitudes Towards the Negro, 1550-1812 (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press The University of North Carolina Press (or UNC Press), founded in 1922, is a university press that is part of the University of North Carolina. External link

  • University of North Carolina Press

, 1968, rept., New York, 1977), 6.

(69.) The findings of my investigations into the early history of English slavery will be published by Verbum, Madrid, in 2008.

(70.) Archivo Historico Provincial de Sevilla, Protocoles Notariales, legajo 3289, fol. 23 r-24 v; fol. 125 r-v; fol. 126 r-v. These records together with some others will be published in the appendix of the above mentioned study.

(71.) For Hakluyt’s “economic nationalism” shaping his editorial policy see Emily C. Bartels, “Imperialist Beginnings: Richard Hakluyt and the Construction of Africa,” Criticism 34 (1992): 517-38. For a discussion of Thorne’s document see Roger Barlow, A Brief Summe of Geographie, ed. E. G. R. Taylor, The Hakluyt Society, 2d ser., no. 59 (1931; Nendeln: Kraus Reprint, 1967), XXV ff. Hakluyt had no scruples about eliminating narratives, abridging materials, and excising records for political reasons. See James P. Helfers, “The Explorer or the Pilgrim? Modern Critical Opinion and the Editorial Methods of Richard Hakluyt and Samuel Purchas,” Studies in Philology phi·lol·o·gy  
n.
1. Literary study or classical scholarship.

2. See historical linguistics.


[Middle English philologie, from Latin philologia, love of learning 94 (1997): 160-86.

(72.) See David Loades’s entry on Sebastian Cabot in ODNB, vol. 9. For Cabot’s role as innovator and mediator in handing down to the English pilots his knowledge of mathematical navigation acquired as Spain’s pilot major see Eric H. Ash, Power, Knowledge and Expertise in Elizabethan England (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Johns Hopkins University, mainly at Baltimore, Md. Johns Hopkins in 1867 had a group of his associates incorporated as the trustees of a university and a hospital, endowing each with $3.5 million. Daniel C.  Press, 2004).

(73.) For the transmission of the Thorne papers see R. C. D. Baldwin, “Robert Thorne, the younger,” ODNB, vol. 54, p. 606; G. C. Moore Smith, The Family of Withypoll, Walthamstow Antiquarian an·ti·quar·i·an  
n.
One who studies, collects, or deals in antiquities.

adj.
1. Of or relating to antiquarians or to the study or collecting of antiquities.

2. Dealing in or having to do with old or rare books.  Society 34 (1936): 38.

(74.) Venice is a transposed trans·pose  
v. trans·posed, trans·pos·ing, trans·pos·es

v.tr.
1. To reverse or transfer the order or place of; interchange.

2. image of mercantile London, Shylock Shylock

shrewd, avaricious moneylender. [Br. Lit.: Merchant of Venice]

See : Usury  and Antonio operating as mirror images of Elizabethan society. Shylock, who is pressed by the court to forgive Antonio, claims the same rights to sell human flesh as the Venetian (English) merchants have and urges them to free their own slaves and grant them the rights of free subjects: “You have among you many a purchased slave, / Which, like your asses and your dogs and mules, / You use in abject and in slavish parts / Because you bought them. Shall I say to you, / ‘Let them be free! Marry them to your heirs! / Why sweat they under burdens?” Quoted from M. M. Mahood’s edn. of the play in The New Cambridge Shakespeare (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987), 4.1.90ff. There is evidence that some English contemporaries of Shakespeare, who were operating in the Mediterranean, were working hand in glove Adv. 1. hand in glove – in close cooperation; “they work hand in glove”
cooperatively, hand and glove  with the Venetian elite as purveyors of slaves. Thus, in 1594, the captain of the English vessell Susanna sold seven slaves to the “magnifico mag·nif·i·co  
n. pl. mag·nif·i·coes
1. A person of distinguished rank, importance, or appearance: “He is both an old-world and a new-world figure, a feudal magnifico and a modern technocrat”  Giovanni Maria Canevali, cittadino e mercante,” three men, three women, and a boy, all of them presumably Moors. See Alberto Tenenti, “Gli Sciavi di Venezia alla fine del Cinquecento,” Rivista Storica Italiana Founded in 1884 to serve as manifesto for the new scientific profession, Rivista Storica Italiana is among the world’s top academic reviews and by far the most authoritative historical journal in Italy.  67 (1955): 52-69.

COPYRIGHT 2008 Associated University Presses
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
« Previous Page — Next Page »

WPMU Theme pack by WPMU-DEV.