Forés @ UVPress






         Universitat de València PRESS -UVPress- weblog for research uses

May 14, 2010

01 China’s School Killings and Social Despair

Filed under: future,política — fores @ 12:59 pm
Tags: , ,



May 13, 2010, 7:04 pm

<!– — Updated: 7:21 pm –>

China’s School Killings and Social Despair

By THE EDITORS

China's schoolchildren
Mark, via European Pressphoto Agency A security guard escorted children out of a school in Shenyang, Liaoning Province, on May 13.

For the past two months, Chinese authorities have been trying to deal with a string of vicious attacks on young children in rural elementary schools. They have clamped down on news coverage, citing fears of copycat crimes and called for heightened school security. But on May 12, a man stormed a village school in Shaanxi Province and hacked to death seven children and two adults. It was the fifth attack since March, all involving middle-aged men using knives, cleavers or tools. Seventeen people have been killed and nearly 100 wounded in the attacks.

Some commentators say these attacks are symptoms of extreme stress in a rapidly changing society, an undercurrent which the government has failed to recognize. Though the cases may differ, is there a broader context for these attacks?


The Attacks’ Political Significance

Xueguang Zhou

Xueguang Zhou is a professor of sociology and a senior fellow at Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies at Stanford University. He is currently in Beijing teaching at the Stanford-in-Beijing program.

Details about the school attacks remain to be sorted out — whether these school attacks are isolated or copycat acts; whether they are triggered by mental illness or based on some malicious motives. But one thing is clear: these incidents are reflective of widespread and rapidly rising social anxieties, frustrations and tensions in the Chinese society today.

These acts put intense pressure on the fragile trust between the government and various social quarters.

At one level, such tensions are almost inevitable in a rapidly changing society. China today is experiencing social transformation at a scale and speed that its long history has rarely witnessed.

Large-scale and, in many cases, forced urbanization is carried out through migration, land seizure and residential relocation in both rural and urban areas. Alarming social inequality has become a naked fact that individuals experience in everyday life. In particular, housing prices have skyrocketed in large cities, increasing three or four times in as many years, creating a profound divide between those haves and those have-nots.

Strolling on the streets in Beijing or other large cities, you can glimpse those gated residential areas, with security guards, electronic cards and well-maintained walking paths and green areas within the high walls that separate the well-to-dos from the noise and crowds in the rest of city.

Read more…

Yet a new college graduate, even with a decent job in a large city, can hardly hope to own a home in his or her lifetime, given soaring housing prices. This is a far cry from the earlier reform era when reform policies, especially that of returning lands to peasant families, led to a great increase in productivity and benefited a large proportion of the population.

The traditional social fabric of family-based social support and neighborhood mutual assistance cannot cope with the rise in social dislocation, social closure and the marginalization of certain groups.

Desperation and resentment now run deep. Sociologists use “anomie” to describe the breakdown of social norms and values, and the school attacks are likely to be eruptions from these growing tensions.

At another level, what is really troubling is the way the Chinese government handles such conflicts. It has been trying hard to “contain” symptoms of social disruption, instead of cultivating mechanisms to diffuse them. The bureaucratic machine — often efficient, remote, impersonal and ruthless — has often engendered as much social resentment as it has resolved.

China’s transformation will depend on how these tensions and conflicts are sorted out. Incidents like the school attacks have far-reaching political implications in a politicized society like China. These acts, though isolated and incidental, tend to acquire political significance, putting intense pressure on central and local governments and on the fragile trust between the government and various social quarters.

A Chinese adage, which refers to the people as “water” and the ruler as a “boat,” puts it: “while water can carry a boat, it can also overturn it.” The Chinese leadership, mindful of this dynamic, is in a process of rolling out a series of social welfare programs — minimum living standard safety net, old-age support and health care — which aim to cover a larger and disadvantaged population.

But in the absence of new mechanisms to encourage local problem-solving capacities, how effective these public programs will be in diffusing social tensions remains to be seen.


The Death of Innocents

Guobin Yang

Guobin Yang is an associate professor in the Department of Asian and Middle Eastern Cultures at Barnard College and author of “The Power of the Internet in China: Citizen Activism Online.”

The close sequence of these attacks (five in less than two months!) seems to lend support to the theory that these are copycat crimes. Others suspect that the killers suffered from mental illness. Still others point to the lack of safety valves in a controlled society.

The attacks reveal a deep crisis in community, which has long been a source of stability in Chinese society.

Individual motivations may vary, but there are common underlying causes. These attacks are only the most explosive and brutal symptoms of an increasingly sullen and contentious society. Here are some other symptoms:

— A growing number of mass protests (8,700 in 1993, 87,000 by 2005) mostly targeting government authorities.

— Increasing number of violent attacks against government authorities, like burning police vehicles and government buildings.

— Desperate individuals resorting to self-immolation as a means of protesting forced relocation and the lack of legal channels for seeking justice.

— Rampant corruption of government officials being exposed daily in online forums and blogs.

WPMU Theme pack by WPMU-DEV.