Forés @ UVPress






         Universitat de València PRESS -UVPress- weblog for research uses

March 18, 2012

05 Busting Mr. Daisey

Filed under: economía,future,módulo básico,politics & literature — fores @ 11:30 am
Opinion

Jack Shafer

Follow Jack Shafer

Busting Mr. Daisey

By Jack Shafer
March 16, 2012

This week, the highly regarded public radio show This American Life learned a lesson that many journalists, including me, have learned the hard way: It’s almost impossible for an editor to fact-check a contributor who lies.

The show, hosted by Ira Glass, just retracted its Jan. 6, 2012, episode, “Mr. Daisey Goes to the Apple Factory,” adapted from Mike Daisey’s popular one-man show, The Agony and the Ecstasy of Steve Jobs, which is about working conditions in a Chinese factory that makes Apple products.

Daisey’s deceptions were uncovered by Rob Schmitz, a China-based reporter for Marketplace. This American Life will air an hourlong explanation and re-examination this weekend, featuring both Glass and Daisey, about the circumstances behind the retraction. Glass and the show are to be commended for their quick response, and everybody who cares about real journalism owes a debt of gratitude to Schmitz.

We don’t yet know all the lies Daisey told Glass and the listeners of This American Life, but here’s a taste. In the Jan. 6 segment, Daisey said:

The problem is that n-hexane is a potent neurotoxin, and all these people have been exposed. Their hands shake uncontrollably. Most of them can’t even pick up a glass.

I talk to people whose joints in their hands have disintegrated from working on the line, doing the same motion hundreds and hundreds of thousands of times. It’s like carpal tunnel on a scale we can scarcely imagine. And you need to know that this is eminently avoidable. If these people were rotated monthly on their jobs, this would not happen.

When a doubting Schmitz contacted Daisey’s translator, he learned that the artist hadn’t talked to workers poisoned with hexane. We have now learned that he met people who knew people who had been poisoned. So why did he lie? Because, Daisey said, “I wanted to tell a story that captured the totality of my trip.”

On his own website, Daisey offers this larger rationalization, which deserves complete quotation.

I stand by my work. My show is a theatrical piece whose goal is to create a human connection between our gorgeous devices and the brutal circumstances from which they emerge. It uses a combination of fact, memoir, and dramatic license to tell its story, and I believe it does so with integrity. Certainly, the comprehensive investigations undertaken by the New York Times and a number of labor rights groups to document conditions in electronics manufacturing would seem to bear this out.

What I do is not journalism. The tools of the theater are not the same as the tools of journalism. For this reason, I regret that I allowed This American Life to air an excerpt from my monologue. This American Life is essentially a journalistic — not a theatrical — enterprise, and as such it operates under a different set of rules and expectations. But this is my only regret. I am proud that my work seems to have sparked a growing storm of attention and concern over the often appalling conditions under which many of the high-tech products we love so much are assembled in China.

This grander explanation, which invokes the liberties one can take with the truth working inside the theater, skirts the question of why he lied to Glass, who obviously trusted him to tell the truth. Daisey’s only stated “regret” here is that he allowed the program to air part of his monologue. Meanwhile, the New York Times has excised a paragraph from an Oct. 6, 2011, op-ed he wrote, because “Questions have been raised about the truth of a paragraph in the original version of this article that purported to talk about conditions at Apple’s factory in China.” As I write, surely others are scouring his book, 21 Dog Years: Doing Time @ Amazon.com (2002) for fabrications.

Perhaps Daisey will offer more complete contrition on This American Life‘s hair-shirt edition this weekend, but I doubt it. Liars come up with all sorts of justifications when caught. In Daisey’s case, he claims “dramatic license” gives him the right to lie to Glass. Other apprehended fibbers working in the journalistic arena have blamed booze, drugs, madness, overwork, bad fact-checking, notes got lost, wrong version got sent to the editor, or family problems.

I’m still waiting for somebody who got caught lying while practicing journalism to say why he did it. I have my theory: 1) They lie because they don’t have the time or talent to tell the truth, 2) they lie because they think they can get away with it, and 3) they lie because they have no respect for the audience they claim to want to enlighten. That would be an ideal subject for a one-man theatrical performance.

(Afterthought, March 17: If this piece interested you, allow me to direct you to my piece from earlier in the week about the fabulisms in Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood.)

******

Send scripts to Shafer.Reuters@gmail.com. My Twitter feed tells the truth. Sign up for email notifications of new Shafer columns (and other occasional announcements). Subscribe to this RSS feed for new Shafer columns and subscribe to this hand-built RSS feed for corrections to my column.

PHOTO: Mike Daisey appearing on MSNBC’s The Ed Show.

Mar 16, 2012
6:28 pm EDT

Mr. Shafer, please also bust NYT for their Apple Foxconn story.

Did you guys miss the NPR retraction of Mike Daisey Apple Foxconn story? It’s full of fabrication.

NYT never disclosed the fact their primary source, China Labor Watch, is a US government funded dissident group that is financially beholden to US foreign policy interest.

China Labor Watch’s financial connection with US Congress is open information. National Endowment for Democracy grant publication clearly states the grants given to CLW.

Posted by ChasL | Report as abusive
Mar 16, 2012
10:25 pm EDT

So what are the facts about the working conditions at Foxconn? Can Mr. Shafer contribute to the discussion?

Posted by Aretherefacts | Report as abusive
Mar 16, 2012
10:50 pm EDT

Daisey’s monologue may be “theatre” but he gave interviews where he wasn’t peforming, and he misled people in those interviews.

Posted by KenG_CA | Report as abusive
Mar 16, 2012
11:55 pm EDT

It is not the responsibility of the playwright to be factually accurate. To hold Mr. Daisey to the standards of someone like Stephen Glass at The New Republic is ludicrous. Journalistic standards do not and should not apply to theater. Almost no play would be left standing.

Many audience members and journalists have claimed that they were falsely led to perceive Mr. Daisey’s accounts as fact. Are plays now to be fact-checked and playwrights treated as journalists? Shall we exhume Shakespeare’s corpse, reanimate him and demand to know why he presented Richard III as hunchback when it wasn’t factually accurate?

This debacle has made it very clear that a great many people have utterly no idea what purpose the theater serves and what it is that we actually do. No wonder that funding for the arts in the United States is so appalling and the majority of our national theatrical output is swill.

Mr. Daisey has rightly pointed out that he is attempting to communicate the essential truth of the situation, which he has done in all of his work with great success. Any appearance/writing by a playwright in Op-Ed, television, radio, et al. should be viewed primarily as publicity for their play, not as journalism. Organizations like The New York Times and This American Life should note that if they want to fact-check a play, they should not cite the proverbial horse’s mouth as a source.

Complain all you like, but there’s blood on our hands. For example, I just typed this on my iMac.

Posted by SethDuerr | Report as abusive
Mar 17, 2012
12:24 am EDT

More hard evidence of America’s deteriorated democracy & and American media’s credibility.

Posted by GMavros | Report as abusive
Mar 17, 2012
5:01 am EDT

Limbaugh, Brietbart, Beck, Daisey? Oh heck, they’re just “entertainers”… nobody takes them seriously.

And I would laugh at what they, except for the blatant attempt to defraud people. And, mostly out of hatred.

Posted by nieldevi | Report as abusive
Mar 17, 2012
6:42 am EDT

We can’t wait to hear the Apple fanboys claim vindication…

We’ve been waiting for that other plump Mike, the Moore guy, whom we’re now going to start calling “Smart Mike” to distinguish him from this guy, to get on the Apple story like he did the Nike story. Because as much as he’s a self-promoter, he gets it right. And it’s a story that doesn’t need a break in momentum.

Watching Daisy stammer in the first part of his CNBC interview would have made any good detective a bit worried about his veracity. Live and learn. He’ll no doubt write a book about it next.

Posted by WeWereWallSt | Report as abusive
Mar 17, 2012
11:10 am EDT

Jack, your theory needs a fourth leg, though it doesn’t apply in the case of Daisey, since his story was pre-packaged. But more and more in these “narrative nonfiction” days, editors want a moral along with the pitch. It’s not enough to say, “I know there’s something there–let me figure it out.” Editors want conclusions before they’ll take a pitch, and the temptation for journalists is to offer those, then mash all unwieldy material into that frame. The urge to oversimplify and find a sermonizing arc is ultimately everyone’s fault, since readers and listeners reward these stories the most. And as we’ve seen from this piece and the Kony nightmare, those tendencies are worsened x10 when the story happens abroad.

Posted by Esmerelds | Report as abusive
Mar 17, 2012
1:11 pm EDT

@SethDuerr (and those making similar arguments): It’s true that a playwright is not obligated to be factually accurate when writing a play, but in this case Daisey wasn’t writing a play. He was adapting his play for This American Life, on which he was fully aware that it would be presented as the truth. Reading Daisey’s “apology” makes it sound like he just realized that This American Life was a journalism program and that its viewers understand everything on the show to be true (as in factually correct, not “true” as Daisey is accustomed to interpret the word).

But this isn’t the case, because Daisey lied to Ira Glass and the staff of TAL and actively sought to cover up the parts of his show that were fabrications. There is no excuse for this. I guess he sees this act as another part of his selfless, noble quest to right the wrongs in this world, but I can’t help but see it as the act of a immoral man who is more concerned with his own publicity than his own integrity or the reputation of Glass and TAL.

Daisey could have either told Glass that parts of his story weren’t entirely true, so TAL could have aired a disclaimer, or they could have modified his story to take out the untrue parts. Instead, he chose to lie. And now he’s only made it worse with his self-righteous, weaselly non-apology.

Posted by TheDollarGame | Report as abusive

March 17, 2012

05 Outlaw mountain men, extremists roam the Rockies


Aparentemente una noticia como cualquier otra en la que se cuenta la leyenda de los hombres libres  que sobreviven en las montanyas rocosas y que se enfrentan a la autoridad por su afan de ser libres y no someterse a ley alguna mas que la de la superviviencia. Heroes para algunos villanos para muchos. Pero leyendo entre lineas, inevitablemente, se insinua que alguno de   estos locos podria ser el futuro asesino del presidente Barack Obama, tal como Timothy McVeigh en 1995 se convirtio en el terrorista que mato con un atentado de bomba a 168 personas en Oklahoma City. El tambien se habia escondido de la autoridad en las rocosas y tuvo al FBI buscandole durante anyos. La historia se repite cuando interesa repetirla.



Outlaw mountain men, extremists roam the Rockies

By Laura Zuckerman
SALMON, Idaho | Fri Mar 16, 2012 1:14pm EDT
(Reuters) – One is a loner who has eluded capture on Utah’s rugged Cedar Mountain for five years. Another is hiding out in the mountain forests of western Montana, wanted for attempted murder.
They are extreme versions of the self-reliant, independent-thinking frontiersmen who have long roamed the American West.
From wanted criminals to the more eccentric “Phantom Pooper” or “Dugout Dick,” a wide range of outlaws and drifters live off the land in the rugged Rocky Mountains, folk heroes to the militia movement and a source of chagrin for law enforcement.
Among the more storied is Troy James Knapp, 44, a loner wanted for burglaries of resort cabins near Zion National Park in Utah. In his five years in the wild, he has lived off land so rugged the average visitor stocks his four-wheel drive with emergency supplies.
Legend about Knapp’s uncanny outdoor skills and hardiness has grown along with the thefts he is accused of committing – frequently of firearms – and the threats he has made against a local sheriff in the forested high country of southern Utah called Cedar Mountain.
The snowshoe-clad survivalist has out-maneuvered authorities in manhunts, one as recently as last month when a reported sighting of a rifle-toting figure sent police in camouflage and bullet-proof vests pouring into the woods on foot and by air.
Knapp is one of a number of fugitives thought to be holed up in the vast back country of the Rocky Mountains, a region where self-sufficiency is almost a religion and separatist and militia movements have found fertile ground.
The forbidding mountainscape has given rise to characters such as 19th century trapper and explorer Kit Carson, and has acted as a magnet for modern-day mountain men and outlaws such as Claude Dallas.
Dallas was convicted in 1982 of manslaughter in the slayings of two Idaho game wardens investigating him for poaching while living off the canyon lands of southwestern Idaho.
After the killings, Dallas fled into the wilderness and eluded police for months. During his time on the run, he gained cult status among anti-government militiamen and was portrayed in a popular ballad as a renegade hero.
FOLK HERO OR CRIMINAL?
Aided by survival skills a U.S. marshal has likened to those of American frontiersman Davy Crockett, Knapp and a handful of other back country drifters are folkloric figures to fiercely anti-authority loners and groups of the American West, and their hostility seems to center on law enforcement officials.
In Cedar Mountain, the specter of an armed loner who may harbor extremist views has stoked fear among seasonal residents and vacation homeowners from Las Vegas.
“This guy is not a folk hero, he’s a dangerous criminal,” said Jud Hendrickson, whose family getaway property straddles the area where Knapp is known to roam. “People are going to get hurt before this is over.”
Authorities say break-ins mostly occur in winter, when the frigid weather and deep snow drive Knapp indoors in search of food, equipment and guns.
Those weapons have reappeared in what Iron County, Utah, Detective Sergeant Jody Edwards calls “doomsday stashes” in camps Knapp erects deep in the woods in mild weather.
Knapp runs trap lines, shoots squirrels and has trekked across hundreds of miles of harsh terrain. He is uninterested in valuables many thieves would prize, said Michael Wingert, supervisory deputy for the U.S. Marshals Service in Utah.
“If a cabin owner left a gold brooch on the table, he probably wouldn’t touch it,” Wingert said. “Outside of reading about Davy Crockett, I can’t tell you the last time I’ve encountered a case like this.”
In Montana, authorities are following up on hundreds of tips on the whereabouts of former militia leader David Burgert, 48.
Burgert is wanted on attempted murder charges for a shootout with Missoula County deputies in June, when authorities say he fired a handgun at officers before escaping into the tangled back country of western Montana.
Missoula County Undersheriff Mike Dominick said Burgert, sentenced in 2004 to seven years in federal prison on weapons charges, is a survivalist able to fend for himself in the wilds.
“He’s in desperate circumstances and we believe him to be a particular problem for local law enforcement. His animosity is directed at us,” Dominick said.
OPEN SPACES
The challenge in the wide-open spaces of the western United States is telling the difference between harmless hermits and recluses – and dangerous sociopaths. While the behavior of eccentrics in the western hinterlands may be objectionable, it isn’t usually criminal, authorities said.
Police in Idaho have grappled with the socially unacceptable behavior of individuals like the “Phantom Pooper,” who defecated on properties in the Frank Church River of No Return Wilderness.
Then there’s “Dugout Dick,” a squatter on public lands who irrigated his asparagus crop with urine, and rented out caves he carved into the rocky outcroppings above the Salmon River.
“There are plenty of people with anti-social behavior out there who never really bother anybody,” said Tony Latham, a retired Idaho Fish and Game investigator.
The Southern Poverty Law Center released a report on March 8 showing a sharp rise in anti-government groups between 2010 and 2011. The report came after an FBI warning in February that extremists opposed to the central government pose a growing threat to local law enforcement.
Such “sovereign citizens” were mostly known for filing arcane lawsuits against government officials, refusing to pay taxes and displaying phony license plates before May 2010, when two Arkansas police officers were gunned down during a traffic stop of a member of the movement.
“That was a wake-up call for everybody,” said Don Robinson, FBI supervisory special agent in Idaho.
Police are the preferred targets, said Mark Potok, senior fellow at the Southern Poverty Law Center.
Extremists espouse a patchwork of beliefs where one conspiracy about the government overlaps another, Potok said, and the worry is knowing when “today’s eccentric becomes tomorrow’s building bomber.”
Militias movements tend to come in waves, like that which spiked in 1995 when Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh killed 168 people. A second wave of separatist activism began in early 2009 after the election of an African-American president with a foreign-sounding name.
The rebirth of fringe movements may also be linked to the economic downturn, fears that Democratic leaders will impose new restrictions on guns and ultra-right rhetoric in the media, he said.
The FBI’s Robinson said what concerns authorities most is the “lone offender,” the under-the-radar extremist who suddenly surfaces in an act of spectacular violence.
Police also worry about what they call the “time bomb,” the sometime offender whose potential for violence escalates over time. That’s how Edwards, the Utah detective, views Knapp, who recently pledged to put a neighboring sheriff “in the ground” in a note left behind at a burgled cabin.
“We have a dangerous situation on our hands,” Edwards said.
(Editing by Steve Gorman, Daniel Trotta and Todd Eastham)

Outlaw mountain men, extremists roam the Rockies

inShareShare this
EmailPrintRelated TopicsU.S. »Lifestyle »

By Laura ZuckermanSALMON, Idaho | Fri Mar 16, 2012 1:14pm EDT(Reuters) – One is a loner who has eluded capture on Utah’s rugged Cedar Mountain for five years. Another is hiding out in the mountain forests of western Montana, wanted for attempted murder.
They are extreme versions of the self-reliant, independent-thinking frontiersmen who have long roamed the American West.
From wanted criminals to the more eccentric “Phantom Pooper” or “Dugout Dick,” a wide range of outlaws and drifters live off the land in the rugged Rocky Mountains, folk heroes to the militia movement and a source of chagrin for law enforcement.
Among the more storied is Troy James Knapp, 44, a loner wanted for burglaries of resort cabins near Zion National Park in Utah. In his five years in the wild, he has lived off land so rugged the average visitor stocks his four-wheel drive with emergency supplies.
Legend about Knapp’s uncanny outdoor skills and hardiness has grown along with the thefts he is accused of committing – frequently of firearms – and the threats he has made against a local sheriff in the forested high country of southern Utah called Cedar Mountain.
The snowshoe-clad survivalist has out-maneuvered authorities in manhunts, one as recently as last month when a reported sighting of a rifle-toting figure sent police in camouflage and bullet-proof vests pouring into the woods on foot and by air.
Knapp is one of a number of fugitives thought to be holed up in the vast back country of the Rocky Mountains, a region where self-sufficiency is almost a religion and separatist and militia movements have found fertile ground.
The forbidding mountainscape has given rise to characters such as 19th century trapper and explorer Kit Carson, and has acted as a magnet for modern-day mountain men and outlaws such as Claude Dallas.
Dallas was convicted in 1982 of manslaughter in the slayings of two Idaho game wardens investigating him for poaching while living off the canyon lands of southwestern Idaho.
After the killings, Dallas fled into the wilderness and eluded police for months. During his time on the run, he gained cult status among anti-government militiamen and was portrayed in a popular ballad as a renegade hero.
FOLK HERO OR CRIMINAL?
Aided by survival skills a U.S. marshal has likened to those of American frontiersman Davy Crockett, Knapp and a handful of other back country drifters are folkloric figures to fiercely anti-authority loners and groups of the American West, and their hostility seems to center on law enforcement officials.
In Cedar Mountain, the specter of an armed loner who may harbor extremist views has stoked fear among seasonal residents and vacation homeowners from Las Vegas.
“This guy is not a folk hero, he’s a dangerous criminal,” said Jud Hendrickson, whose family getaway property straddles the area where Knapp is known to roam. “People are going to get hurt before this is over.”
Authorities say break-ins mostly occur in winter, when the frigid weather and deep snow drive Knapp indoors in search of food, equipment and guns.
Those weapons have reappeared in what Iron County, Utah, Detective Sergeant Jody Edwards calls “doomsday stashes” in camps Knapp erects deep in the woods in mild weather.
Knapp runs trap lines, shoots squirrels and has trekked across hundreds of miles of harsh terrain. He is uninterested in valuables many thieves would prize, said Michael Wingert, supervisory deputy for the U.S. Marshals Service in Utah.
“If a cabin owner left a gold brooch on the table, he probably wouldn’t touch it,” Wingert said. “Outside of reading about Davy Crockett, I can’t tell you the last time I’ve encountered a case like this.”
In Montana, authorities are following up on hundreds of tips on the whereabouts of former militia leader David Burgert, 48.
Burgert is wanted on attempted murder charges for a shootout with Missoula County deputies in June, when authorities say he fired a handgun at officers before escaping into the tangled back country of western Montana.
Missoula County Undersheriff Mike Dominick said Burgert, sentenced in 2004 to seven years in federal prison on weapons charges, is a survivalist able to fend for himself in the wilds.
“He’s in desperate circumstances and we believe him to be a particular problem for local law enforcement. His animosity is directed at us,” Dominick said.
OPEN SPACES
The challenge in the wide-open spaces of the western United States is telling the difference between harmless hermits and recluses – and dangerous sociopaths. While the behavior of eccentrics in the western hinterlands may be objectionable, it isn’t usually criminal, authorities said.
Police in Idaho have grappled with the socially unacceptable behavior of individuals like the “Phantom Pooper,” who defecated on properties in the Frank Church River of No Return Wilderness.
Then there’s “Dugout Dick,” a squatter on public lands who irrigated his asparagus crop with urine, and rented out caves he carved into the rocky outcroppings above the Salmon River.
“There are plenty of people with anti-social behavior out there who never really bother anybody,” said Tony Latham, a retired Idaho Fish and Game investigator.
The Southern Poverty Law Center released a report on March 8 showing a sharp rise in anti-government groups between 2010 and 2011. The report came after an FBI warning in February that extremists opposed to the central government pose a growing threat to local law enforcement.
Such “sovereign citizens” were mostly known for filing arcane lawsuits against government officials, refusing to pay taxes and displaying phony license plates before May 2010, when two Arkansas police officers were gunned down during a traffic stop of a member of the movement.
“That was a wake-up call for everybody,” said Don Robinson, FBI supervisory special agent in Idaho.
Police are the preferred targets, said Mark Potok, senior fellow at the Southern Poverty Law Center.
Extremists espouse a patchwork of beliefs where one conspiracy about the government overlaps another, Potok said, and the worry is knowing when “today’s eccentric becomes tomorrow’s building bomber.”
Militias movements tend to come in waves, like that which spiked in 1995 when Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh killed 168 people. A second wave of separatist activism began in early 2009 after the election of an African-American president with a foreign-sounding name.
The rebirth of fringe movements may also be linked to the economic downturn, fears that Democratic leaders will impose new restrictions on guns and ultra-right rhetoric in the media, he said.
The FBI’s Robinson said what concerns authorities most is the “lone offender,” the under-the-radar extremist who suddenly surfaces in an act of spectacular violence.
Police also worry about what they call the “time bomb,” the sometime offender whose potential for violence escalates over time. That’s how Edwards, the Utah detective, views Knapp, who recently pledged to put a neighboring sheriff “in the ground” in a note left behind at a burgled cabin.
“We have a dangerous situation on our hands,” Edwards said.
(Editing by Steve Gorman, Daniel Trotta and Todd Eastham)


05 El Pujol más valenciano

Filed under: módulo básico — fores @ 12:08 am


Sorprendente, ni un solo comentario por ninguno de los lectores del Levante.

De repente, se hizo el silencio y todos enmudecieron.

El Pujol más valenciano


El expresidente asegura en sus memorias que siempre situó la “unidad lingüística” en el eje de sus prioridades políticas y negoció con Aznar el respeto a la lengua a cambio de su apoyo – Lamenta que no se consolidara el eje euromediterráneo


JOSÉ SIERRA Jordi Pujol (Barcelona, 1930) acaba de publicar el tercer volumen de sus memorias: De la bonança a un repte nou (1993-2011) en el que reitera su «visión» de una eurorregión mediterránea con la Comunitat Valenciana y con Murcia. A lo largo de 300 páginas publicadas por la editorial Proa, desvela sus inquietudes, sus estrategias, admite equivocaciones políticas —pocas y entre ellas destaca su apoyo al trasvase del Ebro—, desnuda a algunos políticos españoles en activo y, por lo que a nosotros se refiere, desvela cómo Eduardo Zaplana apoyó «la unidad de la lengua» tras un encuentro secreto en Tarragona.

En un periodo en el que la lengua comenzó a ser objeto de debate, Pujol prácticamente abre sus memorias relatando una conversación informal con el valenciano Francisco Tomás y Valiente, por entonces presidente del Tribunal Supremo, en la que éste le transmitió su convicción de que el asunto «de más trascendencia» sobre el que se tenía que pronunciar el Alto Tribunal era el recurso contra la inmersión lingüística y no, como se apuntaba entonces desde el PSOE, el recurso de Ruiz Mateos contra la intervención del Estado en sus empresas.

Pujol valora «la actitud» de Francisco Tomás y Valiente y «el prestigio, la libertad y la sensibilidad» de aquel Tribunal Supremo cuyo presidente le reconoció que la decisión sobre el catalán tenía «muchísima trascendencia y no sólo para el día a día político, sino para la estructura del Estado y el concepto de España» que la sentencia sobre el caso Rumasa. «¡Qué diferencia entre esta actitud y la chapucería jurídica y la politización barriobajera que ha imperado en el recurso contra el Estatut de Cataluña de 2005!», concluye Pujol.

Las memorias del presidente de la Generalitat de Catalunya incluyen en esta entrega opiniones, a veces descarnadas, sobre otros políticos con los que el estadista catalán tuvo relaciones. En varias ocasiones equipara la psicología y los comportamientos de Aznar, incluso los de Zapatero, «aunque con matices», añade, con el de «los nuevos ricos».

Pujol explica que, tras el triunfo electoral del PP en 1996 por mayoría relativa, Aznar se ve obligado a negociar con CiU. El punto 7 de sus notas o exigencias, según se mire —compuestas por nueve epígrafes— plantea que el Gobierno del PP «nos asegure» que «en el País Valenciano el PP respetará la unidad de la lengua—independientemente del nombre de la lengua valenciana— y la política de normalización».

«Vaig deixar clar també que una de les condicions del suport era que s´havia de resoldre definitivament i bé el fals problema de la unitat lingüística del català, discutida pel PP de València», explica el influyente político.
Pujol exige garantías a Aznar sobre este asunto y añade que antes de dar un paso para el acuerdo de Gobierno con el PP en 1996 «hemos de estar bien seguros de que la unidad lingüística será respetada».

Respeto por lo valenciano
«Para situar las cosas —añade Pujol en sus memorias— quiero recordar que durante todos mis años de gobierno he procurado no interferir en la política del País Valenciano. No utilicé nunca el término Països Catalans, que había usado alguna vez de joven. En cambio, sí que me mantuve siempre muy firme en la unidad lingüística del catalán y en todo aquello que pudiera representar una acción cultural conjunta». «Aznar —revela Pujol— me dijo que estaba de acuerdo y me indicó que hablara directamente con Eduardo Zaplana (…) que él hablaría también con el president de la Generalitat Valenciana, pero que debíamos de ser nosotros dos los que deberíamos encontrar una solución».
La entrevista entre ambos líderes políticos tuvo lugar el 8 de abril de 1996. Se celebró, «sin publicidad» en el Mas Calbó, entre Reus y Salou y donde en el siglo XI había nacido San Bernat Calbó.

Zaplana, según la versión de Pujol recogida en sus notas del encuentro, aceptó la propuesta. El presidente se muestra satisfecho por ello en sus memorias y escribe que «aunque con dificultades, el acuerdo lingüístico se cumplió, sobre todo a través de la Academia Valenciana de la Lengua».

Juntos contra el centralismo
Pujol analiza en sus memorias la importancia y el futuro de lo que denomina el tráfico euroasiático de mercancías y la lucha desatada en los puertos del Mediterráneo —italianos, franceses y españoles— para captarlo a través de Génova, Marsella, Barcelona, Tarragona, Valencia, Algeciras y «quizá» Tánger. «La importancia que atribuíamos al puerto —el de Barcelona— ayuda a entender por qué teníamos tanto interés en que el AVE llegara y no sólo para viajeros, sino también para mercancías», explica.

Se muestra convencido de la importancia de la «fachada mediterránea» desde sus tiempos de estudiante y revela cómo «en mi época en Banca Catalana me ocupé bastante de uno de nuestros bancos filiales, el de Alicante, y conocí el País Valenciano desde un punto de vista económico y empresarial».

«Es un país muy potente y muy abierto al mundo (…) Después me he hecho muy de mirar estadísticas y estudios económicos. No me hacen falta muchas, de todos modos, para saber que Cataluña y Valencia, con Murcia, constituyen la zona mas exportadora de España y no sólo de productos agrarios, sino también industriales. A parte de ser una potencia turística». «¿Cómo es posible entonces que hasta los años setenta no hubiera una buena carretera entre Valencia y Barcelona y, de hecho, entre Valencia y Francia? ¿O que todavía haya más de un centenar de kilómetros de ferrocarril entre Castelló y Tarragona de vía única? ¿ O que el AVE entre Valencia y Cataluña haya quedado muy a la cola de los proyectos ferroviarios españoles?», se interroga Pujol. Y cita a Germà Bel y su conocido ensayo España, capital París.

«El centralismo español —suscribe Pujol citando a Bel— es político, es administrativo, es económico y lo es en lo referente a comunicaciones, con todas las carreteras y las líneas ferroviarias principales con el kilómetro cero en Madrid. Es así desde el siglo XVIII, y ahora lo es de una manera muy acentuada. Se quiere evitar la creación de un conglomerado económico y también político potente en el Mediterráneo. Desde el centro se quiere impedir que se mantenga viva la relación económica y cultural entre Valencia y Cataluña».

«Más de una vez, políticos españoles, especialmente madrileños, han dicho bien claramente que no había prisa para enlazar bien Valencia y Cataluña (…) Con el AVE han llevado esto al extremo. Un tren va de Madrid a Valencia, sube hasta Castelló y allí se para . Un tren va de Madrid a Tarragona y este punto no enlaza con el de Castelló. Sería absurdo —concluye—, si no hubiera detrás un proyecto político y de estructuración del Estado bien definido».

Y reflexiona: «Los valencianos han de pensar que el perjuicio es más grave para ellos que para Cataluña. Nuestra industria y los puertos de Tarragona y Barcelona ya disponen de un AVE que partir de 2012 los conectará con Francia y Europa Central, también para las mercancías. Pero todos ganaríamos si de la fachada mediterránea española sacáramos todo el jugo que se puede obtener».


El gran fracaso del trasvase del Ebro



J. S. ­
En sus memorias, Pujol analiza en detalle todo lo ocurrido con el trasvase del Ebro y revela que el fracaso del proyecto y la gran oposición que provocó en las tierras de Cataluña le llevó a cuestionar incluso su capacidad para la política. Tras reconocer que apoyó expresamente y sin dudas el trasvase del Ebro para Cataluña, Comunitat Valenciana, Murcia y Andalucía, dice que ha hablado con técnicos americanos —probablemente los mismos que cada trimestre invitaba el Govern de la Generalitat Valenciana— que «me han recordado que los grandes trasvases que en los años treinta y cuarenta se hicieron entre los ríos Sacramento y Colorado y California, son el origen de la prosperidad de este estado norteamericano (…) Y añadían: “Ahora no se podrían hacer; la población lo impediría”. Yo lo supe demasiado tarde». «No supe calibrar la reacción contraria que el plan hidrológico provocaría. No fue un error técnico. Fue político y sociológico».
La oposición al trasvase caló hondo en Pujol. «En este punto debo preguntarme si sirvo para hacer política», escribe. Lo dice quien ha sido presidente de Cataluña 23 años y lo explica: «El PHN que presentaba el PP hizo depertar en mi el reflejo de la solidaridad con Castelló, Valencia, Alacant, Murcia y Almería (…) Me pregunto , viendo cómo se han desarrollado las cosas, si mi convicción no es señal de una candidez que un político no se puede permitir». «Después de haber pensado que el trasvase podía beneficiar a Valencia, Murcia y una parte de Andalucía, todavía he tenido que oír que estas tierras se quedaban sin agua tras el fracaso del Plan Hidrológico “por culpa de los catalanes” —en castellano en el original catalán—. En los diarios de Valencia, añade, también he leído artículos en la misma dirección».
Le molesta que nadie hable de la oposición de los aragoneses en todo el episodio, «que ha sido la más radical», y desvela que Marcelino Iglesias, expresidente de Aragón, le reconoció que «al menos hasta Castelló habría que desviar entre 100 y 200 hectómetros cubicos anuales». «Puede que algún día se haga» este trasvase a Castelló, concluye, y afirma que el problema no será principalmente un problema de agua, sino de la manera de hacer política.




March 16, 2012

05 For Romney, a campaign shaped by Bush allies


For Romney, a campaign shaped by Bush allies

By Samuel P. Jacobs
WASHINGTON | Thu Mar 15, 2012 6:53pm EDT
(Reuters) – In November 2010, supporters of George W. Bush gathered on a college campus in Dallas, Texas, to mark the groundbreaking of Bush’s presidential library.
Among those in the invitation-only crowd – which included former Vice President Dick Cheney, former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, a former Colombian president and singer Wayne Newton – was Mitt Romney.
Romney’s visit to Dallas to celebrate the former Republican president, one who left office historically unpopular, was a hint of how he would build his campaign to be the next Republican president: with the Bush crowd surrounding him.
From policy advisers to campaign strategists, more than two dozen veterans of the Bush administration have flocked to Romney’s campaign.
Their key roles contrast with Romney’s rhetoric on the stump. The former Massachusetts governor has tried to cast himself as a Washington “outsider,” largely avoided mentioning Bush’s tenure and made a point of criticizing several programs at the heart of Bush’s legacy.
Among Romney’s favorite targets: the No Child Left Behind program, which ties schools’ federal funding to assessment testing of students. Bush lauded it as a breakthrough to improve student achievement; Romney and many of the conservative voters he is courting say it gives the federal government too much authority in local school systems.
Some Bush loyalists are rankled by such attacks on their old boss, particularly from another Republican.
“I think a lot of the attacks on President Bush are gratuitous and disingenuous, and frankly a lot of them are flat-out wrong,” said Tony Fratto, a former Bush press aide who is now a Washington, D.C., consultant.
But most of those joining Romney’s team seem to have a more pragmatic view. Some note that Romney has supported measures such as No Child Left Behind in the past, and has taken a more conservative posture in this campaign.
Privately, they believe that however anti-Bush the chatter gets during the campaign, Romney is the Republican most likely to defeat Democratic President Barack Obama in the November 6 election – and that a Romney presidency could have a look much like Bush’s presidency.
Romney’s campaign is “a restoration of the Bush establishment,” said former Bush speechwriter Matt Lattimer, who is not supporting Romney. Bush loyalists “all want to be back in power again, and Romney’s the best bet.”
Romney campaign spokeswoman Andrea Saul said Romney “is honored to have the advice and counsel of so many individuals who have served at the highest levels of government. He fields their opinions, evaluates them and ultimately makes his own decisions.”
AWKWARD MOMENTS ON THE TRAIL
Several of the people who helped Bush win two terms in the White House are guiding Romney’s campaign.
Romney’s chief political strategists, Russ Schriefer and Stuart Stevens, are veterans of both Bush-Cheney campaigns. Romney campaign adviser Kevin Madden was a spokesman for the Bush-Cheney effort in 2004, then was a spokesman for Bush’s Justice Department.
Romney’s economic advisers include Glenn Hubbard, architect of the Bush-era tax cuts as chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers and now dean of the Columbia University Graduate School of Business. He’s joined by Harvard’s N. Gregory Mankiw, author of a popular economics textbook and Bush’s primary economic adviser from 2003 to 2005.
Romney has named 24 “special advisers” in national security and foreign policy, 16 of whom served in diplomatic or political roles under Bush. They include Michael Chertoff, the former homeland security chief, and Dan Senor, who was an administration spokesman in Iraq.
On judicial issues, Romney is advised by at least three top veterans of Bush’s Justice Department.
Romney’s education advisers include Margaret Spellings, who was secretary of education under Bush and a chief advocate for No Child Left Behind. Spellings has not commented on Romney’s opposition to the program.
Like Spellings, several Bush veterans are siding with Romney even as he continues to essentially run against chunks of Bush’s record. On the campaign trail, that disconnect has created some awkward moments.
In Detroit, Romney condemned the federal government’s $81 billion bailout of the auto industry, which was initiated by the Bush administration.
In Florida, Romney dressed down rival Newt Gingrich because the former U.S. House of Representatives speaker had supported a prescription drug benefit for Medicare, the government health insurance program for the elderly. The Bush administration favored such a benefit.
And in Arizona, Romney criticized another Republican candidate, former Pennsylvania Senator Rick Santorum, for favoring No Child Left Behind and increases in the government’s debt ceiling that Bush also endorsed.
At one rally, Romney blasted Santorum’s debt-ceiling vote while standing beside Ohio Senator Rob Portman, who repeatedly has voted for debt-ceiling increases while in the House and Senate.
Portman was Bush’s budget chief from 2006 to 2007, a period in which Bush also supported increasing the debt limit.
Romney’s tough talk on illegal immigration appears to have raised concerns in the Bush family itself.
In January, the New York Times reported that Jeb Bush, a former Florida governor and a brother of the former president, had urged Romney to tone down his message, fearing that Romney risked alienating Hispanics, a growing voting bloc that the Bush brothers have tried to attract to the Republican Party.
Although he is not happy with criticism of the Bush era by other Republicans, Fratto is among the Bush veterans who praise Romney for putting together a Bush-influenced team stacked with people who have experience in Washington. “You want people with experience and talent, and those guys have all that,” said Fratto. “They’ve been inside. They’ve worked on real policy.”
Obama’s campaign already is signaling that if Romney wins the Republican nomination, the presence of so many members of the Bush-Cheney administration on Romney’s team will be an issue in the fall campaign.
Bush’s approval rating, battered by an unpopular war in Iraq, growing deficits and a troubled economy, was at 22 percent when he left office, according to a CBS News/New York Times poll in February 2009.
“It’s no surprise that Mitt Romney’s reckless foreign policy and failed economic philosophy look familiar,” said Obama campaign spokeswoman Lis Smith. “He has surrounded himself with the same people who already helped bring us these disastrous policies.”
‘WE’RE OUT OF POLITICS’
George W. Bush has stayed mum on the Republican contest.
“We’re out of politics, as George would say,” former first lady Laura Bush recently told an audience in Florida.
However, some of Romney’s most enthusiastic cheerleaders come from Bush’s inner circle.

Rival campaigns complain that Karl Rove, Bush’s lead strategist, has turned his prominent media perch into a position to attack Romney’s challengers.

Last week, Bush’s mother, Barbara, a former first lady, called for a quick end to the bruising Republican primary battle to improve Romney’s chances of being elected in November.
Their enthusiasm for Romney may be rooted in the respect he has shown Bush’s administration in choosing his advisers, some leading Republicans said.
As a leading contender for president, “you have the choice of every adviser in the world,” said Houston venture capitalist Fred Zeidman, a Bush friend and Romney fundraiser.
Romney “picked the people who had been advising Bush and raising money for Bush because I think they have been consistent with the way he wants to run the country and what he believes.”
(Editing by David Lindsey and Eric Beech)

March 15, 2012

05 How the Assad emails came to light

De nuevo, otro ejemplo de la literatura convertida en un elemento mas de la politica.

How the Assad emails came to light

Syrian activists say a scrap of paper from a government worker gave them a window into the ruling couple’s lives

and 

Bashar al-Assad and his wife, Asma, whose personal email addresses and passwords are thought to have been leaked by a government worker. Photograph: Benainous/Hounsfield/Gamma-Rapho via Getty Images

In late March last year, Syrian opposition activists say, a young government worker in Damascus nervously handed a scrap of paper to a friend. On it were four handwritten codes that the friend was instructed to pass to a small group of exiled Syrians who would know what to do with them.

The paper contained two email addresses: sam@alshahba.com and ak@alshahba.com. They are thought to have been the personal email usernames and passwords of the president, Bashar al-Assad, and his wife, Asma.

For the next nine months they were to offer a cell of activists an extraordinary window into what appeared to be the private lives ofSyria‘s first family and their attempts to turn around the country’s steady descent towards the abyss.

In June – three months later than the original mole had intended – the email details found their way to two Syrian professionals in a Gulf state. Both had recently become active in the nascent opposition movement in exile after spending most of their adult lives as silent opponents of the regime.

The uprising in the southern Syrian city of Deraa on 15 March had empowered them, as it had hundreds of thousands of others in the totalitarian state. They were now determined to do what they could to bring an end to more than four decades of rule by the Assad clan.

“It was clear who we were dealing with,” said one of the activists. “This was the president and his wife. There was no doubt.”

At first, the activists say, the emails came in slowly, one or two a day to each account. Assad, as could be expected, was busying himself with affairs of state. His wife was occupied with family life – and shopping.

By the end of the summer, they say, the email traffic to the inboxes had markedly increased. In Assad’s case, this coincided with the increase in violence that followed the end of the Muslim fasting month of Ramadan, which last year fell in August.

As 2011 ground on, the situation deteriorated in many parts of Syria. By autumn, Assad had assembled a team of advisers who would help him with the international press and give frank reckonings about sensitive subjects, including the blazing insurgency that had taken hold in Homs and the views of Syria’s allies, Iran and Hezbollah.

The media advisers were Sheherazad Jaafari, the daughter of Syria’s envoy to the United Nations, Bashar Jaafari, and Hadeel al-Ali, a young Syrian woman studying at a US university.

Both flew to Damascus to advise Assad personally. They demonstrated their contacts in the US by passing on details of conversations with executives from the New York Times, NBC and ABC, all of whom had shown an interest in interviewing the Syrian president.

The two women became regular fixtures in the sam@alshahba.com inbox, with both of them using email addresses that they had used to communicate with journalists and editors.

The activists intensified their efforts as Assad cracked down, monitoring the email accounts 24 hours a day from the comfort of their living rooms.

Some days it was slow going, but the activists were kept enthused by the hope that morsels might arrive that would give them intelligence for use in the field or, better still, help them oust the most impenetrable regime in the Middle East.

They soon noticed differences in the way the couple used their email accounts. “We had to be quick with Bashar’s emails,” one of the activists said. “He would delete most as soon as they arrived in his inbox, whereas his wife wouldn’t. So as soon as they went from unread to read we had to get them fast.”

Deleting emails as soon as they arrive shows a degree of awareness of web security. So too did the fact that Assad never attached his name or initials to any of the emails he sent. However, many of the emails that arrived in his inbox are addressed to him as president and contain intimate details of events and discussions that were not known outside of the inner sanctum and would have been very difficult to manipulate.

“We were watching everything closely,” the activist said. When Assad was notified about the presence of western journalists in Homs, they were able to warn opposition activists there.

By mid-December, the correspondence to Assad’s inbox had become increasingly interesting. There were notes for an election speech he was due to deliver, daily world media briefings, glowing tributes from acolytes and constant chatter from his media advisers. But the devastating revelation that the activists had all been hoping for continued to elude them.

“There was no 800-pound gorilla,” one said. “But the body of evidence was still very strong.”

In January came the Anonymous leaks: a group of hackers had accessed the Syrian ministry of public affairs website and trawled through more than 80 email addresses stored on the ministry’s server. It is suspected that this leak spread the two usernames and password details beyond the small group of activists who were monitoring them. Somehow, someone searching through the ministry’s emails was able to establish that the Sam email belonged to the president.

On 7 February, a threatening email in Arabic was sent to the Sam email address. Traffic to the account stopped on the same day. And so did the extraordinary ability to monitor the inner sanctum in real time.

“Now we just want to show the world what this regime is like,” said the activist. “We just want him to go.”



« Previous Page — Next Page »

WPMU Theme pack by WPMU-DEV.